Which Battle Was Better: Helm's Deep or the Gondor One?

I liked Helm's Deep better.

i liked helms deep too although minas tirth rocked

i just liked seeing haldir show up out of nowhere

Both.I can't decide.

Pelennor Fields was too much in my opinion. Helm's Deep was simple adn a lot more intense.

Hmmmm well if PJ followed the books and sent the Elves to Minas Tirith than everyone's fav would most likly be Minas Tirith but since he switched that and sent them to Helm's Deep they'ree pretty much even. I don't like how Haldir died in Helm's Deep, he wasn't supposed to die!!!

but he did 🙁 sword to back of the head lol

pellenor fields was not too much, this was the battle that it had been building up too, saurons one chance of destroying gondor therefore making m:e weaker, and for gondor it was do or die, it was all out all or nothing,

i liked the plennor feilds or however you spell it because the ringwraiths had a part in it, but helms deep because...just because

Originally posted by sauron
but he did 🙁 sword to back of the head lol

pellenor fields was not too much, this was the battle that it had been building up too, saurons one chance of destroying gondor therefore making m:e weaker, and for gondor it was do or die, it was all out all or nothing,

Ahhhhhhh I see where you going at.....

poor haldir, oh arwen was at halms deep, well at least they filmed her there, but after the outrage of her taking glorfindels (yes kit GLORFINDEL) place they took ther right out, and gave her the more exciting jog of knitting

I liked Pelennor Fields a lot, but I liked Helms Deep is VERY much...

Arg I cant decide lol

I guess I'll say Pelennor Fields

I liked Helms Deep better..more fighting...though the dead army was cool....and I'm sure the EE DVD will be better 🙂 But it's Helms Deep for right now (if you take out all the interuptions with both) Though Pip is in the Pelanor fields 😄

The dEad army was crap. Those bastards cheated big time.

how did they cheat?

they didn't cheat. hey you think quater million against 10000 is fair anyway???????..........those guys had to fight, they were bound to it.

i like pelennor fields better, hmmm after watching ROTK, TTT is boring to me ( wellllllll besides for the ents and gollum). At least i still love FOTR.

In movie terms, FOTR is my favorite because you get the whole gang fighting side-by-side together. And the bastards cheated coz they got "Immortal Soldiers". I mean, thats just cheating.

yeah, well if the immortal soldiers hadnt ran away from the last alliance battle then they wouldnt be there so blame THEM not aragorn

Well Aragorn's the one that wanted them.

I prefer Helm's Deep because of more cool quotes and because of the colour of the whole situation... I loved the blue... Pelennor is too colourful for a battle, especially with these nassssty little errr green members of the Grey Host. But on the other hand there was this stupid death of Haldir in Helms Deep... and stupid Legolas-Mûmak-action on Pelennor.
I love them both, but what was missing for pelennor was a cool beginning athmosphere - just throwing stones, that was kinda boring.

Yeah. I mean, the whole "urak-hai dodged the rock within 3 seconds". Seriously, not cool.

yeah pellenor should have bben on a night, or if it must be in the day in a storm or something