Silmarillion fans

Started by shadow link5 pages

it would be very hard to do this in a movie probably best for a tv show but if done right it could be a worl wide phenominon and all that

love the book, very poetic

Originally posted by turin
movie #1 beren and luthien
movie #2 tale of turin (include battle of unnumbered tears)
movie #3 tale of tuor (include war of wrath)
movie #4 tale of numenor
movie #5 the begining up to the fall of fingolfin, this being the last since it would most likely be the least popular

Hm, that's good, but what with the silmarilli in context with Lúthien?

yea but what producer's gonna sponser it?? after all it would be horrible if there wer bad special effects...

yeah it would only work if they had special effects as good or better than lord of rings, but if they did think of the ratings, a cure for all those suffering from post lotr movies

Bumpity bump bump fixing the forum la la laaaaa

😂 Good idea... has been ages since we last talked about the Silmarillion 😊

Soooo what were we talking about... Silmarillion films? ... I changed my opinion on that, I prefer not having one... the Silmarillion is a perfect book, too perfect for a film. Could only spoil things and ruin imaginations by providing too many new pix.

And about the original topic... I love the story of Eol and his son Maeglin ✅ I think Maeglin is a fascinating character and gets paid far too little attention ✅

My new fav part beside the Fall of Gondolin, Túrins Story and the deaths of the different Elven Kings is the Akallabêth... brilliant story, the Fall of Númenor ✅

😱 I was wondering if there was this topic!

LORDY!! You rock! 😍 Thanks for the topic bump hehe

So do you Exa 😄

The Valar are cool 😄 Nienna 😛

😂 🙂

Originally posted by Nienna

The Valar are cool 😄 Nienna 😛

YEY Nienna is the best of all Valier ✅ definitely... the rest is kinda boring... so are the Valar... except for Melkor ✅ ~ Aule is also sometimes cool though. And Ulmo. And Mandos. DOOM!

(Silmarillion: "So it is doomed" < Mandos ^^)

i enojy reading mostly of melkor and sauron, dark lords 🙂
i just enjoy their cruelty, the way they do not flinch when they bring down a whole civiliasation 🙂

my favourite sauron line would have to be when he tells grimbold to tell him the whereabouts of *cough* and he will unite him with his wife, grimbold sings like a well fed canary and sauron tells him he will go to his wife, who is dead....then has him killed lol 😛

Oooh this is one of the few, few scenes where I really see Morgoth and Sauron as enemies who should be defeated... that's just too cruel and unfair 🙁

One of my fav parts is also the singing competition between Sauron and Finrod 🙂
... and of course the Kinslaying of Alqualonde. Wonderfully sad story... and the Doom of the Noldor and the Prophecy of the North 😱 😱 GREAT IS THE FALL OF GONDOLIN

it is cruel and unfair, but that is what they are mr frod-----lady exa, and i believe that showed them in all their cruelty...which is how hey should always have been shown.
i love the way melkor realises killing hurin would be too good, so he enslaves him-torturous lol

and curses his kin
thats one bad thing to do
getting sombodys kids

Heheee yea the story of Húrin is great... also unfair and cruel but an excellent story 😊

I love the descriptions of Túrins journeys....

i like the music of the ainur
melkors uprising lol

iluvatars face grew stern...angry...and loth to look upon

"But thou, Melkor, shalt discover the secret thoughts of thy mind, and shalt perceive that they are but a pant of the whole and tributary to its glory..."

About the númenóreans -
"And they built mightier houses for their dead than for their living, and endowed their buried kings with unawailing trasure; for their wise men hoped still to discover the secret of prolonging life, and maybe of recalling it..."

"Death is their fate, the gift of Ilúvatar, which as time wears even the Powers shall envy"

"Few ever changed his courses by counsel, none by force"

"Never did Melkor forget that this war was made for the sake of the eles, and that they were the cause of his downfall"

... practically each sentence is a perfect quote in the Silmarillion...

the kinslaying- galadriel was there that day, but she took no part in that evil

YEY the Kinslaying is great 😱

"So it is doooooomed" 😛 (Mandos)

i think thats what happened

mandos: so it is dooooomed
galadriel: *years later* yes littl elrond, and then mandos said it is dooomed
elrond: wow-nice word, will remember it
elrond: at counsil it is hopeles.....i mean doooooomed!

Originally posted by sauron
i think thats what happened

mandos: so it is dooooomed
galadriel: *years later* yes littl elrond, and then mandos said it is dooomed
elrond: wow-nice word, will remember it
elrond: at counsil it is hopeles.....i mean doooooomed!

😆

As far as I remember, Mandos uses it quite often... and so does Manwe 😖 😖

thats because manwe steals others words because he was tragically created without a personality