Which character do you want to die in future books?

Started by TheSun9 pages
TheSun Senior Member

Originally posted by Anoushka
lot of us predicted that though so i don't think it comes as a shock -shrugs-

but it is sad,you have to admit 🙁

Spoiler:
but atleast there's the portrait!🙄 not as if they'll never speak again.

Portraits can only repeat what the real people would have said in life, like catchphrases.

babysooner13 Lavender Brown

Something sad. Dumbledore dies in the 6th book.

DarkCanadian -KMC THREAD KILLER-

Originally posted by TheSun
Portraits can only repeat what the real people would have said in life, like catchphrases.

Ah, but we don't know that for sure. Look at those two in OotP, Dilys Derwent and someone else...they acted like their selves had been actually living inside the portriat istelf.

TheSun Senior Member

Originally posted by DarkCanadian
Ah, but we don't know that for sure. Look at those two in OotP, Dilys Derwent and someone else...they acted like their selves had been actually living inside the portriat istelf.

JKR herself told us that they could only repeat catchphrases. We do know for sure.

DarkCanadian -KMC THREAD KILLER-

Even so, Dily Derwent acted like her normal self in OotP.

LoVeRgIrL LoVeR!!!!!!!!

i dont know.............Snape

DarkCanadian -KMC THREAD KILLER-

Where'd she say this, TS?

ladygrim The Grim piratess

😐

TheSun Senior Member

Originally posted by DarkCanadian
Where'd she say this, TS?

Lol, I've read so many online chats..I'll try and find it, I definitely know she said it though.

Imaginary blinded

Oooh that's what I was referring to when I mentioned portraits in another thread. It'd be hilarious to have Dumbledore saying "Nitwit! Blubber! Oddment! Tweak!" in portrait form 😂

Anoushka The Vampire Anoushka

😂 hell yeah
i can totally imagine 😂

is it just me or are people unusually silent about him dying..they caused a bigger uproar when sirius did 😖 and you'd think dumbldore dying would be a harder blow..

iluvcandy Member

Hi! I'm new here! 😄

I want... Hermione to die!

NightCrawler341 Angel of Music

Originally posted by TheSun
JKR herself told us that they could only repeat catchphrases. We do know for sure.
And yet I see the portraits in the portraits in the Headmaster or Headmistresses room having minds of the own.

TheSun Senior Member

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
And yet I see the portraits in the portraits in the Headmaster or Headmistresses room having minds of the own.

Hey, take your beef up with JK, I didn't say they couldn't have their own mind.

NightCrawler341 Angel of Music

She might have meant portraits around the school. The headmaster and headmistress portraits are clearly different.

TheSun Senior Member

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
She might have meant portraits around the school. The headmaster and headmistress portraits are clearly different.

She meant any portait, it was very clear. I think she cited Mrs Black in her example, and it was in a response to a question regarding Sirius returning in the form of a portrait.

NightCrawler341 Angel of Music

Then how come it seems that the headmaster and headmistress portraits have a mind of their own?

TheSun Senior Member

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
Then how come it seems that the headmaster and headmistress portraits have a mind of their own?

Like I said, take your beef up with JK, she may have made another mistake.

NightCrawler341 Angel of Music

I believe on of them said something to McGonagal in HPB, saying her name. I am sure that wasn't a catchphrase to be able to say ones first name, and I don't think she was in school when he was headmaster either.

TheSun Senior Member

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
I believe on of them said something to McGonagal in HPB, saying her name. I am sure that wasn't a catchphrase to be able to say ones first name, and I don't think she was in school when he was headmaster either.

Well, I have no explanation, perhaps JK meant something different from what she said.