"In vain? But what a GLORIOUS death it would be," says the Elf (whose inner light, incidentally, shines brighter than that of the average Elf). "Worthy of a song, I feel, at least. Half a million, a million, TEN million- what difference?
"Oh, unless you meant... you feel your death might be better spent elsewhere? But could that be so, in a war without hope? Is that not how we have portrayed it hear?"
"Please," says Elrond, "calm yourself. I doubt even you could take on the Witch-King and his host, and prevail alone."
"Nonetheless," he says. "If asked to I would try. Which is more than I can say for all gathered here. So I must ask... why HAVE they gathered here? To here again what they already know? That Angmar is evil, that men are dying, that we intend to do nothing? We needed no meeting for that."
"Elrond called us to this meeting," says the Elf from Lorien.
"And you came. And you came because you want to see what we will do, and that means that you do have options, regardless of the 'convenants' of the past. They are not written in stone and blood any more, Our kind do not have to kill or stand by whilst others die simply on a word spoken in a forgotten past."
"We have not forgotten," says the Elf from Lorien.
"Then it is better that you do," says the golden-haired Elf. "This is Man's Age now, as we are all keen to say. 500 years is many lifetimes."
"So, you would march us to war and death?"
"No," says the Elf. "If only I thought we could prevail I would. But Orcs are growing more numerous throughout Middle-Earth, especially in the Mountains near here. We now have riders all along the rivers to keep back the Orcs who prey at our borders. We cannot even maintain the Last Bridge any further- it has fallen to Dunlendings.
"But I am saying we cannot pretend we are seperated from this world. After all, why have we not sailed west? Why are the havens maintained? To be an ever unattainable glimpe of paradise to the mortal races? No. We maintain that which was, that is true, but we also are here because the legacy of the connection between Elf and Man is not quite yet fully spent. And should the time be right, we MUST be willing to fight for his sake."
"That time will never come," says the Elf from Lorien.
"I say it will," says the golden-haired Elf. "I say it will, and I say we can help." He points at Vardalain and Palanfirith. "These Elves have been living with Man for a year, something none of the rest of us can say, and they say that we can aid Man. The Master of Horses here has ridden far from his lands to see what happens in Arnor, and offer his services. What does this say about the unification of Man? You say it is impossible, but the spirit of its possibility sits here with you. And come the right time, I will not be afraid to fight. How many of you would stand with me, I wonder?"