Silver Surfer vrs Superman (MOS)

Started by Darth Thor2 pages
Originally posted by h1a8
1. Surfer would be statued in this fight.

The guy traverses the planet in seconds. And he doesn't even stand around to be a statue Lmao

Also characters fight IN CHARACTER. When has Superman ever taken advantage of his opponent being a statue. Prove he can punch someone (with the strength to take out Surfer) while keeping his opponent as a statue.

Spoiler:
And yes I'm being a little over-elaborate and pedantic, but that's how I have to argue against someone who gives silly arguments just ignoring the abilities of a guy who can traverse through the Galaxy, go intangible, transmute, emit planet sized explosions and drill through the Earth. "But hey who cares when My Guy can Maybe Move Faster!" Ridiculous.
Originally posted by h1a8
2. He has no feats showing he can blast-vaporize someone with Superman-level durability.

Circular argument given Superman has never shown resistance to being trans-mutated into a surf board. At least we saw Surfer (or Doom with Surfer's powers) go up against super strong beings, (The Thing and Johnny Super Skrull).

Originally posted by h1a8
Superman either one-shots him off the board or one-shots him outright.

Troll conclusion. Science was needed to separate Surfer from his board. Travelling at light speed doesn't do it, so zero reason to think Superman has the strength to do it.

Surfer clearly is the one who stomps here.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
The guy traverses the planet in seconds. And he doesn't even stand around to be a statue Lmao

Also characters fight IN CHARACTER. When has Superman ever taken advantage of his opponent being a statue. Prove he can punch someone (with the strength to take out Surfer) while keeping his opponent as a statue.

Spoiler:
And yes I'm being a little over-elaborate and pedantic, but that's how I have to argue against someone who gives silly arguments just ignoring the abilities of a guy who can traverse through the Galaxy, go intangible, transmute, emit planet sized explosions and drill through the Earth. "But hey who cares when My Guy can Maybe Move Faster!" Ridiculous.

Circular argument given Superman has never shown resistance to being trans-mutated into a surf board. At least we saw Surfer (or Doom with Surfer's powers) go up against super strong beings, (The Thing and Johnny Super Skrull).

Troll conclusion. Science was needed to separate Surfer from his board. Travelling at light speed doesn't do it, so zero reason to think Superman has the strength to do it.

Surfer clearly is the one who stomps here.

1. Show Surfer traversing the planet - from one side to the other - in seconds, not minutes. Provide actual numbers: distance and time. Then, demonstrate how that directly correlates to reaction speed or combat speed.

2. Superman statued Wonder Woman - a character with faster perception than Silver Surfer - during his fight with Flash. He also perceived Steppenwolf in slow motion and was moving in relation to lightning.

3. More durable materials have greater resistance to transmutation than weaker ones. It's a special attribute to transmute objects more durable than Doom. I don't need to prove Superman is immune to Surfer's transmutation - you need to prove Surfer can affect someone as durable as Superman. A nuke can transmute material into vapor, yet it failed to do that to Superman.

4. Any punch exceeding 500 tons of force could knock out Surfer, as he has no feats of withstanding blunt force above that threshold.

5. How could Superman be trapped on Surfer's board if he perceives Surfer as moving in slow motion or not at all?

6. Doom, while wielding Surfer's power, was knocked off the board by the Thing - and Superman is astronomically stronger than the Thing.

7. Surfer didn't emit a planet-sized explosion. He triggered a chain reaction within a planet-sized cloud entity. The explosion had zero effect on Earth, showing it lacked significant destructive power.

Originally posted by h1a8
1. Show Surfer traversing the planet - from one side to the other - in seconds, not minutes. Provide actual numbers: distance and time. Then, demonstrate how that directly correlates to reaction speed or combat speed.

He flew from one solar system to another in a few seconds. You can ChatGBT the speed on that.

Originally posted by h1a8
2. Superman statued Wonder Woman - a character with faster perception than Silver Surfer - during his fight with Flash. He also perceived Steppenwolf in slow motion and was moving in relation to lightning.

He never hit Aquaman or WW whilst they were statued. So we have no idea how hard he can hit while his opponent is statued.

Yeah Steppenwolf was slow motion, not a statue. Surfer fights in flight mode. Ergo he will always be moving much faster than Steppenwolf. Ergo not a statue, heck not even slow.

Originally posted by h1a8
3. More durable materials have greater resistance to transmutation than weaker ones. It's a special attribute to transmute objects more durable than Doom. I don't need to prove Superman is immune to Surfer's transmutation - you need to prove Surfer can affect someone as durable as Superman. A nuke can transmute material into vapor, yet it failed to do that to Superman.

Yes you do. You're stuck on this point which is why you're trying to move on./

Originally posted by h1a8
4. Any punch exceeding 500 tons of force could knock out Surfer, as he has no feats of withstanding blunt force above that threshold.

That's not how the rules here work. You can't just make up a character who has never been kocked out will be knocked out by an arbitary amount of force.

But at least Surfer has durability feats to physical force. Superman has none against being transmted into his board.

Not only that but he will just go Intangible. Superman can't lay a finger on him.

Originally posted by h1a8
5. How could Superman be trapped on Surfer's board if he perceives Surfer as moving in slow motion or not at all?

Speculation.

Originally posted by h1a8
6. Doom, while wielding Surfer's power, was knocked off the board by the Thing - and Superman is astronomically stronger than the Thing.

And yet The Thing couldn't seperate Surfer. Science was needed.

Heck traversing through Space doesn't knock Sufer off his board. Superman is stuck here.

Originally posted by h1a8
7. Surfer didn't emit a planet-sized explosion. He triggered a chain reaction within a planet-sized cloud entity. The explosion had zero effect on Earth, showing it lacked significant destructive power.

Yes he did. Quit making excuses.

And he drills a hole through the Earth.

And he transmutes his opponents or attacks against him. And he goes Intangible. Superman can't even touch him.

Surfer stomps. And you're a Troll.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
He flew from one solar system to another in a few seconds. You can ChatGBT the speed on that.

He never hit Aquaman or WW whilst they were statued. So we have no idea how hard he can hit while his opponent is statued.

Yeah Steppenwolf was slow motion, not a statue. Surfer fights in flight mode. Ergo he will always be moving much faster than Steppenwolf. Ergo not a statue, heck not even slow.

Yes you do. You're stuck on this point which is why you're trying to move on./

That's not how the rules here work. You can't just make up a character who has never been kocked out will be knocked out by an arbitary amount of force.

But at least Surfer has durability feats to physical force. Superman has none against being transmted into his board.

Not only that but he will just go Intangible. Superman can't lay a finger on him.

Speculation.

And yet The Thing couldn't seperate Surfer. Science was needed.

Heck traversing through Space doesn't knock Sufer off his board. Superman is stuck here.

Yes he did. Quit making excuses.

And he drills a hole through the Earth.

And he transmutes his opponents or attacks against him. And he goes Intangible. Superman can't even touch him.

Surfer stomps. And you're a Troll.

1. We're not given a timeframe for how long it took Surfer to arrive; it could've been days or even weeks.
Traveling within an atmosphere is significantly slower than in a vacuum due to drag forces.

I once posted a calculation showing that someone traveling to the nearest solar system in a week would only cover the first 20 meters in about 0.01 seconds. That's because of acceleration-objects need time to build up speed.

You also can't move faster than your reflexes allow. Humans can guide FTL ships in space because the distances are vast, but they couldn't navigate through a house at those speeds.

2. Superman can hit extremely hard while others appear statued. He retains his strength, and due to the velocity, the kinetic energy behind his punches would be astronomical. Superman's punch speed was nearly matching the propagation speed of the lightning around Flash.

3. I'm not claiming Superman can't be transmuted by Surfer. Transmuting human-level material doesn't prove being able to transmute steel or vastly more durable substances. If you claim Surfer can transmute Superman, you need to show him doing so to something comparably durable.

4. Characters don't get special attributes without evidence. You're assigning Surfer the durability to tank a 500-ton punch without being KO'd, with no proof. That's not how it works.
Surfer can't just go intangible before being hit, especially if Superman doesn't give him the chance. Even if allowed, Surfer must be tangible to attack, meaning he's vulnerable during the fight.

5. How is it speculation to say Surfer would be statued or appear to move like a snail? What's the fastest he's traveled and reacted during a fight?

6. Thing never hit Surfer, he hit Doom, who had Surfer's powers. Traveling through space isn't the same as tanking a 100-ton punch. Humans in fiction can travel in space without issue. We could calculate the G-forces acting on Surfer, but we'd need his acceleration data in space to do that.

7. Now you're trolling. The cloud was already there; Surfer didn't create it. Triggering a chain reaction inside a cloud isn't the same as producing the cloud itself. As for the drilling argument, I already mathematically proved that it's a weak feat. You completely ignore that argument, which is trolling.

Originally posted by h1a8
You also can't move faster than your reflexes allow. Humans can guide FTL ships in space because the distances are vast, but they couldn't navigate through a house at those speeds.

Doesn't matter as he goes intangible. He flew straight through a building. And he flies faster than HT who can out race rockets and missiles.

So yeah very unlikely Superman will get a punch on him.

Originally posted by h1a8
2. Superman can hit extremely hard while others appear statued. He retains his strength, and due to the velocity, the kinetic energy behind his punches would be astronomical. Superman's punch speed was nearly matching the propagation speed of the lightning around Flash.

That's not enough to effect someone who travels at light speed.

Originally posted by h1a8
3. I'm not claiming Superman can't be transmuted by Surfer. Transmuting human-level material doesn't prove being able to transmute steel or vastly more durable substances. If you claim Surfer can transmute Superman, you need to show him doing so to something comparably durable.

4. Characters don't get special attributes without evidence. You're assigning Surfer the durability to tank a 500-ton punch without being KO'd, with no proof. That's not how it works.
Surfer can't just go intangible before being hit, especially if Superman doesn't give him the chance. Even if allowed, Surfer must be tangible to attack, meaning he's vulnerable during the fight.

You're the one giving special attributes to Superman. That he can't be absorbed by his board, or tansmutated himself.

At least I have Surfer (or Doom with Surfer's power) easily handling super strength punches of someone who can lift the London Eye. And easily damaging and transmutating such beings.

You have nothing from Superman to compare.

Originally posted by h1a8
7. Now you're trolling. The cloud was already there; Surfer didn't create it. Triggering a chain reaction inside a cloud isn't the same as producing the cloud itself. As for the drilling argument, I already mathematically proved that it's a weak feat. You completely ignore that argument, which is trolling.

You aint mathematically proved shit. Maths no one can argue, yet you can't concinve anyone you have any kind of valid math or arguments.

Keep trolling troll.

Oh and Surfer stomps. Keep crying over it.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Doesn't matter as he goes intangible. He flew straight through a building. And he flies faster than HT who can out race rockets and missiles.

So yeah very unlikely Superman will get a punch on him.

That's not enough to effect someone who travels at light speed.

You're the one giving special attributes to Superman. That he can't be absorbed by his board, or tansmutated himself.

At least I have Surfer (or Doom with Surfer's power) easily handling super strength punches of someone who can lift the London Eye. And easily damaging and transmutating such beings.

You have nothing from Superman to compare.

You aint mathematically proved shit. Maths no one can argue, yet you can't concinve anyone you have any kind of valid math or arguments.

Keep trolling troll.

Oh and Surfer stomps. Keep crying over it.

You ignored 1.
It explains the concept of acceleration. Surfer and HT need time to build up speed. Missiles are orders of magnitude slower than both Flash and lightning. You can't move faster than your reflexes allow. Humans can navigate FTL ships through space but can't do so within a house.

2. Surfer travels at light speed in space (not in an atmosphere) and after spending time building up to that speed. He gets punched hard and KO'd.

3. I've never stated that Superman can't be absorbed into the board. He won't be, because Surfer will be a statue or slow-moving to him. Superman will knock him out right after the bell. I didn't claim that Superman is immune to Surfer's transmutation. I'm merely stating that you must prove that Surfer can transmute someone as durable as Superman since you're claiming he can. Maybe he can, maybe he can't. This argument is irrelevant due to Superman knocking Surfer out at the start of the bell.

4. The London Eye is orders of magnitude weaker than Superman. Thing knocked Doom off the board in one punch. He failed to transmute Thing (who's less durable than Superman) while being able to transmute humans - which proves my earlier point.

You ignored 5.
You have to prove Surfer's acceleration in an atmosphere and also his reflex speed. Without such proof, he doesn't get the special attribute of being able to react to Flash-like speed in a forum fight.

You ignored 6.
You have to prove Surfer's acceleration in space that can be used to calculate the G-force acting on him. Otherwise, he doesn't get the special attribute of withstanding Superman-level punches.

7. So the cloud was already there. We have that established.

It took Surfer 2–3 days to drill 5 holes. That averages about 8 to 12 hours per hole. This adds up, given that Doom was able to reach Greenland by helicopter to confront Surfer. Visually, each hole appears to be roughly 350–500 feet in diameter and about 800 - 1000 feet deep (we actually see the bottom of the hole in Greenland from the sky).

Since steel is like tissue paper to Superman, dirt, ice, and soil would be vastly weaker. Superman can dig such holes in a matter of seconds to minutes considering his speed in relation to lightning. I fail to see how digging big holes in hours translates to Surfer being able to hurt Superman.

I like how you ignore key points that completely undermine your argument and instead focus on the ones you think you can counter. Some of the points you attempt to address are irrelevant to the fact that Superman simply knocks out Surfer right after the bell.

Originally posted by tkitna
Can the Surfer hurt Superman if Superman just stood there without fighting back? Apparently H1 feels there's no way that Surfer can even harm Superman and i'm curious as to what the masses think.
Originally posted by h1a8
1. Surfer would be statued in this fight.

2. He has no feats showing he can blast-vaporize someone with Superman-level durability.

Superman either one-shots him off the board or one-shots him outright.

Why would Superman do any such thing, when the whole point of th ethread is that Superman is just standing there trying to resist /tank attacks?

^Correct! I got the two threads mixed up. Good catch.

Originally posted by carver9
I dont believe you. You just say anything and if anyone takes anything you say as fact, they are crazy. You type anything and ignore all that goes against anything you say. Its such a waste of time debating you. The movie forum has the mental strength of a honey bagger by giving you their time debating you for pages.
Crazy thing is, you might as well be addressing yourself here and you'd be 100% correct 😛

Originally posted by carver9
Surfer created a blast that killed a being that dwarfed earth in size. Surger could hold back most of his power and kill Superman. Superman literally died by a nuke and was knocked out by an oil tanker falling on him. He was also turned to dust from the mother boxes exploding.

Sometimes I wonder if you actually believe what you type.

So what do people think of this thread?

Originally posted by h1a8
Some of the points you attempt to address are irrelevant to the fact that Superman simply knocks out Surfer right after the bell.

Prove it Troll.