Seriously which franchise is better HP or LOTR

^100% agree. Harry Potter movies suck suck suck suck

although i enjoyed all of the HP books, LOTR's movies are much better than HP movies...

Refer to above...😄

i guess lotr has more of a presense since it's been around longer and has more fans in different age ranges.

definitely lotr! dat totally kiks hp'z ass!
also, da characters r way beta....lyk lotr aint all witches n wizards, theres all different races which makes it really interestin, plus da lotr guys r so sexy *drools*

is it just me, or are you a very bad typist?

😆

lotr defiantly

the wizards back in middle earth time can battle extremely well physically and with swords better than the one's in harry potter. that's what i find lame in harry potter, they can't do hand to hand combat.

The only thing is, in Middle-Earth, there are only 3 wizards (Saruman the White, Gandalf the Gray/White, and Radaghast the Brown). Not that it makes much of a difference. All they need to do is rally a band of elves, and that'll be more than you can shake a stick (or wand 😄) at

Harry Potter has good books but suckie movies...
LOTR has good movies but hard-to-understand books...
ZACH

LOTR... hands down, i was originally a HP fan but after i read lotr i was like wow, i like this SOOO much better

LOTR x10,000,000,000

Just plain all around better... LOTR appeals to all audiences, young and old alike, and the movies are incredibly well done--they don't scrap too much of the plot of the books, but are still easy to follow.

This topic just made me realize something... I think JK Rowling got the idea to kill Sirius from LOTR--Boromir and Theoden's deaths were a gut-wrenching, however effective, (and you could say even necessary) part of the story. Boromir's death showed the sheer power of the ring to corrupt even the strongest of men. Theoden... Well I'm not sure why he had to die... But the story wouldn't be the same w/o it 😄 I think she was trying to do the same thing.. Only she didn't. I'm tempted to not read the next HP book.

LOTR wins hands down

South park LOTR spoof:

http://www.southparkstudios.com/down/download.html?file=/media/sounds/613/PUTINTOCONTEXT.wav
http://www.southparkstudios.com/down/download.html?file=/media/video/613/quest.mov
http://www.southparkstudios.com/down/download.html?file=/media/video/613/eviltape.mov
http://www.southparkstudios.com/down/download.html?file=/media/video/613/precious.mov
http://www.southparkstudios.com/down/download.html?file=/media/video/613/thefinalconflict.mov

the lord of the rings movies kick harry potters ass

The Harry Potter movies are terrible. The third looks okay, though

Lord of the rings takes it with flying colors because there is a whole lot more of action in LOTR then in HP 💃

Come on, People, isn't it obvious... I mean, Lotr doesn't get 11 oscars for nothing... 👆

Originally posted by Ice18
Lord of the rings takes it with flying colors because there is a whole lot more of action in LOTR then in HP 💃