The Official Shipping Debate Thread [merged]

Started by Anoushka191 pages

Originally posted by DarkCanadian
For the first time, I disagree with a fellow H/Hr.

Although that part where we find out what turns Harry and Hermione on is pretty funny.

Harry: Treacle tart, broomsticks, ginny's perfume
Hermione: Fresh mown grass, new parchment

Hermione's screams "NERD" at every turn. 😆

crap i remember reading that,which page was it on?

Originally posted by Phoenix
with you witj the ships Anoushka! 😄

oh yeah!💃

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
So Harry likes her for both. That great.He loves her, not Hermione. Seriously, oh well.

Yeah, and it can be a good thing that he goes for both. And whoever Hermione falls in love with, it'll be for who they are as well, because you know how she doesn't like guys for there looks. I doubt she likes Ron for his looks because he's always been described lanky and freckily in the books. so he's probably not supposed to be hot, though I think he looks hot in the movies. oddly enough, she'll like him for who he is, even though they do get into arguments here and there, though that was probably to hide their feelings for one another. And Ron certainly likes Hermione for who she is, because he seemed to look at every other girl who he thinks is a looker, until he got his wake up call when Hermione went out with Viktor. And Hermione must've had her wake up call when Ron dated lavender, maybe even earlier. plus, the relationship grew slowly as well. and they know each other pretty well.

well, like i said im sticking to h/hr and no one or nothings gonna change it... only stating the truth i may not be right this time but i am seriously overly confident on this one...and my fellow h/hrs never let your guard down it may come back to bite you in the arse...like the little switch-a-roo in HBP. which i still say wasnt ment to happen! you can say im in denial or wahtever but my point stands and who evers with me speak now or forever hold your peace i only hope its not to late...katie if your out there you gotta back me up...i dont wanna be the lonelyest beliver with faith.... we dont have much h/hrs anyway

I have faith. But not much hope.

Originally posted by pumpkinpie4ever
i only hope its not to late...katie if your out there you gotta back me up...i dont wanna be the lonelyest beliver with faith.... we dont have much h/hrs anyway

I'm backing you up for sure. I still have faith, and I still believe that they would be the prefect couple, even if for some weird reason, JKR doesn't have them end up together. I feel like H/Hr would be such a deep and meaningful relationship, and she would be the person who Harry could really lean on as he's trying to track down voldemort and such. And yeah the thing that bothers me most about H/G, as Dark has said, is that he only started noticing her and liking her once everyone else in the book did, and she was considered good looking. Harry only seems to go for the good looking, popular girl of the moment (Cho is books 4 & 5, Ginny in 6). So that dissapoints me, I wish he would have more romantic depth. And y'all are going on about how he loves Ginny, but he never said that to her, and they were together for what... 3 weeks... before he breaks it off. So can you really be so deeply in love with somebody by then? I don't think so. I think when push comes to shove and times get hard, Ron and Hermione won't be strong enough to stay together, and Harry and Ginny will fade.

Originally posted by pumpkinpie4ever
i dont wanna be the lonelyest beliver with faith.... we dont have much h/hrs anyway

I know that feeling, cept its H/G. Seriously, everyone either likes them because they are R/Hr shipper. You get used to loneliness!

If you havn't read HBP yet, then don't read this, just in case.

I honestly wasn't expecting R/Hr to get together in HBP, but i knew there would be more hints pointing in that direction, which there were. They will eventually get together, even if its right at the end of book 7 - it's too damn clear now, they've practically said that they love each other (well Ron has anyway lol). And as for H/G, i think that Harry will continue to have feelings for Ginny and hopefully Ginny won't move on; she'll wait for him to defeat Voldemort. Even thought she went out with other people, she did say "I never really gave up on you" to Harry. But who knows, she might decide to go out with other people, but i don't think that's very likely (maybe because i'd like to see them get back together later on) 😄

Originally posted by DarkCanadian
Good point......but its disappointing to see him going for looks still. I thought that maybe JKR wouldve tried to convey the message that looks aren't everything but oh well.

when has it ever been said that ginny is pretty? she's been described rather negatively in the looks department. She's got red hair, something that not many people go for (e.g. GINGER shouts - not from me, I hasten to add, I like redheads! They're well sexy 😄)), she's also got freckles, which ARE cute, but only until your about 12.

H/Hrs... can you give me some actual physical evidence from the books? I'd just like to know what fills you lot with such fire that you still think it can happen...? Not in a mean way at all, I'm just curious...

Originally posted by pumpkinpie4ever
well, like i said im sticking to h/hr and no one or nothings gonna change it... only stating the truth i may not be right this time but i am seriously overly confident on this one...and my fellow h/hrs never let your guard down it may come back to bite you in the arse...like the little switch-a-roo in HBP. which i still say wasnt ment to happen! you can say im in denial or wahtever but my point stands and who evers with me speak now or forever hold your peace i only hope its not to late...katie if your out there you gotta back me up...i dont wanna be the lonelyest beliver with faith.... we dont have much h/hrs anyway

The H/Hrs always used to outnumber the R/Hrs and H/Gs ((mostly cos me and night were the only ones!)) Whats happened to them all? Have they turned to the dark side? 😈

I would like to see some evidence of Harry and Hermione getting together from the books as well - from H/Hr shippers, because after reading HBP i think it's quite clear that this shipping is as likely as Ron becoming a Death Eater (which won't happen in a million years!) Yes there are some reasons out there that might suggest that they would make a good couple, but there are also reasons why R/Hr would make the good couple. At the end of the day, the big difference between the two is that there is more evidence of R/Hr happening and not H/Hr.

I think we've all given tons of evidence from all 5 books, but none of us have done any from book 6 (manily because there isn't that much). I don't have the energry to dig up old quotes and reasons, but there are many.

so do i but maybe there was so much evidence it was obvious which makes us wrong...BUT JKR LOVES TO FLIP-FLOP HER STORY SO KEEP FAITH H/HRS!!!!!

JKR: Well I think anyone who is still shipping Harry/Hermione after this book -

ES: [whispered] Delusional!

JKR: Uh - no! But they need to go back and reread, I think.

http://www.mugglenet.com/jkrinterview2.shtml

phoe, I AM NOT DELUSIONAL! i have faith in my ship and if im wrong for it sue me! i am not in the mood to be insulted b/c of the ship i happen to ship!!!....inhale...exhale...sry for that explosion.... its RED MONTH...so sorry...im "a little" edgy.

you never know if she could be bluffing or if she could change it in the last book. i hope ginny dooesn't tag along w/the trio on their search.

Well, if they're not going to believe JKR herself, it looks like they're lost beyond all hope...

Originally posted by pumpkinpie4ever
phoe, I AM NOT DELUSIONAL! i have faith in my ship and if im wrong for it sue me! i am not in the mood to be insulted b/c of the ship i happen to ship!!!....inhale...exhale...sry for that explosion.... its RED MONTH...so sorry...im "a little" edgy.

We never said you were delusional. the person in the interview said that.

To all the Hermoine/Harry shippers out there:

I TOLD YOU SO!

Originally posted by Draco69
To all the Hermoine/Harry shippers out there:

I TOLD YOU SO!


And another gloater. Yes, just by saying that you have made that much more enemies on this forum.