Match The Feat

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
But....it's a planet. So sure, it could be a small planet.....but by it's very definition, it's planet size.

Like dogs can be small or large dogs. Some cats (tigers, for example) are larger than dogs.

But a Chihuahua is still dog sized. Because it's a fricking dog lol.

How are you so stupid lmao.

Btw: Pluto is a dwarf planet. Just an fyi. That object Superman destroyed was NOT called a dwarf planet. So at the very least, we can say it was bigger than Pluto 🙂

Personally I have no problem with acknowledging that the feat is impressive, but I don'y know why so many people(not you) have suddenly flipped their stance on planets. Not knowing how big a planet is, how dense a planet is, etc. are all things that Supes's fans have been questioning to no end for years before Supes's springboard in an effort to downplay the feats of other characters...

Nyone on that list could prolly do it

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Planets come in many sizes.

Pluto was considered one, too.

This is as stupid as saying 'Cap America (or any other character) is as strong as 10 men' then saying 'Oh, men come in all sizes, so let's assume they're all 10 sick men, or 10 midgets, or 10 sick old midgets with no arms' or some stupidity.

Let's lowball Phildo's comics, and use RL logic.

https://www.quora.com/Which-is-the-average-planet-size-in-the-universe-approx

This is the average size of planets in the Universe:

See that? There's a peak at around 2.4/2.5 times Earth size.

So lowballing, with RL science, we get 2.4 times the size of Earth. Using lowballig, with comics, we get about 5x the size of Earth.

At the very least, we can get to Earth size.

Originally posted by Philosophía
The planet was so massive/dense, that Superman couldn't reach escape velocity even when he first step foot in there.

By comparison, on Earth, even young 'Golden Age' Supes easily does it:

The planet was made by a Multiversal being to not let him [and countless other Supermen] escape. Suffice to say, it is created to be far above any planet in our solar system - since even Jupiter only has about 5 times Earth's escape velocity:

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Nyone on that list could prolly do it

Originally posted by darthgoober
Yeah but it's not being called a dwarf planet doesn't actually mean too much. When they're talking about Martinex the on panel narration(at least in general) says he's from the planet Pluto, not the dwarf planet Pluto.

Personally I have no problem with acknowledging that the feat is impressive, but I don'y know why so many people(not you) have suddenly flipped their stance on planets. Not knowing how big a planet is, how dense a planet is, etc. are all things that Supes's fans have been questioning to no end for years before Supes's springboard in an effort to downplay the feats of other characters...

Originally posted by Philosophía
The planet was so massive/dense, that Superman couldn't reach escape velocity even when he first step foot in there.

By comparison, on Earth, even young 'Golden Age' Supes easily does it:

The planet was made by a Multiversal being to not let him [and countless other Supermen] escape. Suffice to say, it is created to be far above any planet in our solar system - since even Jupiter only has about 5 times Earth's escape velocity:

Just world breaker

Originally posted by abhilegend
Anyone? Prove it.

Oh wait.. Surfer's here..? Not sure about him.

Other than him, everyone on the list had had some ridiculous showing of strength and durability. Wouldn't be surprised if they do something similar

Originally posted by carver9
It was? How massive was the planet Superman damaged?

- if it was smaller than that it wouldn't be called a planet but e.g. an ASTEROID (the thing Hulk destroyed was an asteroid)

- if it was larger than that it would be called e.g. a star, dwarf star or neutron star, depending on its properties.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
But....it's a planet. So sure, it could be a small planet.....but by it's very definition, it's planet size.

Like dogs can be small or large dogs. Some cats (tigers, for example) are larger than dogs.

But a Chihuahua is still dog sized. Because it's a fricking dog lol.

How are you so stupid lmao.

Btw: Pluto is a dwarf planet. Just an fyi. That object Superman destroyed was NOT called a dwarf planet. So at the very least, we can say it was bigger than Pluto 🙂

Kid, calm down. Anyways, the size of that small looking planet is unknown. There's no taking away from this. We do not know the density or anything of said planet. Looking at the panels, it looks extremely small. Blame the artist, not me.

You guys realize that World Forger doesn't want Superman to ever escape that world because he believes Superman's existence in the mainstream reality will ultimately bring about the end of ALL existence, right? You realize that he created the entire galaxy Superman is currently stuck in, and positioned all the planets/stars within it accordingly, just to make the 'prison planet' as inescapable as he possibly could, right?

But here we are, arguing that this fully multiversal, hyper-dimensional entity...the being who literally created all physical bodies in the DC multiverse(ie. World Forger)...must've just created a dwarf, hollow, and overall fragile planetoid to trap Superman on here, despite being intimately familiar with everything Superman represents on a fundamental level...cuz reasons?

Lol. This 'logic' will never cease to amuse me. 🙂

Originally posted by Magnon
The mass of the PLANET Superman DESTROYED was somewhere between 0.03 to 6000 Earth masses, because:

- if it was smaller than that it wouldn't be called a planet but e.g. an ASTEROID (the thing Hulk destroyed was an asteroid)

- if it was larger than that it would be called e.g. a star, dwarf star or neutron star, depending on its properties.

Are you sure? Can you show the inside of the planet not being hollow? Example, the planet Bills destroyed is clearly in every perspective a planet by looking at it....

https://static1.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11120/111202308/5199437-1.jpg

Can you show me the same?

Originally posted by Galan007
You guys realize that World Forger doesn't want Superman to ever escape that world because he believes that Superman's existence in the mainstream reality will ultimately bring about the end of ALL existence, right? You realize that he created the entire galaxy Superman is stuck in, and positioned all the planets/stars within it accordingly, just to make the 'prison' as inescapable as he possibly could, right?
[b]
...But here were are arguing that this fully multiversal, hyper-dimensional entity -- the being who literally created everything in the DC multiverse(World Forger) must've just created a dwarf, hollow, and overall fragile planetoid for Superman to stay trapped in for some reason, despite being intimately familiar with everything Superman represents on a fundamental level.

This logic will never cease to be amusing to me. 🙂 [/B]

edit: right above this post, Carver is arguing the planet is hollow.

I legitimately can't believe some people are in the same species.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Using what..? Breaking planet feats? Jumping?

Oh wait.. Surfer's here..? Not sure about him.

Other than him, everyone on the list had had some ridiculous showing of strength and durability. Wouldn't be surprised if they do something similar

Originally posted by carver9
Kid, calm down. Anyways, the size of that small looking planet is unknown. There's no taking away from this. We do not know the density or anything of said planet. Looking at the panels, it looks extremely small. Blame the artist, not me.

So we all agree it's planet sized? Step by step little Carver 🙂

We've at least moved on from your first statement on this subject lmao.

Galan, my only argument against that is this

The WF created this galaxy, not because he fearsome Superman’s power to directly defeat him. Rather, it’s Superman’s ability to inspire others to do good, to be just, and “good”. The WF knows that Superman will get the league, and potentially Batman on his side and defeat the WF (or his plans). Remember, his power it to make dreams and thoughts a reality, Batman is fueling that right now. When asked by Batman, the WF did admit that the main Superman can potentially get out of the prison.

Anyways, the feat it self is freakin amazing.
Dude can barely fly and managed to break the planet by lift off. Insane

^ That's not really an argument against what I was saying.

Seems like we both agree that the planet/galaxy World Forger created to trap Superman in, was designed with the sole intent of making this 'prison' as inescapable as possible. Therefore it is absolutely idiotic to try and pretend like the planet was made out of paper mache or some shit.

Originally posted by Galan007
You guys realize that World Forger doesn't want Superman to ever escape that world because he believes Superman's existence in the mainstream reality will ultimately bring about the end of ALL existence, right? You realize that he created the entire galaxy Superman is currently stuck in, and positioned all the planets/stars within it accordingly, just to make the 'prison planet' as inescapable as he possibly could, right?

But here we are, arguing that this fully multiversal, hyper-dimensional entity...the being who literally created all physical bodies in the DC multiverse(ie. World Forger)...must've just created a dwarf, hollow, and overall fragile planetoid to trap Superman on here, despite being intimately familiar with everything Superman represents on a fundamental level...cuz reasons?

Lol. This 'logic' will never cease to amuse me. 🙂

He also pointed Superman in another direction that had food, etc... for him. He asked Superman to go the other way vs jumping to the light and Superman declined it. That planet wasnt meant for him to remain on, it was a starting point for him.

Also, when I posted this...

Abhi declined it because of this dimension being connected to a door. He said that since we see a pathway that takes us (directed at ABHI) through this dimension, everything within it must be small. Why are you accepting this showing ABHI even though a doorway was used to get here?

Originally posted by carver9
That planet wasnt meant for him to remain on, it was a starting point for him.

World Forger absolutely did NOT want Superman to escape from that planet. Ever.

Originally posted by Galan007
Proof that you've not read the issues right here.

World Forger absolutely did NOT want Superman to escape from that planet. Ever.

Who said anything about leaving? Here he tells Superman there is a cosmic garden on the other side with for you with food, etc...

https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/41202023/Screenshot_20190527-153216_Chrome.jpg.html

Maybe I'm reading this wrong but he is telling Superman that he have what he needs there but NOT where his friends are at.