Originally posted by abhilegend
How's it non canon? It directly references multiple in canon stories.It references Nuclear Man who's canon in DC rebirth only.
So nope, it's canon all the way.
there's no point proving those marvel trolls wrong, they gonna keep saying non-canon. they wouldn't be able to live if they don't lie to themselves everyday.
I think the question cones from it being originally a walmart comic and emphasis on it not being tied to continuity as expressed by Kubert below.
https://www.ign.com/articles/2018/09/06/how-this-new-superman-comic-aims-to-hook-new-dc-readers
Originally posted by TheHulkster
I think the question cones from it being originally a walmart comic and emphasis on it not being tied to continuity as expressed by Kubert below.https://www.ign.com/articles/2018/09/06/how-this-new-superman-comic-aims-to-hook-new-dc-readers
Lol...
Originally posted by TheHulkstersmh where does it say it’s not part of continuity? Providing a link doesn’t solidify your argument especially when it doesn’t back your argument.
I think the question cones from it being originally a walmart comic and emphasis on it not being tied to continuity as expressed by Kubert below.https://www.ign.com/articles/2018/09/06/how-this-new-superman-comic-aims-to-hook-new-dc-readers
They targeted a different audience, one that doesn’t follow the soap opera of dc comics. This is a one arc deal. It doesn’t continue to a new story like or is tied into one that is going to the next arc.
Now the question for you is, is it canon? Yes or no?
[QUOTE=17365530]Originally posted by TheHulkster
[B]I think the question cones from it being originally a walmart comic and emphasis on it not being tied to continuity as expressed by Kubert below.
“I wanted people that normally didn’t read comics to pick this up and just be sucked right into it and not have to work to see what’s going on,” Kubert explained.
“It’s big and bombastic and it’s simple,” Kubert said. “If you’re going to a Walmart a month later [to pick up the next issue], all you have to remember is, Superman is trying to save a girl.” King added on, saying, “You don’t have to know a single thing about continuity, you don’t have to know anything about the history of comics. You just have to know that Superman is a superhero, and he’s in love with Lois Lane, and he hates Lex Luthor. ... As long as you keep those facts, you can pick up and read it.”
So it's written in a way to a appeal to people who don't read comics, yes?
"you don't have to know about previous continuity" =/= "the book itself is out of continuity"
The creative team was told to write the book in a way which does not alienate new readers. So in order to achieve that all they had to to do was introduce new storylines and characters which don't depend on previously released comicbooks. The actual book itself (UP in the Sky) does not need to be non-canon in order to appeal to the general audience. Unless something in the book specifically contradicts established continuity I don't see why it should be treated as non-canon
Originally posted by C1arkpost the statement word for word and I will gladly explain how to understand the subject and when it shifts. It's just like me saying I'm looking for the " fastest." of all the powerful corvettes. Now what kind of Corvettes am I talking about? Because there are many types of powerful Corvettes out there, but I'm looking for a particular kind,right?
Please break down that statement piece by piece. I am having a lot of trouble comprehending how you interpret the English language
Originally posted by JBL
post the statement word for word and I will gladly explain how to understand the subject and when it shifts. It's just like me saying I'm looking for the " fastest." of all the powerful corvettes. Now what kind of Corvettes am I talking about? Because there are many types of powerful Corvettes out there, but I'm looking for a particular kind,right?
You forget that there is a comma separating tenacious and powerful.......
Originally posted by JBLlet’s look at this statement. You’re a lazy, stupid troll.
Nowhere in that scan did it say " one of the most powerful being in the universe" he was focusing on the most tenacious, I will say it again, the most tenacious, powerful beings.. stop! He and no point said most powerful. He said powerful.
Now factoring in the comma what’s in focus? You’re lazy or a stupid troll or both?