The Official Shipping Debate Thread [merged]

Started by pumpkinpie4ever191 pages

night the point is you say ginny wanted to be with harry if she was in love with him in the GoF its surely over. and besides i agree with katie and dark( kinda predictable) anyway again if ginny was in fact in love with him it is over. just like hermione and krum; harry and cho; ron and hermione. although krum is mentioned in the 5th book i dont think he'll come back but JK did say it was a possiblility.

Originally posted by KKdave
Haha thanks Steph! And thanks to Dark too, when dealing with people like TheSun I think reinforcements are a must. In my opinion I havent seen a lot of interactions that would make me think harry and ginny have any kind of connection, or deeper relationship, then her being rons little sister and thereby associated with their group of friends. I think ginny is becoming more important to the books, but I still don't think she'd be able to pass hermione up as the most important girl.

ding ding ding we have a winner! hehe just joking but exactly right and your welcome i think we all need back up when it comes to ppl like that.
NO GIRL CAN PASS HERMIONE WHEN IT COMES TO IMPORTANCE IN HARRYS LIFE. AND EVEN IF HE DID GET ANOTHER GIRLFRIEND SHE WOULD BE JEALOUS OF HERMIONE LIKE CHO. and that is why harrys best choice is to be with hermione its most logical (and not because its obvious) because they can understand each other maybe not like a boi/girl friend relationship now but watch in the next book.

God, I said don't use the damn quote! EVERYONE WAS WITH THE WRONG PERSON! Who was Ginny with? Neville, not Harry. Your not going to shoot my down about Harry and Ginny, no matter what. Just like I can't shoot you guys down on Harry and Hermione. That quote doesn't go for Harry and Ginny. And don't say, "Oh, since Ginny was with Neville, she has to be over Harry", yea well it doesn't really mean that. She could be tired of waiting and checking to see if there is anyone she likes like Harry, and that doesn't mean she is over him. Hermione said she was over Harry, Hermione could mean be trying to stop anything between Harry and Ginny. Until I hear Ginny say she is through with him... no.. until I hear JKR say Ginny is over him or the books end before anything happens between them, I wont stop going for Harry and Ginny.

night, take a chill pill okay....just calm down....alright if your done....no ones forcing you to stop beliveing in our ship....okay....as far as im conserened every one still has the same ship......just calm okay?

Yes, but did my point get through? Sometimes I need to shout to get noticed in a crowd of H/Hr people.

i understand kinda but i still my point remains....its just the fact that there are only four h/hr shippers....katie, hermione, dark, and myself.... i know theres only you and phoenix for the harry/ginny thing....maybe we should all try a new perspective...BUT NOT SAYING TO CHANGE SHIPS...I AND MOST PPL ARE TO STUBBORN TO DO THAT....i wish there were more harry and hermione fourms that were still active all those fourms are dead....i know there are ginny and harry fourms not sure if there active though...i dont really want to enter it and find out either.

i wish the moderators would speed up the seperate shipper threads so we could like compare evidence then show it to the public or something....that'd be fun or at least i think so.

We need more Harry Ginny peoples.

Originally posted by pumpkinpie4ever
night, take a chill pill okay....

😆 😆 That's such a good phrase...chill pill.. hahaha.. nice. And yeah, I know that we're all way too stubbron to change our opinions, so I'm going to stop arguing with people until book 6 comes out and we all have new evidence to agrue about, because at this point we're all just beating a dead horse. All that I do when I agrue with someone is make people angry, and thats not what I'm here to do. But beware, after July 16th I'm going to be back into full fledged argue mode! 😄

I think I will do the same as KKdave. That's why I wanted to take a short break from here (which didn't happen). I will stop arguing about the subject, though I find it rather annoying about people saying stuff about Harry and Hermione and other people agreeing. Besides Phoe, i'm all alone with the Harry Ginny thing. Phoe is only shipping it because she ships R/Hr. I have no one who is a Harry/Ginny fan, because they like the couple, to back me up. I guess saying it is annoying is sort of a childish thing to say, but look at it from my point of view. I'm basically a one army man fighting agaisnt a army of three.

Originally posted by TheSun
So everyone can judge except me? That sounds a bit hypocritical to me.

No. You see, when you try and judge yourself, it tends to be extremely inaccurate.

Dark, why don't we just report him to the Mods? I've had enough of it, we've warned him and been polite for too long, and it's obviously not working.

katie i couldnt agree with you more... im getting really tired of his nonsense its getting on my last nerve. just report him im pretty sure everyones sick of it. yeah basicly we are just beating a dead horse...hehe i like that phraise its cool. im only going on here to talk at least until book 6 comes out. THEN COMES THE WARS...HEHE HERE IS A POEM DETICATED TO HP 6.

its a dream come true for us hp fans,
harry potter 6 comes out july i6 2005,
wars will arise from goodship to pumpkin pie,
rivals and allies here on that day,
only to argue about our own way,
its ron and hermione or harry and hermione,
the subjects not important,
but we still care,
the subject will be forever there,
when the wars all over and done,
only to those who are against us will be shunned,
love forever faithful,
love forever pure,
it is important forever more,
that is why we argue that is why we fight,
we all argue from mornig to night,
this is what we do in our spare time,
now im done with this poem because im running out of rhymes.

I'm not sure if I'm aloud saying this, but I Phoe told he she dealt with TheSun. So we have no worries at all.

hello guys back again so ive been reading the last msgs and someone ask where is the link of the quote "Everyone is in love withe the wrong person" so here it goes

http://www.quick-quote-quill.org/articles/1999/0199-scotlandsunday-goring.html

When she talks of Harry Potter, his imagined life is clearly more interesting to her than her own. She talks as though he's within earshot: respectfully and with affection: "Harry is changing as he's getting older. He and his friends are 14 now and their hormones are kicking in, so it's really fun to write about. Everyone's in love with the wrong person, it's brilliant."

http://www.quick-quote-quill.org/articles/1999/0999-barnesnoble-staff.htm

Dear Ms. Rowling, I'd like to ask if there would be a lot of romances between the characters in the upcoming books?
Good question. I'm having so much fun writing Book 4 because for the first time Harry, Ron, and Hermoine are starting to recognize boys and girls as boys and girls. Everyone is in love with the wrong people. Let no one say my books lack realism.

http://www.quick-quote-quill.org/articles/1999/0999-time-gray.html

Yes, Rowling acknowledges, Harry is on the brink of adolescence and will fall into that hormonal morass any day now. Harry and friends will notice, and do more than notice, members of the opposite sex, and the action starts inBook Four where they all fall in love with the wrong people. A foolishly smitten or moony Harry may challenge the devotion of the readers who admire his innocent, boyish virtues and unflappable dignity, except, perhaps, those readers who have grown into adolescents themselves.

http://www.quick-quote-quill.org/articles/1999/1099-columbusdisp-gilson.html

[/quote]Q: Will Harry find romance in book four?
A: He tries, but he doesn't get very far.

They're all kind of after the wrong people, as in life. Hermione gets the first date, and it's quite a cool one because I thought I owed her a bit of fun.[/quote]

Everyone is in love with the wrong people [in GoF]. Let no one say my books lack realism.

Part of the reason it's so much fun to write is that they're discovering their hormones. And they're mainly in love with all the wrong people, just to make it lifelike.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

nice poem ppf

Too bad TheSun wont be able to read it. Oh well, I'm confused on this quote now. ^.^

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
I think I will do the same as KKdave. That's why I wanted to take a short break from here (which didn't happen). I will stop arguing about the subject, though I find it rather annoying about people saying stuff about Harry and Hermione and other people agreeing. Besides Phoe, i'm all alone with the Harry Ginny thing. Phoe is only shipping it because she ships R/Hr. I have no one who is a Harry/Ginny fan, because they like the couple, to back me up. I guess saying it is annoying is sort of a childish thing to say, but look at it from my point of view. I'm basically a one army man fighting agaisnt a army of three.

Yeah I find that all annoying too with the Harry and Hermione thing. But I see why you believe Harry likes Ginny. I was reading the fifth book when I went to Disney World for the past two weeks, so I understand the whole Harry liking Ginny thing. I still don't understand the Harry and Hermione concept. I certainly missed a lot on this thread. What's been going on since I was gone?

4 - allowed himself to be stunned by Harry a million and one times, is hidden in lake. ((Anyone else notice how Hermione is NOT Harry's most treasured person - if he secretly or subconciously loved her, it would be Hermy down there))

Ah, yes. That's one thing I forgot about. good one pheonix.

Well... look who it is. Long time no see Rupert Lover.

hey ppls hey hermione thanx 4 the complement and katie thanx 4 reviewing my story to bad there are only 4 ppl who support out ship me,katie, hermione, and dark i think. does anyone i mean anyone know where an active h/hr fourm is....nothing'll beat kmc fourms but i need to talk to my own ppl 4 a little and if i find one katie, hermione i'll tell ya and if dark ships it i'll tell you to.

I don't know of one, haha but it would be nice to "talk to our own people" for awhile. But yeah, for sure let me know if you find one 😄