The OFFICIAL 'Ask Hermione' Question Thread

Started by ashle26 pages

Originally posted by Midnight109
I have to go with Phantom's idea...I can't really remember but I don't think Hagrid was even in Gryffindor to begin with.

He was gryffindor.He said it himself.

Originally posted by ashle
He was gryffindor.He said it himself.
Where?

Originally posted by ashle
He was gryffindor.He said it himself.

I don't remember that.

I was told to bump this because no one could fricking find it on THE FRONT PAGE! Come on people, stop being lazy.

😂i dont have a clue .but i think he did say that (maybe it was on the chamber of secrets)

hey,

go look at the 1st movie.you know when hermione shows that her dad was a seeker on the awards room.well,if you look next to the another award goes to 'M.G. Mcgonnagal'.i just noticed it.so do you think p.mcgonnagal was a qudditch player.

anyway,i am not actually sure though.

Originally posted by ashle
hey,

go look at the 1st movie.you know when hermione shows that her dad was a seeker on the awards room.well,if you look next to the another award goes to 'M.G. Mcgonnagal'.i just noticed it.so do you think p.mcgonnagal was a qudditch player.

anyway,i am not actually sure though.

No, I don't think so...movies don't always have accurate information- If you want the real information you have to read the books.

Originally posted by Midnight109
No, I don't think so...movies don't always have accurate information- If you want the real information you have to read the books.

i guess .but there , they haven't mentioned about it at the book.

Originally posted by ashle
hey,

go look at the 1st movie.you know when hermione shows that her dad was a seeker on the awards room.well,if you look next to the another award goes to 'M.G. Mcgonnagal'.i just noticed it.so do you think p.mcgonnagal was a qudditch player.

anyway,i am not actually sure though.

I'll check that out...
Yup, it says "1771, M.G MCGONAGAL"
Does anyone know her middle name?

Originally posted by Diamonds
I'll check that out...
Yup, it says "1771, M.G MCGONAGAL"
Does anyone know her middle name?

told you.

and no.i dont think its ever been mentioned.

Hi, I'm looking for a picture from the prisoner of Azkaban movie that was released before the film, but never actually made it to the film or deleted scenes. It showed a scene with harry and Lupin and the stag patronus in a classroom, but it was the full stag, and was really pretty, and I remember being really gutted that it didn't make the film. Anybody got it?

Originally posted by hrh_jennifer
Hi, I'm looking for a picture from the prisoner of Azkaban movie that was released before the film, but never actually made it to the film or deleted scenes. It showed a scene with harry and Lupin and the stag patronus in a classroom, but it was the full stag, and was really pretty, and I remember being really gutted that it didn't make the film. Anybody got it?
Nope, but I can tell you why it probably didn't make the movie though. Lupin was never around when Harry made the full stag patronus.

Of course, that makes sense, it was still a pretty picture, though, and I want it! papillon

Originally posted by hrh_jennifer
Of course, that makes sense, it was still a pretty picture, though, and I want it! papillon

try google.com

Originally posted by Diamonds
I'll check that out...
Yup, it says "1771, M.G MCGONAGAL"
Does anyone know her middle name?

Its............................ 😐....................

Question and favor. Can someone please find the quote when Hagrid tells Harry about Snape and Dumbledore fighting and does this have any connection with Dumbledore trusting Hagrid with his life as he says in the first book.

Another question. As I'm rereading SS, Dumbledore says Harry's scar may come in handy. As we notice this yes it allows Harry to know when Voldemort or Death Eaters are near, but does it ever serve another purpose?

Edit: More questions. Dumbledore had a scar that resembles the London Underground. Has this information even been used and do you think, though comical as it is, it may still yet be used or mentioned. Like if they have to go through the London Underground or something in book 7?

Originally posted by The Phantom
Another question. As I'm rereading SS, Dumbledore says Harry's scar may come in handy. As we notice this yes it allows Harry to know when Voldemort or Death Eaters are near, but does it ever serve another purpose?

Edit: More questions. Dumbledore had a scar that resembles the London Underground. Has this information even been used and do you think, though comical as it is, it may still yet be used or mentioned. Like if they have to go through the London Underground or something in book 7?

Harry's scar was used to connect him to Voldemort, as you may recall, from OoTP.

Dumbledore's scar was of the ondon underground, but how couldit help them if DD is dead?

Originally posted by The Phantom
Question and favor. Can someone please find the quote when Hagrid tells Harry about Snape and Dumbledore fighting and does this have any connection with Dumbledore trusting Hagrid with his life as he says in the first book.
No. Hagrid merely overheard the two yelling, as Hagrid was going about his buisness. Dumbledore did not tell Hagrid about this.

"I -- well, I was comin; outta the forest the otehr evenin' an' I overheard 'em talking -- well, arguin'." HBP pg. 405 US

Originally posted by ~Pielover~
Harry's scar was used to connect him to Voldemort, as you may recall, from OoTP.
I said that already. But I mean more of a purpose.

Dumbledore's scar was of the ondon underground, but how couldit help them if DD is dead? No. Hagrid merely overheard the two yelling, as Hagrid was going about his buisness. Dumbledore did not tell Hagrid about this.

"I -- well, I was comin; outta the forest the otehr evenin' an' I overheard 'em talking -- well, arguin'." HBP pg. 405 US

One, I meant it more on the area of could we see the London Underground at anytime or if DD is alive (though my theories say he isn't) maybe it will deal around there.

And I also meant DD making Hagrid say stuff and everything. Remember, this could all be planned.

Another question. The letter that Dumbledore left with him when he was dropped at the Dursleys. We never found out exactly what it said, did we?