Of course Sirius will be back.... after the fall of the Despotic Dumbledore, Harry's Death and the end of the Death Eater/House Elf alliance led by Draco and hermione, Sirius will get out of the shower and realise it was all a dream... onlyto encounter Neville Longbottom, and realise that the "dream" may have been a premonition of what is to come....
Originally posted by Line
To Amy Black: I know. The veil is more mysterious. But then, so is death ( please excuse that horrible cliché 😮 ) We simply do not know what happens to a person when he/she dies. Sure, Rowling could have finished him off straight away, just let Beatrix use the Avada Kedavra, but it wouldn't have had the same effect, it wouldn't illustrate just have suddenly Sirius dissapeared from Harry's life. The Avada Kedavra leaves a body behind. The veil didn't. The avada kedavra is a weapon, a method of killing someone. Veils are more often used to symbolize the line between two worlds, such as the ones of the living and the dead. Therefore, the veil works more like a symbol of death, than the avada kedavra could. Harry is taught a lesson about loss. I still think this lesson would loose it's edge if Sirius suddenly returns.
that's true, the veil does make you re-think about Sirius's death.
but i hold to what i said before, Sirius will not come back 🙁 i guess i'm kinda stubborn...
Originally posted by big gay kirk😂
Of course Sirius will be back.... after the fall of the Despotic Dumbledore, Harry's Death and the end of the Death Eater/House Elf alliance led by Draco and hermione, Sirius will get out of the shower and realise it was all a dream... onlyto encounter Neville Longbottom, and realise that the "dream" may have been a premonition of what is to come....
I think it can't end like this.
When you first read the Prisoner of Azkaban, you think that Sirius is evil, we find out that he's innocent only in the end.
In the Goblet of Fire, he doesn't appear much, but we like him anyway.
In the Order of the Phoenix, he becomes a main character. We love him either if he's happy or angry.
And then he disappears.
Is that all? He must be back for some reason. I don't know why, but I know he must.
Originally posted by kayne
Sirius is DEAD! period. beyond return. Do not pass go, Do not collect two hundred dollars. Nearly Headless Nick said he will not return. Nick admitted to a fear of the otherside which is why he was still around. Sirius was all about the adventure. The excitement of whatever he did.His best friend in life "James Potter" Harry's father who is dead and not a ghost. (please don't respond with a James would have been a ghost if it wasn't for the spell old Voldy used. that was explained as a Shadow of the spell not the person themselves.
Anyways. Sirius would more then likely see death as another adventure and a chance to reunite with his lost friend James. Yes he cared for Harry and probly wouldn't want him to be alone, but Sirius knows Harry has great friends and a whole new family (Weasly's)
J.K. Rowling has stated in her last interview that Sirius was dead. and that any future deaths are not planned for return. He is Gone!
Thank you for putting up with my rant. You had a great theory but no foundation for support. 😈