Vader's death: the mystery.

Started by Dirty Vader3 pages

Vader's death: the mystery.

What is the exact cause of vader's death? Was it the Emperor with the force lightning? Was it Luke cutting his circuits along with the hand? Something else?

If the removal of the mask killed him, why was he going to die anyway? What did it?

The lightning was too much for him to handle. He took a much higher dosage of it than Luke in a much shorter amount of time, because the Emperor was panicked.

the lightning killed the suits circuits and his life support failed him.

the lightning damages the body by superheating the bones, which is why vader's bones glow. It melted the prosthetic he has at C3 (3rd vertebrae on his spine, where his neck is broken, again this info is from the enhanced shot from TFN) so he had difficulty breathing and could not move without Luke's aid. He needed a high pressure, medicated atmosphere to survive after inhaling volcanic ash. By removing his mask, luke euthanised him instead of having him go through the slow and painful ordeal of superheated bones and a broken neck.

yup, probably the lightning, cause he wasn't in pain after the duel with luke

Ultimately it was a lack of oxygen to his brain that got him...

that or he was tired getting laughed at by the stormtroopers

again Darth Jello, info from that other site is not info from Lucas himself. and that whole pressure thing is what "his life support failed" meant in my previous post. the lighting killed the suit, the suit kept Anakin alive, no working suit, no working anakin. It wasn't the lightening alone because Luke took just as much and was okay.

vader took more, his bones were hot enough to glow, luke's weren't

it seems obvious that the effort in throwing the emperor into the shaft and everything around that event eventually killed him

Its weird because its a very important event in the saga but we dont know what the exact cause is. If us fans dont know for certain then nobody knows.

good call finiti. We know what happened Dirty, we don't need complete medical records unless you want each little cut and scrape of every character. We saw what we needed to see. We all understand enough that the scene is not confusing. Thats all we need.

just go to the site and examine it critically. theforce.net, technical commentaries-injuries of darth vader

ok look. i don't know how many times I'm gonna need to repeat myself here, so I'll just be blunt. I apologize in advance if this is offensive. That is THE MOST inconclusive CRAP evidence to support ANY indication to what Anakin's injuries will be in Episode 3. There are too many filmmaking factors (screw ups, guess work, flaws in the final product as opposed to storyboard) to make ANY judgement based on that. All that scene means is he is getting ELECTROCUTED TO DEATH. It wasn't meant to give you a glimpse of injuries and as such can not be treated as evidence for his injuries. Until III opens, or the really good spoilers hit, we will have no good evidence to what it is that happens to Anakin, too many major scenes have been given new context because of the prequels to take that little glimpse of his skeleton any creedence. BAM!

case closed

I know what killed him - Gearge Lucas, because it was good for the story... 😛

well, what would have happened if he had lived? He'd be put on trial and executed by the alliance, and luke would be exiled as a traitor for supporting vader.

if Vader had lived he would have lived as Anakin, not many left alive if any besides Luke and Leia knew Vader real identity

true, he wouldn't have been executed

Yeah, Luke would have hidden him away, probably on Dagobah. 🙂