ROTJ Luke vs AOTC Ani

Started by Admiral Akbar5 pages

That I agree with. ROTJ did nothing impressive, anakin fought during the clone wars. Luke sat back and trained.. Why do people think Luke is better?

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
That I agree with. ROTJ did nothing impressive, anakin fought during the clone wars. Luke sat back and trained.. Why do people think Luke is better?

Bias, really. A lot of people like Luke, and he is the hero of the OT. But saying he is good enough to compete with a PT jedi is ludicrous. Hell, GL himself supposively said that the PT jedi are better than the OT. This would make everyone weaker in the OT, including Vader, Ben, and Luke, then their respective counterparts of the PT era.

In Luke's case, he would just plain be on the bottom.

totally, but there was no republic to train new jedi in OT. The empire killed of almost every jedi.. but I was wondering..

Coruscant has the jedi council and all, but are there other places in the galaxy like dantooine were other jedi trained? I read the dark horse comics and there were some wierd ass jedi in there. One of them said
"You coruscant jedi take your time dont you." Where else do the jedi camp at. What planets?

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
totally, but there was no republic to train new jedi in OT. The empire killed of almost every jedi.. but I was wondering..

Coruscant has the jedi council and all, but are there other places in the galaxy like dantooine were other jedi trained? I read the dark horse comics and there were some wierd ass jedi in there. One of them said
"You coruscant jedi take your time dont you." Where else do the jedi camp at. What planets?

Supposively on Dantooine, Arkania, and a few other places. But the main one by the time of the PT is on Corsucant, I think, because of the lower number of jedi in comparison to the other times.

How many Jedi were there just before the Great Sith War?

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
How many Jedi were there just before the Great Sith War?

Great Sith War? Is that the one with Exar Kun? There were literally tens of thousands in the attack team on Yavin alone.

Yes, The Great Sith War was the one with Kun.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Yes, The Great Sith War was the one with Kun.

Well, the numbers were considerable. But of course they were pretty much wiped out between that war and the Jedi civil War. This probably greatly contributed to the low number of jedi in the PT era, since strong Force sensitivity is inherited.

Originally posted by Deus Ex
Supposively on Dantooine, Arkania, and a few other places. But the main one by the time of the PT is on Corsucant, I think, because of the lower number of jedi in comparison to the other times.

They were better than ROTS obi.... It was just weird.. Mace was considered the 2nd best jedi... but who knows there were other out there.

That doesn't make much sense to me. The Chu'unthor had the capability to house 10,000 Jedi. I don't think that it was the Jedi main training area.

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
They were better than ROTS obi.... It was just weird.. Mace was considered the 2nd best jedi... but who knows there were other out there.

I was also wondering that about KOTOR. Revan is the most important person in the galaxy at that time, yet he isn't being handled by the Jedi Council of Coruscant. I think Janus, you gave somesort of answer in this, but I don't remember what it was.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
I was also wondering that about KOTOR. Revan is the most important person in the galaxy at that time, yet he isn't being handled by the Jedi Council of Coruscant. I think Janus, you gave somesort of answer in this, but I don't remember what it was.

I think the jedi were hiding out at Dantooine, regardless of what Bastila says. And in any case, most of the surviving jedi masters on the council at Dantooine were also on the Council at Coruscant. I think they were just in exile for the time being, because of the war.

I forgot.... did bastila say the council in couruscant or did the dantooine masters say that

Well, Bastila said the jedi were safe at dantooine, but they weren't. And considering many of the jedi masters who presided over the Exile's Banishment at the end of the Mandalorian wars included a few Dantooine jedi masters.

Anyone have any thoughts on why the Chu'unthor had the ability to house 10,000 when there were other academies and it was only 300 or 400 years before PT when they had about 10,000.

But in Kotor 2 it showed the coruscant jedi council and the dantooine jedi were not in it..

Notice that over half of the Coruscant Council seats were empty.

yeah I noticed that.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Anyone have any thoughts on why the Chu'unthor had the ability to house 10,000 when there were other academies and it was only 300 or 400 years before PT when they had about 10,000.

What's this now?

I don't recognize the name Chu'hunthor.

Originally posted by Deus Ex
What's this now?

I don't recognize the name Chu'hunthor.

Neather do I...