The Official Shipping Debate Thread [merged]

Started by NightCrawler341191 pages

Imaginary!

Ok, this is kind of weird, but here but this little pic... smilie thing is like when everyone found out about H/G in the book. The kool aid dude is my, the others are H/Hr shippers (sorry but I am just doing this to get laughs) kool-msn

I was reading the last pg.
wow great fight, night vs TS

Originally posted by hermione7
I was reading the last pg.
wow great fight, night vs TS
Get ready for another round soon. Trust me, it doesn't take long for me and TS to get into fights.

um, do you ENJOY fighting TS or something, Night?

At times, yes.

Is it possible that Ginny in fact planted a LOVE POTION!

Fred/Gorge's rooms- Though a large vase flowers had been placed in a desk in front of a small window, their perfume could not disguise the smell the lingering smell of what Harry thought was gunpowder.

HBPp.183 They chose the nearest a gold-cauldron that was emitting one of the most seductive smells Harry ever inhaled😖omehow reminded him simultaneously of a treacle tart, the woody smell of a broomstick, and a flowery sent he might have smelled at the burrow(i don't have the book in front of me i turned it back into the library)

Slughorn- Slughorn caused the fiasco. He wasn't necessarily working for Voldemort but screwed up Harry's life up big time.He forced hermione out of his life and look where he is now. Dumbledor died because Harry wasn't able to figure out what was happining around him because the brain behind Harry which is Hermione was taken away...By Ron.

Is it not possible that Slughorn knowing how much Ginivera Weasley liked Mr.Potter planted the potion in the cauldron to coufuse him? Is that why all the school is acting akward?Maybe they got a wiff of that potion...Is it not possible?I think it is very possible, we all knkow that Ginny had a crush on Harry but she didnt seem to care when he dumped her...Did Harry even once say "I Love You, Ginny"? and you notice this love is out of the blue there was no build up to get there it just came up! which was as obvious as a blue moon! Or Perhaps Ms. Granger got a wiff of the flowers also...Is it possible that she then after that started to go out of character? I know Hermione is not the person to act childishly why the sudden change?And that concludes my Theroy exit stage left but the water fountian.

Originally posted by pumpkinpie4ever
Is it possible that Ginny in fact planted a LOVE POTION!

[b]Fred/Gorge's rooms- Though a large vase flowers had been placed in a desk in front of a small window, their perfume could not disguise the smell the lingering smell of what Harry thought was gunpowder.

HBPp.183 They chose the nearest a gold-cauldron that was emitting one of the most seductive smells Harry ever inhaled😖omehow reminded him simultaneously of a treacle tart, the woody smell of a broomstick, and a flowery sent he might have smelled at the burrow(i don't have the book in front of me i turned it back into the library)

Slughorn- Slughorn caused the fiasco. He wasn't necessarily working for Voldemort but screwed up Harry's life up big time.He forced hermione out of his life and look where he is now. Dumbledor died because Harry wasn't able to figure out what was happining around him because the brain behind Harry which is Hermione was taken away...By Ron.

Is it not possible that Slughorn knowing how much Ginivera Weasley liked Mr.Potter planted the potion in the cauldron to coufuse him? Is that why all the school is acting akward?Maybe they got a wiff of that potion...Is it not possible?I think it is very possible, we all knkow that Ginny had a crush on Harry but she didnt seem to care when he dumped her...Did Harry even once say "I Love You, Ginny"? and you notice this love is out of the blue there was no build up to get there it just came up! which was as obvious as a blue moon! Or Perhaps Ms. Granger got a wiff of the flowers also...Is it possible that she then after that started to go out of character? I know Hermione is not the person to act childishly why the sudden change?And that concludes my Theroy exit stage left but the water fountian. [/B]

honestly! if Ginny planted a love potion for Harry, because she would've known, then why did she continue dating Dean? and Harry didn't really stop liking her, he just had to give her up because he knew it would be too dangerous to be around ANYONE. That's why he didn't want Ron and Hermione coming along. and Ginny understood Harry's meaning, only meaning that she understood what Harry needed to do, which means they understood eachother. And notice when Ron accidentally ate those chocolate cauldrons, he was acting like he was obsessed with Romilda vane! plus, do you know how many times Ginny would have to sneak the potion into his food? and I doubt Ginny would do something as sneaky as that! that's as low as you can get! And Harry was developing a crush on ginny since the train ride, and he didn't fully understand it, which if you had the love potion you'd automatically fall in love with the person, from what we saw of Ron, he knew who he liked instantly. and you got to drink the potion, not smell it. Or else everyone in the potions class would've fell in love with Slughorn, or whoever made the love potion, which would be silly. And that doesn't explain why Hermione got jealous of Ron going out with lavender. and she stopped Mclaggen from getting in because she wanted Ron to get on the team, probably. and she was white faced, Jaw-clenched, and frightened looking (not to mention crying, if you didn't notice 'Hermione sniffed' in that one sentence) when Ron got poisoned. and she blushed when he said, "I love you, Hermione." so really, she's doing these childish antics because she's falling in love.

good try though. 😄

For the first time, I disagree with a fellow H/Hr.

Although that part where we find out what turns Harry and Hermione on is pretty funny.

Harry: Treacle tart, broomsticks, ginny's perfume
Hermione: Fresh mown grass, new parchment

Hermione's screams "NERD" at every turn. 😆

Originally posted by #1Rupert_Lover
honestly! if Ginny planted a love potion for Harry, because she would've known, then why did she continue dating Dean? and Harry didn't really stop liking her, he just had to give her up because he knew it would be too dangerous to be around ANYONE. That's why he didn't want Ron and Hermione coming along. and Ginny understood Harry's meaning, only meaning that she understood what Harry needed to do, which means they understood eachother. And notice when Ron accidentally ate those chocolate cauldrons, he was acting like he was obsessed with Romilda vane! plus, do you know how many times Ginny would have to sneak the potion into his food? and I doubt Ginny would do something as sneaky as that! that's as low as you can get! And Harry was developing a crush on ginny since the train ride, and he didn't fully understand it, which if you had the love potion you'd automatically fall in love with the person, from what we saw of Ron, he knew who he liked instantly. and you got to drink the potion, not smell it. Or else everyone in the potions class would've fell in love with Slughorn, or whoever made the love potion, which would be silly. And that doesn't explain why Hermione got jealous of Ron going out with lavender. and she stopped Mclaggen from getting in because she wanted Ron to get on the team, probably. and she was white faced, Jaw-clenched, and frightened looking (not to mention crying, if you didn't notice 'Hermione sniffed' in that one sentence) when Ron got poisoned. and she blushed when he said, "I love you, Hermione." so really, she's doing these childish antics because she's falling in love.

good try though. 😄

That pretty much sums up what I was going to say. It isn't out of character, it is how it is. You think its H/Hr so you think that is is out of character.

Originally posted by DarkCanadian
For the first time, I disagree with a fellow H/Hr.

Although that part where we find out what turns Harry and Hermione on is pretty funny.

Harry: Treacle tart, broomsticks, ginny's perfume
Hermione: Fresh mown grass, new parchment

Hermione's screams "NERD" at every turn. 😆

xD And his turn on being Ginny's perfume... well.... doesn't that kind of say it all?

it's disappointing that he still has his head in the clouds, a little....

What do you mean? He didn't seem much in the clouds to me. He finally chose someone didn't he? And he still loves her, even if he did have to break it off.

maybe Harry's head is no longer in the clouds? Maybe Dumbledore's death was his wake up call to go after Voldemort and kill him.

Good point......but its disappointing to see him going for looks still. I thought that maybe JKR wouldve tried to convey the message that looks aren't everything but oh well.

He didn't go for Ginny because of looks. He went for Ginny because he loves her. If it was for looks Harry and Ginny would be together a long time ago.

Naw, it's because of her character too. But still......I still think that Hermione has a more resolute character than Ginny, and with not as good looks. I would've been happier if he went with her because it would prove that Harry is truly deep of heart, that looks didn't matter. That's all.

Originally posted by DarkCanadian
Naw, it's because of her character too. But still......I still think that Hermione has a more resolute character than Ginny, and with not as good looks. I would've been happier if he went with her because it would prove that Harry is truly deep of heart, that looks didn't matter. That's all.
Do I have to repeat myself. He loved Ginny for Ginny, not for looks. So what if she is better looking than Hermione? Harry didn't have feelings toward her, he had feelings for Ginny.

Originally posted by DarkCanadian
Naw, it's because of her character too.

So Harry likes her for both. That great.He loves her, not Hermione. Seriously, oh well.