Is ***** Dead or Did He Dissaperate AS He Was Falling Into the Veil???

so i dont understand that if its like that

its not,cuz sirus would have told the rest of the ppl

well...sirius only knew about pettigrew b/c of his missing toe...so sirius would not necessarily know...but i dont think JKR would repeat something...but tis a possibility.........hrmmmmmmmmmm??

i think that sirius may not have disapparated because well there wasnt a really loud crack and harry would have heard it if there was, also lupin and all them are all like hes gone to harry, but i think there will be a way to either save him or get him back, do u guys remember the mirror he gave harry to communicate with him and then it didnt work and harry broke it in his trunk, well harry didnt throw it out did he, he threw it into his trunk and its probably still there and might work again, maybe sirius jus didnt use it at the second when harry tried 😕 i really do hope they bring him back and hes proved innocent because then hed be able to become his hot and sexy self 😍 he my favourite character and i dont think he got enough attention so far in the books 😛

maybe,harry seeks voldemort's help,becouse he knows how to bring him back,so haary trades him sometnig valuable for help

thats a theory but i doubt that because its his fault sirius is gone or so they think 😛

sooo,voldemort really wants whatever,so harry gets it for him,and V-guy brings back S-dude

Accually If Harry was going to go to Voldemort then that would be the last person he would go to... Are you getting me? And I was just thinking...... Wormtail still ows Harry his life so..... Maybe if somebody could trade Sirius places it could me Wormtail!!!!........ Just thinking...... But I allready know that Wormtail will give his life away probally in the 7th book....... what do yah think?
-Tonks

i hate to say it but i think J K has killed him, I mean she cant put the readers through all that then make it so he never dies.... its like a story that ends with "but it was just a dream"

if he was alive i mean

did that make sense?

I agree. Sirius is definately dead. And even tho he was my favourite character I still think he wouldn't have disapperated. It's like mg16 said, he wouldn't put Harry through that. I would hate to see sirius come back to life. It really annoys me when someone dies and then comes back to life. It would be cool to see him come back as a memory or something but not back to life. I also think that mirror has something to do with it because J.K wouldn't have added it in for no reson. and lastly I think the veil being the magical graveyard is a great idea.

he can't be dead

Of course he is dead. Don't you remember how JK said before book 5 was released that: "A major character will die in this one." If Sirius is alive that would make her a liar.

yeah, i think hes dead....i was so mad though when harry broke his mirror sirius gave him!!

i neva thought that he could dissapparate

Originally posted by Lokia
The Room has to be called the Death Room for a reason seriously... I think people may dissipear behind it and never come back... therefore dissipearing from this world.

'nuff said.

Originally posted by zombieman
Of course he is dead. Don't you remember how JK said before book 5 was released that: "A major character will die in this one." If Sirius is alive that would make her a liar.

what is jk god? she can't lie? (srry it just sounded funny, "jk can't lie!!"😉

🙄

I think sirius is really dead, becuase jk really does not strike me as the "happily fixed ever after" type writer, real tragedies happen in her books. though i would like sirius back as much as the next huge fan of his!! (I was so devastated when he died, i bawled my eyes out!!)

Oh and a cool thing, i think sirius will somehow be tied into the end (not brought back neccisarily). Becuase on her web site jk said about the mirror (why harry did not remember it before doing all he did) "It didn't do as much as you thought, but it will do more than you think" or something almost exactly like that. 😄 I can't wait to find out what she means!