Petunia is actually Harry's real mother... Lily couldn't have kids, so Petunia became a surrogate, and carried James's child... she then resented having to give the child up, and thats why she is always so angry... yes, I know Dudley was born around the same time, but magic was used to put Harry in Petunia's womb alongside... even more reasons for Petunia to feel resentful towards the wizard world...
I think maybe Lily and Petunia had different dad's or mom's......... maybe they are connected through one same parent.......
What'd be even weirder is if they were half-sisters what if Tom Riddle was related through blood........
It'd make sense b/c he was an orphan. He despises his father....maybe him and Lily had the same dad.
I think it's possible.......
petunia and lilly are full sisters but they might not have been related to there mom and dad they might have both been adopted when the real parents died ?
the resentmant and hate could be b/c there adopted parents loved lilly more even b4 she became a witch and when she did petunia just got ignored?
maybe petunias a squib. maybe theres a deeper reason why she hates lily....
me too in the family, im the only one different! but i guess im not adopted. as i can see, petunia really hates lily just like me and my brother. hahaha, im not making any sense at all! 🤓 😑 😂
****RaVeNcLaW GhOsT****
“the strong shall live and the weak shall die”
Re: Lilly, the adopted daughter...?!
Originally posted by megajoint
Lilly description was nothing similar to Petunia.
Lilly looks: dark red hair,bright green eyes,petite
Petunia looks:blond hair,horse face, tall (I think..)IMO Lilly was adopted because her parents were proud of her when they found out she's a witch...proud.... that's the key word here u can explain why they were in 3 different possibilities:
1)They can be proud because they ,like herm parents, supportive and thinking magic is cool
2)They might be from long generation of squibs and finally there is a witch in the family...
3)Because their adopted daughter is gifted with magic (unlike petunia)The best part in this theory is that maybe Lilly was from DD familly his daughter or his brother daughter(their looks aka red hair) or connected to the weasley family somehow...
(isn't ron said somthing about it in book 1 on the ride to hogwarts..)
the only flaw is DD tells harry that noone left from his family but the dursley's
but DD can't be always right maybe he is wrong....maybe he somehow lost contact with her or lost her when she was a baby....
😮💨 😮💨 💃
(and If someone think DD would have known his own grand granddaughter by looks he might not recognise her ,think about the possibility that she looks nothing alike DD or wealey's but the hair)-------
on another note maybe james was family relate(like uncle) to snape (or my nickname for him "exploding snap" LOL 🤣 )...?
because all pure blood related somehow....search for clues 4 it .....
A excellent theory!
BUT...
Dumbledore says that Harry's protection is all about BLOOD... his MOTHER's blood... He only stays safe from Voldie when he is in the house of someone who shares his mother's blood -- PETUNIA. Therefore, Petunia HAS to share Lily's blood - they have to be biological sisters
Originally posted by fanatos
Maybe you are right. Because it's said that Harry is a true wizard without muggles in his family. That means Lilly and her whole family were wizards, but Petunia is indeed a muggle. 😱
This is good, this shows why Petunia hates Lily so much. If she could lie to Harry she probably lied to Vernon and told him that her parents were indeed muggles, b/c she didn't want to lost him once she found out her family is full of witches.
That could explain why she BABIES Dudley so much. Especially when he has a temper.....maybe she's afraid he's got a bit of wizardness in him.
J.K. shows his OUTRAGEOUS temper in the 1st book. I wonder if he'll be a squib...............
What if Lily and Petunia's parents adopted Voldemort??? Tom got rid of his name b/c of his muggle father (which was probably biological).... also we haven't heard anything about Harry's grandparents.......
I wonder if Voldemort is related to Harry/Lily/Petunia through adoption........AND why does he fear Dumbledore so much............
k......then him and one of lily's parents could have grown up in the same house...him being taken in by Lily's family somehow...that would explain his resistance to want to kill her..................... b/c her family was there for him when his family was not.............. make sense.................. (but then again we are talking about a guy that kills and doesn't care......)
what voldy meant when he talked to harry was not that he didn't want to kill harry's mother but that she didn't have to die, two completely different things, basically if lily had moved out of the way she would have survivedbut b/c she refused, she was killed, voldy came for a target and he just killed anyone that got in the way of him ancd his target. lily was pretty insignificant, he didn't care what happened to her, she posed no threat to him at all she just didn't let him get to harry. also i think probably either hagrid, filch or mrs. figg will learn magic b/c lily and petunia are full blooded sisters and they come from a muggle background, if lily and petunia's family were indeed wizards, then snape would not have called lily a mudblood in the 5th book in snape's worst memory.