Which Battle Was Better: Helm's Deep or the Gondor One?

yeah he suits the unmatching collar and cuffs 😄

Originally posted by Kitoky
Not Haldir, I thought he was prefect.

I hated his stupid glittering armour 😄 and his death...

I hated his death scene...

"For all the others at Helm's Deep who glanced at Haldir's armor, they couldn't help but think, 'TARGET!'"

he was happy with his death because the last thing he saw was dead elves, preety elves though, then aragorn spoilt it, he started running over to haldir all grimy and sweaty and bloody, with everythng from mucus to urine on him, haldir saw he was coming to him and though *noooo* and tried to die quicker, which i think he suceeded in

Oh my god, lol

lol i dont know how my mind works, but im sure its working wrong 😄

😖
The one I liked best was the Last Alliance... but the best would be a combination - like the Ride of the Rohirrim, Mûmakil and blue rainy night on the fields of dagorlad 😄

Notice that the subject is really off.....well that's us I guess.

thats us

i somehow managed to get the subject from battles to haldir trying to kill himself...........😖

Originally posted by sauron
thats us

i somehow managed to get the subject from battles to haldir trying to kill himself...........😖

It just takes Talent man, it's all talent and skill.

which i dont posses either of 🙁

Originally posted by sauron
which i dont posses either of 🙁

Now you do, dude do you know how many threads you turned the tables on? I think that one Orli thread turned into us ranting on about how threads shouldn't be switched, lol.

lol then i started singing thriller over and over an putting MJ into the fellowship 😄

The final battle of the Siege of Bard Dur could have been longer, though...

Anyway, I prefer Helm's Deep and I think that will be the prevailing opinion over time. Whilat Pelennor Fields was nice, and certainly the grandest in scale, it just didn'tt have the focus, good design and suspense of Helm's Deep. And I think posterity will remember Helm's Deep as the battle that had the most impact.

i liked the last offical fight scene outside the black gates or gate

i dont know its proper name

i loved it when merry and pippin charged off eventually everyone had over took them anyway bless em

It's just "Battle of Morannon" 😄

I also liked that but it was too short and they had no cool weapons like Grond --- and I hated the end... poor Barad-dûr and Morannon falling *cries*

Helms Deep was the better one. Minas Tirith had poor fighting and very little fight scenes most of it balls of fire falling everywhere. you never really see anyone get hit with arrows or stabed like in helms deep.
I guess they were short on money torwards the third film 🙁

i can't answer this question because i love them both 😄...works of art they are.

you don't get to see anyone hit? oh i must have missed the flying heads and the fell beast dropping those guys onto the houses 😂....i know it must have been sore but you have to laugh 😖hifty:

either Helm's Deep was too long or the siege of Gondor too short. I wanted to see more of the Battle of Minas Tirith

"or the Gondor one"

ah ya fool 😛

they were both great, Pelennor fields totally ruled better though.