Superman's punch vs Thor's hammer strikes

Started by MrMind10 pages

how are you so sure the ground they stand on here is gorr's planet

how are you so sure they are still on gorr's planet when they are fighting here? we clearly see them in space, we clearly see part of the planet under them shattered, with narrative saying worlds shattered

also the moon/planet (whichever one it is idgaf) from far away cracking

Originally posted by Philosophía
Just to be clear:

You, Mr. Mind, are arguing that Thor shattered the ground beneath him on the planet he was striking Gorr, and the moon above them [producing the volcano above them, that he had to close].

You, abhi, are arguing that Thor shattered the ground beneath him on the planet he was striking Gorr, and the moon above them was a by product of the slammings/fight effects beforehand [producing the volcano above them, that he had to close]?

In short -- what do you think Thor's all-out hammer strikes on Gorr did?

the first moon the okt throw gorr to was lightyears away
has nothing to do with that panel

the shockwave of thor's strikes on gorr, shattered the planet/planetoid they were on and cracked the moon/planet (volcano, the one thor has to go save) far away

So you both agree that the ground beneath them [i.e. of the planet] was cracked, but disagree on why the ground on the moon was cracked to trigger the volcano [abhi says the slamming/fight beforehand, you say the strikes]?

M......eh.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Both of these responses are nonsense. How would Thor and Gorr travel to another planet/moon by same wormhole?

Not exactly sure wut ure saying.
I guess ure saying the wormhole brought them back to Gorr's planet?

Anyways, the moon/planet that Gorr landed after Young Thor smacked him was pretty clear it wasnt Gorr's planet. No sign of life or the moonsized godbomb. There were no dead gods littering the ground, no necro ooze all over the place, no black berserkers... As for the wormhole, Young Thor smacked Gorr into it and he followed immediately after. Gorr did not navigate or control it at that point(because he was smacked in) so it looks like it spit them out at another location.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Just to be clear:

You, Mr. Mind, are arguing that Thor shattered the ground beneath him on the planet he was striking Gorr, and the moon above them [producing the volcano above them, that he had to close].

You, abhi, are arguing that Thor shattered the ground beneath him on the planet he was striking Gorr, and the moon above them was a by product of the slammings/fight effects beforehand [producing the volcano above them, that he had to close]?

In short -- what do you think Thor's all-out hammer strikes on Gorr did?


I'm arguing that Thor shattered the ground beneath him and Gorr. No planets or moons were destroyed.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I'm arguing that Thor shattered the ground beneath him and Gorr. No planets or moons were destroyed.
I agree with this, except I also think he shattered the ground of the moon. No planet/moon being destroyed is obvious -- both the planet and the moon above above them had the ground shattered, but were still there. I think the only disagreement with you and Mr. Mind is that he was also responsible for triggering the shattering and volcano on the moon ... which is a pretty meh point, but whatevs.

Originally posted by MrMind
how are you so sure the ground they stand on here is gorr's planet

how are you so sure they are still on gorr's planet when they are fighting here? we clearly see them in space, we clearly see part of the planet under them shattered, with narrative saying worlds shattered

also the moon/planet (whichever one it is idgaf) from far away cracking


Answer my question first, how did they travel to another planet?
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Not exactly sure wut ure saying.
I guess ure saying the wormhole brought them back to Gorr's planet?

Anyways, the moon/planet that Gorr landed after Young Thor smacked him was pretty clear it wasnt Gorr's planet. No sign of life or the moonsized godbomb. There were no dead gods littering the ground, no necro ooze all over the place, no black berserkers... As for the wormhole, Young Thor smacked Gorr into it and he followed immediately after. Gorr did not navigate or control it at that point(because he was smacked in) so it looks like it spit them out at another location.


That's not what is shown. At the end, thunder was heard on Gorr's planet and thors fell directly below at the planet.

If they were fighting on a different planet, how did their blood falls on Gorr's planet along with unconscious Thors?

That added with the scan where Gorr's wife says that the planet trembled means they were fighting on the very same planet.

Thor but Supes have better lifting feats

Originally posted by Super-fan1230
Thor but Supes have better lifting feats

Superman has better striking feats too.

we have on panel statements of worlds shattering, asteroids destroyed, suns flickered by thor.

the planet/moon had a large crack from the center, the volcano errupted from the core, it was about to blow up any minute before thor saved it

other planets were destroyed via statements too but im too tired to argue that.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Answer my question first, how did they travel to another planet?
That's not what is shown. At the end, thunder was heard on Gorr's planet and thors fell directly below at the planet.

If they were fighting on a different planet, how did their blood falls on Gorr's planet along with unconscious Thors?

That added with the scan where Gorr's wife says that the planet trembled means they were fighting on the very same planet.

they went from other planet to space to sun then fall from the sun back to gorr's planet. that's what happened

Where are you getting that it is the same planet? The whole thing has them traveling light-years across space. You can clearly see the panels right next to each other and the planetoid was not cracked until Thor swing his hammer and the narrative said it began cracking.

Yeah, Superman has much better feats all around. But not in this instance

It's ok y'all. Superman still wins a fight and no, Gorr would get laughed out of existence by world forger

Originally posted by MrMind
we have on panel statements of worlds shattering, asteroids destroyed, suns flickered by thor.

the planet/moon had a large crack from the center, the volcano errupted from the core, it was about to blow up any minute before thor saved it

other planets were destroyed via statements too but im too tired to argue that.

they went from other planet to space to sun then fall from the sun back to gorr's planet. that's what happened


But then we saw Young Thor jump from the planet below to orbit and then in the sun.

You're telling me young Thor jumped lightyears there?

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Where are you getting that it is the same planet? The whole thing has them traveling light-years across space. You can clearly see the panels right next to each other and the planetoid was not cracked until Thor swing his hammer and the narrative said it began cracking.

Yeah, Superman has much better feats all around. But not in this instance

It's ok y'all. Superman still wins a fight and no, Gorr would get laughed out of existence by world forger


Its not just that, the comic falls apart when you look at it even remotely closely.

Like if they were travelling lightyears, how did Young Thor jumped into the orbit near sun?

Originally posted by abhilegend
But then we saw Young Thor jump from the planet below to orbit and then in the sun.

You're telling me young Thor jumped lightyears there?

you are not making any sense

Originally posted by MrMind
you are not making any sense

Your position is that the Gorr's planet and the planet he and Thor fought were lightyears away, right? But we know that the sun they fought in was directly above Gorr's planet?

So either you're wrong or Young Thor jumped lightyears from the planet Thor and Gorr fought near the sun's orbit above Gorr's planet.

Which is it?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Your position is that the Gorr's planet and the planet he and Thor fought were lightyears away, right?

lol I NEVER said that, read the whole thread again abhi, you are confusing yourself

Originally posted by MrMind
lol I NEVER said that, read the whole thread again abhi, you are confusing yourself

So how much apart are they? How do you know it was a different planet at all?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Answer my question first, how did they travel to another planet?
That's not what is shown. At the end, thunder was heard on Gorr's planet and thors fell directly below at the planet.

If they were fighting on a different planet, how did their blood falls on Gorr's planet along with unconscious Thors?

That added with the scan where Gorr's wife says that the planet trembled means they were fighting on the very same planet.


At that point they were fighting in a star werent they? Thunder heard could mean anything. Impact from Gorr attacks, impact from hammers, thunder/lightning attacks... God blood raining down came from the Thor's falling down to Gorr's planet(most likely). Gorr sliced the phuk out of the three Thor's and basically scattered their blood all over the atmosphere. Maybe all over the cosmos.

Gorr's wife is a construct of his. He gave ot life. It's a part of him. Maybe it can alomst sense what he knows and feels.... Like how he knows what his constructs r doing. And even then, from start to finish the whole battle was causing all kinds of raucous above the planet. The beginning alone, "thunder and the pounding of hammers" could be heard "through the depths of space". They also mentioned sky exploding etc.
Tons of atmospheric disturbances that could be seen and heard from the planet.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
At that point they were fighting in a star werent they? Thunder heard could mean anything. Impact from Gorr attacks, impact from hammers, thunder/lightning attacks... God blood raining down came from the Thor's falling down to Gorr's planet(most likely). Gorr sliced the phuk out of the three Thor's and basically scattered their blood all over the atmosphere. Maybe all over the cosmos.

Gorr's wife is a construct of his. He gave ot life. It's a part of him. Maybe it can alomst sense what he knows and feels.... Like how he knows what his constructs r doing. And even then, from start to finish the whole battle was causing all kinds of raucous above the planet. The beginning alone, "thunder and the pounding of hammers" could be heard "through the depths of space". They also mentioned sky exploding etc.
Tons of atmospheric disturbances that could be seen and heard from the planet.


Alot of speculation but hardly anything to show for.

Like I said, it's a planet busting feat if you don't look at it close enough. Also Aaron never showed Thor at that level before or after.