Is ***** Dead or Did He Dissaperate AS He Was Falling Into the Veil???

ok listen here!! everyone has their own right to an OPINION! so dont get huufy with us for sharing our thoughts on the subject!! jk did say he was dead but...she may have been implying a different kind of death!! ever think of it like that.. his charecter dead til she decides to bring him back saying putting him on hold for a while

RIGHT 🙂

thank u .....u brought that to my attention!!

YOUR WELCOME 🙂

hmm.. if the veil is sumthin to separate the dead's n the ones who live, I dun think even wizards can disapparate.
I mean, if he really can, then evrybody can, including James n Lilly. I'm sure he's dead (took me 2 weeks to get dat settle in my broken heart.. still not over it, tho.. *sighs* ) but as for wut Luna said to Harry bout her n her mom, I'm sure it means sumthin. JKR never really writes sumthing for nothing, ait?!

wow, thats very possible, luce, but y would um 'the ded guy' do such a thing 2 harry? he was so depressed and in denial the whole time! man i felt 4 harry, ****** wud NEVER do such a horrible thing 2 him, if he did and suprised harry by appearing, harry would tottally HATE him 😠, catch my drift?

its tottally mean 2 fake a death...

I dont think he faked it..... I just dont think he's dead..... good points though. 🙂

ok,this is my opionion...
thee veil was like a gate to the world of the dead,thats why harry saw thos shadows.BUT,since **** wasnt dead when he passed into the dead world,maybe theres still some chance for him to go back.also,i had dis idea,maybe in one of the next books,harry takes a spacial potion that kills him,and he goes into the dead world,helps sirus,and then harry takes another potion witch revives him.AlSO,are there wizzard gravyards at all,if so, why doesnt harry ever visit his parants' graves?

my opion is that he is dead but some how he will end up comming back and luna's thing about her mom and well it means sumthing i don't know what!

wut bout luna's mom?
cant remember wut was da deal wit her

i thought in book 4 they were in a grave yard b/c his grave had already been dug by voldemort..... maybe i interpreted it wrong....

hmmm,maybe, but i think that graveyard was a muggle one,i think it was th one in the town voldemort's house was in,but can i cant recall there being any wizzard graves cept that....

MAYBE THE VEIL IS THEIR GRAVEYARD! JUST THOUGHT OF THAT.....

WOW i never thought of that....this calls for new theories

yeah i know

meybe they chuck the bodies trough the veil?

yep he disaperated no Qs asked! does n e 1 think that crookshanks is an animagi.it would solve alot of probs as 1.thats how he could communicate with sirius 2.thats how he new where scabbers was and 3. thats how he new scabbers was peter pettigrew!!! 💃 💃 💃 💃 💃

sirius just cant b dead cause he disapperated!!!! i love sirius and gary oldman

umm animals can sence stuff,and i guess the cat was very inteligent and uunderstood what sirust ments,i mean its a frigin wizzard world

i wonder if crookshanks is an animagi...b/c remember the storekeeper had the cat for a LONG time and no one wanted it.....except hermoine...so i think maybe something will come about with that one...

BUT the rat was an animagi..peter...so i dont know if JKR will redo the same kind of thing...doesn't seem like she would......