Originally posted by Mindship
I guess 'Edited' doesn't mean what it used to.Since my hand has now been forced, I was going to ask DDM how do the studies account for: those states which follow guidelines, like NY, are doing better than those that aren't, like FL. Then I figured other factors -- not just mask-wearing -- are helping.
Darn you, SM.
You should talk more about this. No one else really wants to talk about the science and data on KMC. It's just partisan politics and gotchas with no substance.
To get into the factors:
New York still had more deaths than Florida, yesterday. Despite their positive tests being remarkably lower than Florida. Florida saw 10x the number of new cases compared to NY, yesterday. However, overall, NY still had twice the positive cases over time.
Florida also has an older population and more people in it than NY.
New York also got hit harder, faster, than Florida. If you look at their death curve, they got hit the hardest in early April. Florida was almost exactly an entire month after.
And based on the serological testing, New York also was likely among the fastest to have their population infected with serological tests showing that NY had as much as 20% of their population (NYC) infected almost 2 months ago.
Lastly, both NY and Florida locked down at the end of March. However, NY should have locked down at the beginning of Feb. if they wished to use locking down as a tool (at the time, we thought lockdowns were effective but it turns out, they had a positive increase on deaths and a negative on deaths...which is counter-intuitive but that's what the data shows).
If you take a look at the mobility data for social distancing, Florida almost exactly mirrors New York:
https://covid19.healthdata.org/united-states-of-america/new-york