Which Battle Was Better: Helm's Deep or the Gondor One?

lol for the cast's sake i'm glad it wasn't...........those poor souls spent 3 months in the rain during winter to film Helm's Deep. Hey you dont want them to do that again, people can only take SO MUCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!

After all it was called "The Dawnless Day"... I think it was far to light for such a name.

they werent in winter, the helms deep battle wqas filmed indoors, have you not seen it on the apendices of ttt

well the cahrge of the whole rohan in rotk was mindblowing and was mine fav part of the movie. hemls deep was good and the charge of the horses at the end was wicked. put plennor feilds was much bigger, and the eliphants was wicked to.

YES I have , i was in a quarry, and they had alll the extras in the rain and when it came to shooting the next day the prostetic suits couldn't be dried in time so they had to shoot night after night in smelly damp suits.

Why do u think everyone who were involved in making helm's deep got T-Shirts saying " i survived helm's Deep" ???????

lol i heard about that yeah, although lots of it was indoors too, in a warehouse if i remember rightly, i can specificly remember the rain producing machine lol

Both battles were good, but I like Pelennor fields better. Rohan coming and then the army of the dead coming made it a whole lot better in my perspectinve.

Originally posted by sauron
poor haldir, oh arwen was at halms deep, well at least they filmed her there, but after the outrage of her taking glorfindels (yes kit GLORFINDEL) place they took ther right out, and gave her the more exciting jog of knitting

Pfft, they took no mind to our Glorfindel replacement outrage, Liv Tyler actually went online and saw sights that say Arwen, Xena Warrior Princess and talked to PJ that Arwen can be strong even though she doesn't weild a sword.

LOOK AT THIS GLORFINDEL!

He's so adorable!

wheres that from?!?! 😄

no offence but hes got a bad barnet 😛

the hornburg was shot indoors, as far as i remember.
* fini will look back at the appendies when she is done with the net*

Originally posted by sauron
wheres that from?!?! 😄

no offence but hes got a bad barnet 😛

I forget, I think it's from an MSN group thing, and I stole it, yes I stole it, I couldn't resist.

Barnet?

hair style, its rather.....'big' his hair isnt it 😄

Originally posted by sauron
hair style, its rather.....'big' his hair isnt it 😄

Ah I see, actually I like it, especially his side hair just hanging out like that 😍 Glorfindel is the ONLY non-existant character I fawn over, next to Tom of course, but he's not non-existant, we saw him.

i prefer the Pelennor one.

it's just so much cooler!!! 😎 the battle is on a grander scale, and has more creatures, and it's more dramatic and moving IMO.... 😍

god, the battering ram they had was so cool, but so freaky. and all the orcs and stuff... it's the best battle i ever saw in my entire life. 🙂

how comes elves hair dont match their eyebrows, hmmmm

Originally posted by sauron
how comes elves hair dont match their eyebrows, hmmmm

They do have alot of eyebrows, look at Celeborn! And besides they're supposed to be elegant so having bushy eyebrows doesn't exactly fit that description.

because everyone that bleaches their hair and gets weaved done , never think about their eyebrows matching. Its most dumb. someone with black/dark brown hair cant go blonde without lightening the colour of their brows, it will be an incopmplete job

Legolas seems to be complete, *grumbles*

Nearly all blond elves are incomplete 😂 I only remember two elves (and those were female) whole eyebrowcolor actually fit the haircolor.

Blond elves look stupid. at least in the film.

Not Haldir, I thought he was prefect.