Glorfindel and Erestor?

Started by Kitoky3 pages
Kitoky Starting Anew

s'ok, I'm still revolting! 😠

Discos The Discmeister

ok I had a revelation last week and just remembered it yesterday

If you look at the council of Elrond (in the film), you should be able to see Erestor and Glorfindel (the smith elves), but ya can't

I looked closely, so sorry Kit but I think I answered your question

Discos - am gonna feel so stupid if someone already posted this

Arroch Senior Member
Originally posted by Discos
If you look at the council of Elrond (in the film), you should be able to see Erestor and Glorfindel (the smith elves), but ya can't

😑 😑 Glorfindel and Erestor smith elves? 😑

Erestor CAN be seen at the council, he is Elrond's chief counsellor, Glorfindel is not present though

But they are not the smith elves are they 😑

Naib Come and get me!

Originally posted by Arroch
😑 😑 Glorfindel and Erestor smith elves? 😑

Erestor CAN be seen at the council, he is Elrond's chief counsellor, Glorfindel is not present though

But they are not the smith elves are they 😑

I concur with that evaluation. They were not the smith elves.

Discos The Discmeister

ah christ i found the wrong thread then,

I think it was Kit who questioned who the smith elves were?

they arn't Elrond's sons either.....

Naib Come and get me!

They may be, but very highly unlikely as they were not in the end credits.

Arroch Senior Member

Why should Elrond's sons be smiths? I think the smiths were rather elves from Ost-in-Edhil or their descendants as they did flee to Imladris after the death of Celebrimbor - they were rather jewel-smiths, but I think they'd rather reforge a sword like Andúril than Elrond's sons

Discos The Discmeister

I see, then the question has been answered

Kit said they must of been high elves to of stayed behind from going to the grey heavens.....or just piece of trash elves who didnt deserve to go 😛

Exabyte Senior Member

More new Decipher cards 😘

Ghan-buri-Ghan and Erkenbrand of Rohan:

Elrohir 😖

The Innkeeper Senior Member

Images dont work for me 🙁

Exabyte Senior Member

Then go here
http://www.herr-der-ringe-film.de/v2/de/news/news-detail_1018.php

and here
http://www.herr-der-ringe-film.de/v2/de/news/news-detail_1017.php

😉

The Innkeeper Senior Member

*jumps over trainlines infront of passing train and is taken to that site*