Thanos and Thor vs. Superman

Originally posted by TheHulkster
50 jumps (cue bringing in real world science in an effort to dispute this).

Originally posted by NemeBro
The "same axis" line is directly succeeded by Superman by the line "and this time (...) he falls even shorter than the last", before noting that the "rut deepens". The axis is referring to the path Superman's leaps are taking around the Earth's axis, and the rut being the superficial damage along the surface. Nowhere does it state that the integrity of the planet is weakening, and if you're insinuating it is go ahead and provide a scan proving so.

As we see from the issue later, there isn't a single crack that can be seen on the planet:

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11137/111379460/6891132-rco004_1554280018.jpg

So to recap, at no point is it directly stated that the planet is falling apart with every jump, and nowhere after the fifty leaps nor after the World Forger's slam do we see any noticeable damage when looking at the planet as a whole. So you claim that Superman's prior jumps weakened the planet? Have fun proving it, but you're never going to be able to because nothing in the text or art states such to be the case, and until it does I'm going to assume that the planet Superman was on operates like a planet, which is to say that it doesn't start to crumble when the equivalent of a meteorite smashes into a mountain.

Your argument is dumb. I of course know you and carver are just trolling and won't quit making your retard posts, but I'm not making this post for your benefit. I'm making it to concisely nip this troll assertion in the bud for everyone else to see in the hope that no one responds to this brainless assertion again.

On topic, Galactus should win, and this feat we're talking about isn't even relevant to the Superman in this thread.

This is your cue to bail from the thread like a punk again. 👆

Originally posted by NemeBro
This is your cue to bail from the thread like a punk again. 👆

Right on cue.

So Superman's jump as the equivalent of a meteor striking a mountain?

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Right on cue.

So Superman's jump as the equivalent of a meteor striking a mountain?

Which jump are you referring to? 🙂

Guys. No bashing.

Also, unless a writer goes out of their way to say that something that exists in our reality is somehow different in the comics universe, then we start from the point of view that it's just like it is in the real world, subject to all the same laws of the universe.

Originally posted by NemeBro
This retard can't read lmao

Which jump are you referring to? 🙂

You equated his jumps to a meteor smashing into a mountain did you not?

Do we have proof that it weakened the planet? Simple q.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Do we have proof that it weakened the planet? Simple q.

We have evidence that brings doubt. I can name several times feats have been discarded based on doubt.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Right on cue.

So Superman's jump as the equivalent of a meteor striking a mountain?

https://comicvine1.cbsistatic.com/uploads/original/11137/111379460/6891167-rco020_1553068438.jpg

Yes, that is an adequate analogy. You weren't stupid enough to think I meant the one that destroyed the planet, were you? 🙁

Now, why don't you put on your big girl panties and get to providing a case that the planet's integrity was weakened when Superman destroyed it instead of trying to distract us from your argument's weak integrity? 🙂

Originally posted by TheHulkster
We have evidence that brings doubt. I can name several times feats have been discarded based on doubt.

O...k.

So what's the evidence?

Originally posted by TheHulkster
We have evidence that brings doubt. I can name several times feats have been discarded based on doubt.

O...k.

So what's the evidence? 'But others started it!!!!' isn't really proof.....

Originally posted by NemeBro
In this instance:

https://comicvine1.cbsistatic.com/uploads/original/11137/111379460/6891167-rco020_1553068438.jpg

Yes, that is an adequate analogy. You weren't stupid enough to think I meant the one that destroyed the planet, were you? 🙁

Now, why don't you put on your big girl panties and get to providing a case that the planet's integrity was weakened when Superman destroyed it instead of trying to distract us from your argument's weak integrity? 🙂

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Basic physics would tell you that it's impossible for a 225 pound humanoid to shatter a planet by jumping. You can't start picking and choosing to reach for real world science in the comic book world full of rubber science.

The writer stressed him repeatedly jumping from the same axis for a reason. Posters attempting to cite real world science in comic battle debates have commonly been ridiculed.

....but you're using 'real world physics' - by arguing that all of the previous jumps stacked damage on top of each other.

Why are you stacking the damage?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
....but you're using 'real world physics' - by arguing that all of the previous jumps stacked damage on top of each other.

Why are you stacking the damage?

I'm arguing writer intention.

What do you think is Snyder's intention behind the rationale that the 50 Supermen before him weakened the planet?

And what proof did he write into the story that leads you to this ?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
What do you think is Snyder's intention behind the rationale that the 50 Supermen before him weakened the planet?

And what proof did he write into the story that leads you to this ?

Im speaking of one Superman jumping more than 50 times. I stated above the writer emphasized repeated jumps along the same axis. He does this for a reason IMO. That's evidence enough to cause doubt.

Originally posted by TheHulkster

For the planet to have been shattered due to an accumulation of damage, it needed to have been a live one no? Like one with an active core that can be disturbed and ultimately erupt due to multiple powerful impacts? Im no geologist so i dun really know. The planet seemed dead to me however.

But then again we have things like this.
https://imgur.com/a/OU6HtX7

Comics.... 😬

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Im speaking of one Superman jumping more than 50 times. I stated above the writer emphasized repeated jumps along the same axis. He does this for a reason IMO. That's evidence enough to cause doubt.

But then that ignores the rest of what the writer wrote. Which is that every one of those repeated jumps - failed. It was to illustrate the sheer futility of his actions - and the stubbornness of Superman.

Originally posted by NemeBro
I've already refuted this point, why are you repeating yourself? 👇

Unsuccessfully.

Can you provide proof that Superman's previous jumps are meteor hitting a mountain level?

If only the last Superman just jumped fifty more times. 🙁