Originally posted by cdtm
Ooh, I like that. Trading one necessary evil for another.The truth is you can somewhar sympathise with the facists up to a point. Until you learn they genocided races.
I think it would have been stronger had they not been full on nazi's, as even a benevolent facist dictatorship is still an evil.
Moore is a great writer. Even though he is an anarchist himself he doesn't try to paint the crossover period as being pretty or idyllic.
I think the reason he portrayed the fascist government in that way was to make them the perfect encompassing of British fascist / authoritarian ideals, that way the story plays out as a battle of the anarchist / totalitarian dichotomy. Right-wing British ideals have always been heavily centred around targeting minority groups (and women), so that's also why. Anti-immigrant, anti-disabled, anti-queer, it's all core to British Conservativism (e.g. Churchill) and British Fascism (e.g. Oswald Mosley). Disabled people and gay people in the early-to-mid 20th century were subject to all manner of state horrors: chemical castration, locked in asylums where they were ritually abused, all sorts of brutal shit and all hallmarks of right-wing ideology. These factors need to be taken into account whenever discussing fascism because they are a part of the ideology. Just as you can't discuss left-wing authoritarianism without having to take into account the aspect of class-based purges, for example.
The thing about 1984 for example is that it's more of a Stalinist dystopia than a fascist one, but it fuses different elements. Orwell, a true lefty and a staunch socialist, was portraying the dangers of totalitarianism in its entirety, borrowing heavily from what he knew about the Soviet Union at the time, and how it had become a beaurocratic state-capitalist nightmare masquerading under the banner of 'Communism' (hence Ingsoc). Plus in the world of 1984 we as the audience only know so much. For all we know, there were minority purges when Oceania was founded. That part of history is lost in-universe.