Guardian vs. Sabretooth

Started by Wonder Man2 pages

Guardian vs. Sabretooth

Can Sabretooth destroy Guardian?

Which Guardian? Marvel or DC?

If DC (Jim Harper) he should win easily

If Marvel (James Hudson) Guardian stomps, the guy is border line low herald

Originally posted by beatboks
If Marvel (James Hudson) Guardian stomps, the guy is border line low herald
Originally posted by -K-M-

No KM, not hitting on you.
I know Guardian is ranked High Meta, It's just in my opinion hes close to punching the cieling of that tier. Onnsome of his high end feats an argument could be made for him just making low herald tier. Hense the "borderline" part of the comment

Originally posted by beatboks
No KM, not hitting on you.

You spent seven years on this board without really getting our sense of humour.

Amazing.

Logan schooled Human Torch.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
You spent seven years on this board without really getting our sense of humour.

Amazing.

I got the humor Stilt, but someone has to play the straight man for everyone to trundle jokes off for to work as well. Jeryy Lewis was funnier for having Dean Martin. Costello wouldn't have been anywhere near as funny without Abbot beingnthe butt of his jokes.

Have you really never noticed I always have the dry straight man reply?

You're trying too hard to be straight, imho vin

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
You're trying too hard to be straight, imho vin

👍

If so, that just means a bigger laugh at my expense

Originally posted by Wonder Man
Logan schooled Human Torch.

Human torch isnt on Guardian's level.

For one thing, Logan's admantium claws cant penetrate Guardian's shields (uncanny x-men somewhere around 108/109/110 from memory, KM would know for sure and probably have the scan)

Wonderman is not trying to have a discussion, he's just high as usual.

Hudson got "killed" in the simulation by "Wolverine".

Bone Claw Logan swatted him like a fly with a backhand.

If Mac proved one thing in his career, it's that the superheroing really ain't his thing.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Wonderman is not trying to have a discussion, he's just high as usual.

Hudson got "killed" in the simulation by "Wolverine".

Bone Claw Logan swatted him like a fly with a backhand.

If Mac proved one thing in his career, it's that the superheroing really ain't his thing.

Now now Stilt do I have to drop pages worth of knowledge about Guardian?

Post the panels in which he fails to subdue Bone Claw God with a cheapshot and then kisses his mighty backhand.

And what does that prove exactly? He has defeated adamantium wolverine so does that mean bone claw wolverine > adamantium wolverine?

Well, TECHNICALLY....

Bone Claw IS meant to be faster.......so he should be able to tag people that much easier.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Well, TECHNICALLY....

Bone Claw IS meant to be faster.......so he should be able to tag people that much easier.

To a point, but bone claw is also inferior in other ways too. Overall I do not think anyone has claimed bone claw is superior.

If his adamantium claws couldn’t cut him, what does it matter if he back handed him? It didn’t defeat him or do anything serious of note.

We have seen wolverine fail to cut through James shield and another example Lady Deathstrike’s had an Electo magnetic sword (which was similar to Guardians shield)....and Wolverine couldn’t cut it. He even thought her sword was adamantium and was terrified it was going to cut through Heather who was now wearing Guardians suit. But when Deathstrike tried to use her sword on Vindicators shield it shattered to pieces on the first strike

Originally posted by -K-M-
And what does that prove exactly? He has defeated adamantium wolverine so does that mean bone claw wolverine > adamantium wolverine?

Early Adamantium Wolverine, you mean. Before his healing factor.

Modern showings, we have them going toe to toe... and there's also that showing with pre-X-Men Wolverine beating Mac in his prototype suit using environment and being smarter than him.

We have seen wolverine fail to cut through James shield

We've also seen him getting stabbed when facing a simulation (training robot? whatever it was, wasn't the real thing) of Wolverine vin

It's just what 90s TAS said... his lousy ff can't protect him forever 😛

Guardian’s power level was tied to his natural relation with nature so that good results for department H would result in good for people.
I didn’t realize he was that powerful though.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW

Early Adamantium Wolverine, you mean. Before his healing factor.

Modern showings, we have them going toe to toe... and there's also that showing with pre-X-Men Wolverine beating Mac in his prototype suit using environment and being smarter than him.

And? His claws still couldn’t cut through his shields even after that initial appearance. You mentioned bone claw hitting him with a back hand (if your referring to wolverine #95). But that wasn’t even a fight. Guardian thought he was attacking an innocent person so he dive bombed wolverine and was holding him on the ground and told him to stop. He wasn’t trying to fight him. His shields were off and then wolverine back handed him. That was it

What modern showing shows them going toe to toe? You mean in his groundhog armour?

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW

We've also seen him getting stabbed when facing a simulation (training robot? whatever it was, wasn't the real thing) of Wolverine vin

It's just what 90s TAS said... his lousy ff can't protect him forever 😛

Are you talking about AF vol 2 #1? That was after Guardian beat him. He turned off his shields and went to go check on him and then Wolverine recovered and stabbed him. Was a training session to show wolverine was still human and not an animal. That was also planned by Department H so they could clone James and make a version they could control

Guardian’s power level was tied to his natural relation with nature so that good results for department H would result in good for people.

😂 😂 😂 😂 😂