The OFFICIAL 'Ask Hermione' Question Thread

Started by The Ones26 pages
The Ones Death Eater

I have 2 questions about continuity

In Chamber of Secrets, Tom Riddle asks how Harry escaped with just a scar. But in Goblet of Fire he knows how and talks about it. Why did he ask about it in Chamber

also

In Prisoner of Azkaban, Auther Weasly says: "13 years ago, when you stopped, You Know Who..." but in Goblet of Fire its 1 year later and Voldemort says: "13 years it has been, and you all stand here before me". shouldnt it be 14 years?

The Phantom Angel of Music

Originally posted by The Ones
I have 2 questions about continuity

In Chamber of Secrets, Tom Riddle asks how Harry escaped with just a scar. But in Goblet of Fire he knows how and talks about it. Why did he ask about it in Chamber

also

In Prisoner of Azkaban, Auther Weasly says: "13 years ago, when you stopped, You Know Who..." but in Goblet of Fire its 1 year later and Voldemort says: "13 years it has been, and you all stand here before me". shouldnt it be 14 years?

First, that was Tom Riddle as a child. Second, after being told it, he would know it, yes? It being a horcrux. And third, that was a error in Azkaban. Harry was 1 years old when he "stopped" Voldemort.

mentalguy Ooh-Rah

more books?

anyone think that J.K. will add another book to the franchise
ie. followups? prequil?

daeri Senior Member

No, she won't..

Sir J pure blood

no just the 7th book then its the end

hotsauce6548 Approaching the End

She has already said book seven will be the last. ✅

Emily_depp Soon to be Mrs Grint

philosophers /Sorcerer's Stone

Why is the Us version called the Scorcerer's stone? 😉

Pielover666 Restricted

Originally posted by Emily_depp
Why is the Us version called the Scorcerer's stone? 😉

Because USA is filled with uneducated sloths who don't know what a precursor is...sadly...Why Do I live in Americia? Because it rules!

Pielover666 Restricted

She did mention she might make an encyclopedia of every charactor slash item of importance.

The Phantom Angel of Music

Seven books, she said it herself.

Pielover666 Restricted

Phantom! It's you old buddy Pielover! *Hug?*

scurran Senior Member
Originally posted by Pielover666
Because USA is filled with uneducated sloths who don't know what a precursor is

lol 😆
i agree

scurran Senior Member
Originally posted by Pielover666
Because USA is filled with uneducated sloths who don't know what a precursor is...sadly...Why Do I live in Americia? Because it rules!
Emily_depp Soon to be Mrs Grint

is that true?

Pielover666 Restricted

Originally posted by Emily_depp
is that true?

Basically.

sk8stuff09 Senior Member

yeah i wondered that too, i think American's and British people interpretate the word ''philosopher'' differently maybe, i actualy dont know.

danagrint Rupert's Wife

😖hifty:

mentalguy Ooh-Rah

remember since harry is not going to hogwarts anymore there still could be another book to come. destroying all those horcruxs is a lot to put in one book. and i heard that book 7 is going to be smaller than book 5.
as for what J.K. said maybe she changed her mind during or after writing the HBP.

I think its a 50/50 chance that there will be

danagrint Rupert's Wife

I hope there are more books coming, but probably not!

Ashea16Chic **************

Why are the Weasleys called Blood Traitors?

^^ I know it's old news but I still haven't figured out why...
^^ Is it because they all socialize with Muggles and Mudbloods? or something deeper than that...?