Majestic with creation blades vs cosmic herald Thor

Mr. Mind is a trip. Im not even talking about that attack he tanked. Im referring to the attack he withstood before the winter showed up. Doesnt matter since both of those attacks would turn Majestic into dust.

Originally posted by carver9
Mr. Mind is a trip. Im not even talking about that attack he tanked. Im referring to the attack he withstood before the winter showed up. Doesnt matter since both of those attacks would turn Majestic into dust.

Originally posted by carver9
Mr. Mind is a trip. Im not even talking about that attack he tanked. Im referring to the attack he withstood before the winter showed up. Doesnt matter since both of those attacks would turn Majestic into dust.

by the same carveturd
Thor TANKED an attack from Galactus that was amplified far past his normal levels and is fighting evenly with this same Galactus. This showing is like Majestic going all in on Spectre and actually holding his own.

do you have short term memory loss?

also, Thor wasn't fighting Galactus before Black Winter show up

@Mr. Mind

Thats...not...the...attack...im...talking...about. Next time when you're clueless, let me know. I'm talking about Thor #2, page 18, ends on page 19. Look at the pictures, read the panels and next time do a little probing before making assumptions.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85

You're funny. I imagine if Carver posted the short lived scuffle that Superman had with Majestic and won, and then posted the gas station explosion that KO'd Superman during DOS. Would you accept it as a fair durability scaling?

Originally posted by carver9
Dark is trolling. Hes using it as a low showing. I would love for him to show you Skuttle Bucket limitations. This isn't a low showing for Galactus, its a high showing for Skuttle. He would report me if I went into a Doomsday thread and mentioned Doomsday failing to kill a shieldless Blue Beetle, Booster Gold and Guy Gardner after beating on them, going all out. Something that even Luke Cage can do. He holds a candle to certain things (Marvel; The Avengers being weaklings when facing Hulk) but he is bias AF when it comes to DC. He can not be taken serious. Report that. Lol

Originally posted by carver9
@Mr. Mind

Thats...not...the...attack...im...talking...about. Next time when you're clueless, let me know. I'm talking about Thor #2, page 18, ends on page 19. Look at the pictures, read the panels and next time do a little probing before making assumptions.

by the same carveturd
Thor TANKED an attack from Galactus that was amplified far past his normal levels and is fighting evenly with this same Galactus.

where did Thor fight evenly with AMPLIFIED Galactus? where exactly at "Thor #2, page 18, ends on page 19" ? that's the page you mentioned, so don't weasel your way out again

you absolute troll.

carveturd
Im referring to the attack he withstood before the winter showed up

winter showed up at issue 4 you numbskull, why are you back to issue 2?

Originally posted by MrMind
where did Thor fight evenly with [B]AMPLIFIED Galactus at "Thor #2, page 18, ends on page 19"

you absolute troll.

winter showed up at issue 4 you numbskull, why are you back to issue 2? [/B]

😂 ... your comprehension. Fight and tanking something are two different things. He TANKED Galactus attack in Thor #2.

😂 ... issue 2 IS BEFORE ISSUE FOUR. How do you count? 1, 4, 3, 2?

Originally posted by carver9
😂 ... your comprehension. Fight and tanking something are two different things. He TANKED Galactus attack in Thor #2.

😂 ... issue 2 IS BEFORE ISSUE FOUR. How do you count? 1, 4, 3, 2?

by the same carveturd
Thor TANKED an attack from Galactus that was amplified far past his normal levels and is FIGHTING EVENLY with this same Galactus.

Originally posted by MrMind

And it goes against nothing I said. I showed him tanking an attack and you posted a scan trying to discredit THAT statement. Now if you want to discuss the fighting part (that you did not use a scan for), let me know.

Originally posted by MrMind
where did Thor fight evenly with [B]AMPLIFIED Galactus? where exactly at "Thor #2, page 18, ends on page 19" ? that's the page you mentioned, so don't weasel your way out again

[/B]

I ignored that because you ignored my initial statement. 🙂

what is your initial statement? quote it for me

now answer the question, when did Thor fight evenly with an amplified galactus

carveturd
Thor tanked an attack from Galactus that was amplified far past his normal levels and is fighting evenly with this same Galactus.

I'm not letting you off the hook

Originally posted by Stoic
You're funny. I imagine if Carver posted the short lived scuffle that Superman had with Majestic and won, and then posted the gas station explosion that KO'd Superman during DOS. Would you accept it as a fair durability scaling?

Hmm.

How many showings does Superman have? Over the course of his publication history?

How many since 1985, when he was rebooted? Am 100% sure if you went through his entire history, you can cherry pick a low showing here and there. Then be absolutely annihilated with his high showings

Now let's do the same with Herald Thor. How many showings does he have? Of these, how many are low? I am SURE you want to be fair and balanced for both sides, right??

Thor stomps

Originally posted by carver9

Don't worry, I have reported you.

Originally posted by carver9
I ignored that because you ignored my initial statement. 🙂

Originally posted by carver9

Stop getting your feathers ruffled, and stay on topic. 👆

Originally posted by Galan007
You're better than this, carv.

No. No he isn't.

So herald Thor, IMO, is still too early to say. ESPECIALLY as in the few showings he has had so far, he has had some high, but ALSO some low.

If I created a brand new character, and said he was stronger than the entire DCU and Marvel U combined, then had Batman beating him in an armwrestle, then had him casually beating Superman with his pinkie in the same issue....can we then put him up against people like Hulk? No.