Seriously which franchise is better HP or LOTR

It was the acting, the direction, and the book-to-movie transistion. They took out too much (Peeves comes to mind)

there both entertaining, but harry potter is more fun

Originally posted by Lord Soth
It was the acting, the direction, and the book-to-movie transistion. They took out too much (Peeves comes to mind)

yeah its dun feel the same w/o the dear poltergeist😉

GOT YOUR CONK!

😆 🤣 🤣 😂 😂

couldn't hepl myself 😄 😂

Topic ppl

shall i tell you what i think? i couldnt give a damn. i really couldnt.

Oh yeah and i voted for LotR. HP sux.

Metalhead has spoken

lol this thread AGAIN?!?!?!?!

I love nothing in my life more than Harry Potter. It's changed my life and made me a much more interesting and better person. The books are the greatest in the world.

But on a cinematic look, the Lord of the Rings movies are by far twice as good, no arguments. They are so powerful and...I can't explain it well, but they have extreme dedication in them (not that HP doesn't, but...) Lord of the Rings will be the ones looked back upon as great achievments in movie making, not Harry Potter. The greatest thing about Harry Potter is the books by the amazing JK Rowling.

i agree 100%

Originally posted by fini
lol this thread AGAIN?!?!?!?!

yup ✅

If you're looking at the books, there's no way I could ever choose. They're both great, and I hate people who only obsess about one thing. But with the movies, I love the LotR and don't really care about HP. That is all I have to say.

no more poles and comparing lotr and hp please! enough!

I agree LOTR is better.. although I enjoy the HP books more then the LOTR books

^agree

my opinion is that because LOTR books are so much more complicated so unlike a movie there is much more explaining to be done then in the HP books

Hey i'm a newbie but my vote counts right?
I think LOTR and HP should be equal!!
But dont mind the slashers, were just in it 4 the mansex!

I'm amused that someone even ASKED this question. LOTR is obviously a better series overall. The Harry Potter books ARE, however, very very good and only slightly less than LOTR. It's the Harry Potter MOVIES that ruin it. God those are crap.