Originally posted by h1a8
You ignored what I said. I stated SOME graphic novels can be used (some can't).As far as second statement
Because I'm active in movie vs forums so I'm used to debating them. It's a matter of habit.
No I didn't, I misread. But what are you even talking about? It doesn't even make sense that some would be not allowed BECAUSE they're graphic novels. If something isn't allowed it would be because it's non canon, like there are graphic novels that are ELSEWORLDS. Otherwise, you bringing it up is dumb.
So are you now going to say this shouldn't be allowed at all(the movie thing)?
Originally posted by Delta1938
No I didn't, I misread. But what are you even talking about? It doesn't even make sense that some would be not allowed BECAUSE they're graphic novels. If something isn't allowed it would be because it's non canon, like there are graphic novels that are ELSEWORLDS. Otherwise, you bringing it up is dumb. Non Canon has not the only graphic novels that can't be used. Read the rules and come back to me.So are you now going to say this shouldn't be allowed at all(the movie thing)?
Obviously I know the rules that is why I stated some aren't allowed. Remember I didn't give a reason why some were not allowed. You just assumed wrongly.
Basically I gave a true statement
Some graphic novels can't be used.
You misconstrued it as a false statement due to a false assumption of why you think I stated the true statement
Originally posted by h1a8
Obviously I know the rules that is why I stated some aren't allowed. Remember I didn't give a reason why some were not allowed. You just assumed wrongly.Basically I gave a true statement
Some graphic novels can't be used.Non Canon ones aren't the only ones that can't be used. Read the rules and get back with me.
You misconstrued it as a false statement due to a false assumption of why you think I stated the true statement
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Yeah, you only focussed on the rules when you realised you were wrong. Got ya.
Coincidence.
There is proof that I believe we were talking about the movie.
If I knew from the beginning that you guys were referring to the book then I would have stated the rules up front or just not posted at all.
Originally posted by h1a8
Obviously I know the rules that is why I stated some aren't allowed. Remember I didn't give a reason why some were not allowed. You just assumed wrongly.Basically I gave a true statement
Some graphic novels can't be used.You misconstrued it as a false statement due to a false assumption of why you think I stated the true statement
Yeah, no. Graphic novels are just large comics unless you're pretentious and trying to act like a sophisticated snob, like when Neil Gaiman talked about someone said, "You don't write comics, you write graphic novels" and he replied while appreciating the sentiment, he felt like if someone were told, "You're not a hooker, you're a lady of the night."
So there's no reason you should have said what you did, as it applies to anything non canon. It's weird and makes no sense to say unless you're just carter or JBL level stupid.
Originally posted by Delta1938
Yeah, no. Graphic novels are just large comics unless you're pretentious and trying to act like a sophisticated snob, like when Neil Gaiman talked about someone said, "You don't write comics, you write graphic novels" and he replied while appreciating the sentiment, he felt like if someone were told, "You're not a hooker, you're a lady of the night."So there's no reason you should have said what you did, as it applies to anything non canon. It's weird and makes no sense to say unless you're just carter or JBL level stupid.
Originally posted by h1a8
Wait
So you believe all graphic novels are allowed ( Canon or not)?
That's not what I said. Look to my previous post.
Originally posted by Delta1938
No I didn't, I misread. But what are you even talking about? It doesn't even make sense that some would be [b]not allowed BECAUSE they're graphic novels. If something isn't allowed it would be because it's non canon, like there are graphic novels that are ELSEWORLDS. Otherwise, you bringing it up is dumb. [/B]
What was even the point of saying it to begin with? It would be like saying some Annuals aren't allowed and then later saying "because some are ELSEWORLDS."
Originally posted by Delta1938
That's not what I said. Look to my previous post.What was even the point of saying it to begin with? It would be like saying some Annuals aren't allowed and then later saying "because some are ELSEWORLDS."
There are graphic novels that aren't allowed THAT ARE CANON sir.
Originally posted by h1a8
There are graphic novels that aren't allowed THAT ARE CANON sir.
You brought up sometimes graphic novels not being allowed after saying novels aren't allowed. What was the point in that? It's like you said it's because they're graphic NOVELS. I DGAF about the "some aren't canon" because that's a big ****ing DUH, hence the "sometimes annuals aren't canon" comparison. You, whether intentionally or not, equated them not being allowed(even if sometimes) to the novel part.
Over the years on this and other forums I've made a variety of threads on Remo. It really depends where in his story you pick up, whether he would lose or not. By the time he is running around explosions. Moving many times faster than the speed of light around radiation ejecting God's from his mind by channeling Shiva, tanking tectonic plate moving blasts etc, he would wtf own Twishite, but by then he'd wtf own most characters. He and Goku are very similar in the story of their power progression. In fact I believe Remo as much as the Monkey King is an influence on DBZ. Remo is still far more fun and if you don't mind Fumanchu racial stereotyping, a helluva a lot of fun. Remember this is a fifty year old series and like with Perry Rhodan it has to be viewed through a lens of that time.
Originally posted by Delta1938
You brought up sometimes graphic novels not being allowed after saying novels aren't allowed. What was the point in that? It's like you said it's because they're graphic NOVELS. I DGAF about the "some aren't canon" because that's a big ****ing DUH, hence the "sometimes annuals aren't canon" comparison. You, whether intentionally or not, equated them not being allowed(even if sometimes) to the novel part.
The point was to give a list of things that are allowed.
Duh.
Originally posted by h1a8
My fault. Didnt read the OP correctly. He says novels (not movies).
Then that certainly isn't allowed. This forum is for comic related books (some graphic novels). But certainly not books.Hell some graphic novel material isn't even allowed let alone non graphic material.
Originally posted by Old Man Whirly!
Over the years on this and other forums I've made a variety of threads on Remo. It really depends where in his story you pick up, whether he would lose or not. By the time he is running around explosions. Moving many times faster than the speed of light around radiation ejecting God's from his mind by channeling Shiva, tanking tectonic plate moving blasts etc, he would wtf own Twishite, but by then he'd wtf own most characters. He and Goku are very similar in the story of their power progression. In fact I believe Remo as much as the Monkey King is an influence on DBZ. Remo is still far more fun and if you don't mind Fumanchu racial stereotyping, a helluva a lot of fun. Remember this is a fifty year old series and like with Perry Rhodan it has to be viewed through a lens of that time.
Source ?