Both Thor and Orion are warriors-to-the-bone, whether fighting h2h or long-range. They're comfortable in either arena. 2 points for each.
Captain Marvel is basically a h2h fighter. Does he have any ranged abilities? I don't think he can "shazam" down a lightning bolt at a distance, otherwise, why does he usually wait til his opponent is near before shouting the magic word? CM gets 1 pt.
The Surfer is a long-range fighter. He has surprisingly good h2h skills, but again: both his opponents are trained warriors, likely his superiors in this area. Soarin' Norrin gets 1 pt.
4 > 2.
__________________
Shinier than a speeding bullet.
Team 2 for the win. And by some margin too.
Surfer's faster and more durable than anyone here.
He can attack from more angles, his board can KO or trap either Thor or Orion and he can easily destroy Orion's harness with a simple thought.
Since when can a Motherbox turn CM into Billy? If thats actually happened as canon, then clearly Team 2 has no chance here, and these teams are pretty lopsided.
There was an instance when Billy couldn't change into Captain Marvel, so he used someone's MB to help him change. Or it could be the other way. Either way, Billy isn't beating Orion. Orion himself could give Surfer a good fight. Same with Thor.