Etrigan vs Unworthy Thor

Started by celeyhyga173 pages

Originally posted by abhilegend
Yes, really.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus

How was it retconned out of continuity? And it still happened buttercup. 🙂

Originally posted by abhilegend

Secret Wars recreated the universe before any of the incursions happened sweetie.

It's still a thing in 616.

These r just 2 examples. There's actually lot more references to the incursions in current 616.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Rage and celey in Thor vs DC threads:

Rage and celey in Thor vs Marvel threads:

you just murdered this thread DS

😂

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
It's still a thing in 616.

These r just 2 examples. There's actually lot more references to the incursions in current 616.


That's writer inconsistency. Black Panther time traveled to the first incursion at the end of Secret Wars and found it stopped.

Current 616 was recreated, but with the knowledge of those events.
So technically, it is still within continuity. There are multiple references to it happening in current 616.

This is the first scene.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Current 616 was recreated, but with the knowledge of those events.
So technically, it is still within continuity. There are multiple references to it happening in current 616.

Having memories doesn't mean they actually did all those things. Like I said, the incursions never happened so everything from that point onwards actually never happened.

Originally posted by MrMind
you just murdered this thread DS

😂

That he did.

Thats not what im saying.
For whatever reason, the time leading up to and including secret wars was worked into current 616. It still happened.
I dont have all the references handy, but they are many.
Most if not all the heroes remember it. Theres even a reference that regular people knew it happened as well.

I just posted proof that 616 remembers the events. Isnt that nuff? What alternate reality r we living in?

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Thats not what im saying.
For whatever reason, the time leading up to and including secret wars was worked into current 616. It still happened.
I dont have all the references handy, but they are many.
Most if not all the heroes remember it. Theres even a reference that regular people knew it happened as well.

I just posted proof that 616 remembers the events. Isnt that nuff? What alternate reality r we living in?


So where are all the destroyed universes? Why does Black Panther not see the incursion when he traveled back in time?

Sigh...
Current BP knows exactly what happened. Ill try to find the scans later.
When this universe was rebuilt, the people still have knowledge of what happened to them during... It doesnt matter how it was rebuilt. That part in their histories still happened. They still acknowledge the events that happened to them.

Knowledge=/=Actually doing the stuff.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Why would he need to evade Thor for long when he can use his magic to turn Thor inside out?

Secret Wars recreated the universe before any of the incursions happened sweetie.

How does that retcon the event from happening?

Plenty of people remember the incursions. All the important Marvel characters remember: Doom, BP, Reed, Valeria, Loki etc. It's cannon.

🙂

Being canon doesn't mean it actually happened or they actually did all those things. Timeline changed, most of the events never happened.

Originally posted by abhilegend
That's writer inconsistency. Black Panther time traveled to the first incursion at the end of Secret Wars and found it stopped.

Originally posted by abhilegend
This is the first scene.

It's no different from Post Crisis characters remembering pre crisis events.

Pre and post-crisis was a complete reset.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Being canon doesn't mean it actually happened or they actually did all those things. Timeline changed, most of the events never happened.

That doesn't mean it was retconned. It's admissible on battle boards.

P.S. It's established canon that Asgardians, are metaphysical entities driven by stories. So even with time-travel, Thor's unique nature means if someone remembers, it still happened. 🙂

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Pre and post-crisis was a complete reset.

Nope. Lots of pre crisis things were mentioned post Crisis.

For example Chemo was killed on another Earth before crisis but was merger with all the multiverse brought him to new earth.

That doesn't mean it was retconned. It's admissible on battle boards.

P.S. It's established canon that Asgardians, are metaphysical entities driven by stories. So even with time-travel, Thor's unique nature means if someone remembers, it still happened. 🙂

Nonsense.

Lol..
Its not just a random memory. They refer to it happening to themselves.. Smh

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Lol..
Its not just a random memory. They refer to it happening to themselves.. Smh
Originally posted by abhilegend
So where are all the destroyed universes? Why does Black Panther not see the incursion when he traveled back in time?
Originally posted by abhilegend

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Sigh...
Current BP knows exactly what happened. Ill try to find the scans later.
When this universe was rebuilt, the people still have knowledge of what happened to them during... It doesnt matter how it was rebuilt. That part in their histories still happened. They still acknowledge the events that happened to them.

Originally posted by abhilegend
So where are all the destroyed universes? Why does Black Panther not see the incursion when he traveled back in time?

Still no answer. Concession accepted.