Superman's punch vs Thor's hammer strikes

Started by TheHulkster10 pages
Originally posted by abhilegend
So how much apart are they? How do you know it was a different planet at all?

Same solar system. Gorr's planet has life on it. Why would Thor ignore it cracking while rushing to save another planet? We see it cracking below while the narration points out worlds being destroyed.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Alot of speculation but hardly anything to show for.

Like I said, it's a planet busting feat if you don't look at it close enough. Also Aaron never showed Thor at that level before or after.

Did he write any Thor before? And yes, right after this arc, he did a complete 180 on Thor.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Did he write any Thor before? And yes, right after this arc, he did a complete 180 on Thor.

He did.

AvX.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Same solar system. Gorr's planet has life on it. Why would Thor ignore it cracking while rushing to save another planet? We see it cracking below while the narration points out worlds being destroyed.

Gorr's planet was desolate planet, in a void. No other planets were shown alongside it.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Did he write any Thor before? And yes, right after this arc, he did a complete 180 on Thor.
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
He did.

AvX.

But even with Jane Foster (he loved her), she was never shown as planetary level.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Alot of speculation but hardly anything to show for.


Its almost black and white. U actually delved into the speculation.

Originally posted by abhilegend

Like I said, it's a planet busting feat if you don't look at it close enough. Also Aaron never showed Thor at that level before or after.

Thats why its a high end feat. Its not gonna happen every issue. As for what Aaron thinks about Thor when he wrote that scene...

For all the Odin character assination, Aaron had Thor repeatedly do some ridiculous stuff. He was into a lot of space cheddar.
Planet shattering.
Absorbing godbomb.
Solar system length lightning.
Planet sized lightning.
Planet sized storm.
Planet tossing.
etc, etc.

Its not at all surprising anymore.

Originally posted by abhilegend
But even with Jane Foster (he loved her), she was never shown as planetary level.

breh....

there's this

and this

and this

finally this

No, black and white would be this.

Everything else is fair game.

And you listed his storm power and a scene where his hammer moves the prison which he couldn't even break out of.

😂

Originally posted by MrMind
breh....

there's this

and this

and this

None of those show planetary level strength.

finally this

That's not even Aaron.

I thought you were talkin about planetary level feats of Jane in general not just strength, nevermind

those feats were AT LEAST planetary level though

Originally posted by abhilegend
No, black and white would be this.

https://i.postimg.cc/ZqcbGc28/6909096-7829381646-JUSTL.jpg

Everything else is fair game.

And you listed his storm power and a scene where his hammer moves the prison which he couldn't even break out of.

😂


Thats why these r high end feats.
facepalm

In the same issue, a character can all of a sudden perform crazy things even though they do not seem to operate at that same level in other parts of the story. Happens all the time.

Hek ure own scan has supes leaping off the planet much later on when prior to, he couldnt even muster a a few miles.
Remember benching virtual earth weight? Later on he couldnt beat a decaying dragon that was ultimstely killed in an oil well explosion.
He even went to the sun for a recharge prior to that. 😬

Thor hammered Gorr many times before the world shattering. Barely even a shockwave in the other instances. All of a sudden he's cracking planets... Comics.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Gorr's planet was desolate planet, in a void. No other planets were shown alongside it.

So wouldn't that mean that they are not fighting on Gorr's planet since there are other planets around?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Superman has better striking feats too.

I agree that in a no holding contest , Supes would have better striking against Majolnir

Originally posted by abhilegend
But even with Jane Foster (he loved her), she was never shown as planetary level.

Lol.your right, her abilities were shown at a solar system + level with the motherstorm

Why is it so important to you that you low-ball Thor and do everything possible to make up your own headcanon about him?

Everyone agrees that Superman wins a fight but that's just not enough is it?

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Thats why these r high end feats.
facepalm

In the same issue, a character can all of a sudden perform crazy things even though they do not seem to operate at that same level in other parts of the story. Happens all the time.

Hek ure own scan has supes leaping off the planet much later on when prior to, he couldnt even muster a a few miles.
Remember benching virtual earth weight? Later on he couldnt beat a decaying dragon that was ultimstely killed in an oil well explosion.
He even went to the sun for a recharge prior to that. 😬

Thor hammered Gorr many times before the world shattering. Barely even a shockwave in the other instances. All of a sudden he's cracking planets... Comics.


But Superman does that regularly. Aaron never showed Thor was that strong.
Originally posted by TheHulkster
So wouldn't that mean that they are not fighting on Gorr's planet since there are other planets around?

There was a single moon.

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Lol.your right, her abilities were shown at a solar system + level with the motherstorm

Who's talking about mother storm? Name a single planetary strength feat from Jane.

Originally posted by abhilegend
There was a single moon.

And planets shattering around him.

Superman doesn’t strike harder than MJOLNIR, that’s ridiculous. It’s not even debatable at all

Originally posted by TheHulkster
And planets shattering around him.

Show those planets then.
Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Superman doesn’t strike harder than MJOLNIR, that’s ridiculous. It’s not even debatable at all

Superman absolutely hits harder than Thor with mjolnir does. Not even debatable.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Who's talking about mother storm? Name a single planetary strength feat from Jane.

Why are you splitting hairs? The point is whether or not Aaron gave highly favorable showings to Jane, which he did. She is very powerful and formidable.