The Return of the King was the my second favorite, the first was The Fellowship of the Ring of course, my favorite part was to see the friendship loiaty of Sam to Frodo and when the Wizard says that the end was not yet coming and says that there's the Paradise etc...Well, I'm now just waiting for Hobbit movie now!
Originally posted by Kes
I think when Pippin sewered allegiance to him he didnt quite know how much of a psycho Denethor was.Isnt the ending totally different in the book?
Someone said in the book when the hobbits return to the Shire that Sarauman is running it 😑
That would have been way cooler then that big ass ending 😖A few scenes could have been cut from it, the ending I mean.
No, you wouldn;t have liked it, Kes. A whole new, and not very exciting, plot about removing him from the Shire starts, and it would have been an utterly weird thing to put in after the main plot had finished.
THEN you had to have all the other stuff as well.
Originally posted by Ushgarak
No, you wouldn;t have liked it, Kes. A whole new, and not very exciting, plot about removing him from the Shire starts, and it would have been an utterly weird thing to put in after the main plot had finished.THEN you had to have all the other stuff as well.
Well if the movie ended with them seeing Sauroman is running the Shire it would have been cool.
The ending to Return is to boring. It kinda breaks the vibe, they should have cut half the stuff.
Originally posted by Kes
Well if the movie ended with them seeing Sauroman is running the Shire it would have been cool.
The ending to Return is to boring. It kinda breaks the vibe, they should have cut half the stuff.
But that would be NOTHING like the books- Peter can only change so much. To have it actually end with Saruman running the Shire is kind of ridiculous.
My point is, if he had added the rest of the ending from the books, you would have found it worse, believe me.