Not as if I want to be rude or something, but the topic is "Sirius will seriously, definitely be BACK!". And most of you says he is dead and he won't come back. You kill the hope. The only thing I ("A want Sirius back!-erlookaround) have is hope (you know, hope dies last! ✅) and you take it away from me. It makes me feel desperate.
crybaby cry bawling weep
sadwalk
Re: Sirius will seriously, definitely be BACK!
Originally posted by Joy2dWorld
hey i know there are lots of other threads on him in the past but i think this matter about him deserves another one - new one!i read book 5 again & found more clues that he's coming back! dont know why i never saw them b4! they're mostly on the last part of the book during Harry's chat with Luna & Nearly Headless Nick.
I dont have the book with me now but the clues were laid out as something like these:
1) Talking to Harry about her mother who passed away when she was 9yrs old, Luna says:
"ITS NOT LIKE I WONT SEE HER AGAIN RIGHT? Oh come on Harry, you heard them too didnt you? the voices behind the archway! they're keeping themselves from being seen, but they're just there.. behind the veil."
2) Luna was looking for her things - which she lost - were hidden away from her by the other students - she says:
"i'll just wait for them to turn up again. eventually they always do in the end. its just that i wanted to pack tonight."
I take this as a clue to Sirius' return bcoz he was a topic in this same conversation - and Harry LOST HIM - so maybe he's not really gone but was just hidden away from him by "some others" & he'll turn up eventually in the end - but Harry must be patient - wait for it.
3) Nearly Headless Nick says:
"I dont understand the mysteries of death too bcoz I chose a different path. but there is a room at the Department of Mysteries where the great wizards study it.."
he's referring to that "veil room" which Dumbledore (talking to Fudge) referred to as the "Chamber of Death"- where Sirius disappeared.
I don't think any of the examples you mentioned meant to imply that Serious will be back. He's gone forever IMO, and even though none of us might like it, if you think of it more carefully, well, you'll see it's the only solution.
JKR has said multiple times that HP will get more dark near the end, that Serious' death was one of the most difficult parts to write, that she felt like losing a real friend of her own... 😖
Like said, I don't think he'll return.