Rebirth Superman vs Immortal Hulk

Started by DarkSaint8513 pages
Originally posted by TheHulkster
I don't see where Superman says that he was buried underground for that length of time. There is no indication of how long DD is in space and how long he is buried. The context indicates that Superman is referencing the time of DD's death.

It crashed to earth...

But THAT was hundreds of thousands of years ago!!

I took 'That' to mean the crashing.

Superman BFR's him with one punch and it's over. The same foes for any incarnation of the Hulk. He can't fly. Take that off though, and it's a fight.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
It crashed to earth...

But THAT was hundreds of thousands of years ago!!

I took 'That' to mean the crashing.

But he followed up with "he was dead". So the reference seems to be one of him being dead hundreds of thousands years ago. Krypton is 27 light years away. How long would it take DD to drift to Earth?

Originally posted by Stoic
Superman BFR's him with one punch and it's over. The same foes for any incarnation of the Hulk. He can't fly. Take that off though, and it's a fight.

Pretty much.

Just like his "fight" with Lobo ended in the L.E.G.I.O.N. crossover, by simply dropping Lobo into the ocean.

"Oh, you can't swim? Guess you're not as good as I thought."

"I'm a bounty hunter! Not a wimpy rescue team!"

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Exactly two panels. Plus DD had been roaming Earth and kicking butt for nearly two days. He simply readjusts his effort after the no-sell, which is what Hulk does against Vision.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
I don't see where Superman says that he was buried underground for that length of time. There is no indication of how long DD is in space and how long he is buried. The context indicates that Superman is referencing the time of DD's death.

I think DD is massively overrated hype machine by forum standards(I've clashed with plenty over it in fact), but you're reading stuff wrong. DD wasn't running rampant for days, his total time out of the ground all seemed to take place on the same day(on Earth I mean).

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Hulk crushes Vision far easier than Iron Man's effort. Your lowballing relates to a single no-sell whereas Vision accomplishes this by going full density. Does the Vision/WM being use Vision's power to go full density and fail to no-sell Iron Man?

Haha, Vision is now more powerful than Vision+Wonder Man.

😂

Originally posted by TheHulkster
But he followed up with "he was dead". So the reference seems to be one of him being dead hundreds of thousands years ago. Krypton is 27 light years away. How long would it take DD to drift to Earth?
he crash landed on earth and was buried for hundreds of thousand of years ago. What does that have to do with being a drift in space? For the record his last documented encounter in DOS before earth was against Radiant and it wasn’t on Krypton. So I don’t know where you’re trying to go with this?

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Where do you get this from?

From his history.

Hulk is established as one who holds back.

Immortal Hulk? Where?

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Abhi as always does a great job making Hulk look better than Superman.

Just like you make Spider-Man look better than Wolverine.

Originally posted by carver9
Your post doesnt make sense and under the same scene you're talking about, they were screaming out "dont kill him yet. Save some for me"...

https://postimg.cc/64XxJmzQ

They wasnt going for the kill.


😂

"Save some for me" is now equal to "they were holding back". Why would he ask them to "Don't kill him, save some for me" If they weren't trying to kill him?

Is English your second language?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Just like you make Spider-Man look better than Wolverine.

😆

Originally posted by darthgoober
I think DD is massively overrated hype machine by forum standards(I've clashed with plenty over it in fact), but you're reading stuff wrong. DD wasn't running rampant for days, his total time out of the ground all seemed to take place on the same day(on Earth I mean).

Well, in looking at the story, he comes out of the ground during daylight and we later see him rampaging at what appears to be night. Then again during daylight.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Well, in looking at the story, he comes out of the ground during daylight and we later see him rampaging at what appears to be night. Then again during daylight.

When do we see him rampaging at night? If I've simply forgotten then that's my bad, but I don't personally remember night passing at any point in that whole arc.

Is there anywhere where it is stated that DD is underground for hundreds of thousands of years?

Does it matter? Underground or not, Doomsday was still sealed inside the box/tomb, devoid of any solar nourishment for all that time.

Originally posted by Galan007
Does it matter? Underground or not, Doomsday was still sealed inside the box/tomb, devoid of any solar nourishment for all that time.

A box does not devoid you of solar radiation and there is solar radiation throughout space.

Tell me, if DD is underground for hundreds of thousands of years devoid of sunlight, where did the sudden energy come from for him to escape?

Originally posted by darthgoober
When do we see him rampaging at night? If I've simply forgotten then that's my bad, but I don't personally remember night passing at any point in that whole arc.

To me, this scene appears to be at night?

https://imgur.com/a/B2BWS1n

Originally posted by TheHulkster
A box does not devoid you of solar radiation and there is solar radiation throughout space.
So do you have any actual proof that solar radiation penetrated all the way through the thick tomb(and shroud) Doomsday was encased in, and was secretly nourishing him while the tomb was hurling through space, or are you just making baseless assumptions? Be honest.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Tell me, if DD is underground for hundreds of thousands of years devoid of sunlight, where did the sudden energy come from for him to escape?
Adapting is Doomsday's whole gimmick.

Perhaps his body eventually found a way to resurrect itself in the total absence of an energy source..? To me, that is a LOT more believable than the assumption that solar radiation somehow managed to creep its way into the tomb over the years and nourish Doomsday. No evidence I am aware of so much as alludes to that.

It's not like he was imprisoned inside a thin piece of sheet metal, ffs:

srsly

*I'd also note that the burial shroud itself wasn't just some random piece of cloth either. It was extremely durable and energy-resistant... As we saw when it took the combined energy attacks of the JLA just to partially remove it from DD:

Originally posted by abhilegend
From his history. Immortal Hulk? Where?

Read the narration. That's exactly what Vision does here:

https://imgur.com/a/8ow5RK0

The Devil Hulk persona is not bothered by causing death, but "Immortal Hulk" can be other personas. This one appears to have started off as Savage.

And he does start off toying with Thing.

Originally posted by Galan007
So do you have any actual proof that solar radiation penetrated all the way through the thick tomb(and shroud) Doomsday was encased in, and was secretly nourishing him while the tomb was hurling through space, or are you just making baseless assumptions? Be honest.

Adapting is Doomsday's whole gimmick.

Perhaps his body eventually found a way to resurrect itself in the total absence of an energy source..? To me, that is a LOT more believable than the assumption that solar radiation somehow managed to creep its way into the tomb over the years and nourish Doomsday. No evidence I am aware of so much as alludes to that.

It's not like he was imprisoned inside a thin piece of sheet metal, ffs:

srsly

*I'd also note that the burial shroud itself wasn't just some random piece of cloth either. It was extremely durable and energy-resistant... As we saw when it took the combined energy attacks of the JLA just to partially remove it from DD:

Funny thing is that a thin piece of sheet metal CAN stop alpha and beta radiation, and a few inches of lead, or a few feet of generic concrete can stop most gamma radiation.

So no. solar radiation definitely wasn't getting through Doomsday's tomb and cloak. What a foolish thing to try and argue.