Thor + Hulk + Thing .V. Superman?

Started by FeceMan10 pages
You sure this is true? You sure it's not BS?

AC, you're my favorite person today.

Well its kinda dumb to put him up against all 3 of them but im just stating that he could beat each of them 1 on 1 and has done it cept for the thing which wouldnt even be a fight.

Gee, and all the other random vs. posts AREN'T dumb? And guess what? He's NOT fighting them one-on-one, he's fighting ALL THREE, so the point is moot.

Moot. Hehe, funny word.

i like that word too.

I think we can leave Thing at home when fighting Superman. He's nowhere as strong, fast or durable as Superman, and I don't think he would play a large role in this fight.

It depends on Thor and Hulk. Superman can take Hulk (whose strength I never considered limitless, that's bullshit, only without known limits).

But I think that fighting Hulk AND Thor at the same time is too much for our friend Kal-El.

Thor and Hulk (and yes yes, Thing also, sigh) take this one, but it's hardly a fair fight.

"It depends on Thor and Hulk. Superman can take Hulk (whose strength I never considered limitless, that's bullshit, only without known limits)."

I just don't get this. Why, when he has unlimited strength, does everyone just claim it's bullshit coz they don't like it? Yes, he has unlimited strength. Deal with it. It's how he was created, to have no limits to his strength. The angrier he get the stronger he gets and I or anyone else can always combat the old, faulted "He can only get so angry" arguement with, "Yeah but he could get a bit angrier". Like numbers, you could say numbers are without known limits and try to tell me that there is no number beyonf kajillion billion zillion miliion. I could just say "add 1". It's the concept of Hulk's intended infinate rage that gives him unlimited strength.)

Whether anyone likes it or not, yes he does have limitless strength. Sorry that it bothers you so bad.

-AC

Lol, it doesn’t bother me what people want to believe. You make it seem like it’s a big deal for me, but I couldn’t care less about the Hulks strength.

But !, because now we’re talking about it, I just want to stress the fact that nothing is limitless. Everything has a limit. So has Hulk.

If he didn’t have a limit, he could eventually be able to throw Jupiter (many times bigger and heavier than the Earth) to another galaxy with one hand. Now, do you really think he would be capable to do such a thing ?

And, another thing, if he didn’t have a limit, why does he get his ass kicked so many times ? I have seen him FURIOUS !! and still he had trouble defeating some villains. Just saying he “wasn’t furious enough” is a lame excuse.

(Together with Spider-Man, Wolverine, Colossus, Reed Richards and a few others, Hulk is one of my favorites).

The concept of nothing being limitless is hardly valid against a comic book character who is 7ft and 1040 lbs. We're hardly dealing with Jane Austen and the realists of literature here.

"I just want to stress the fact that nothing is limitless. Everything has a limit. So has Hulk."

Well Space is limitless. Infinity is limitless. If Hulk's strength is limitless then of course over many years time he could perform amazing feats. In an alternate timeline there's probably some 10x Maestro strolling around purely off the nature that infinity is limitless and possibilities are endless as a result.

As Vic said, it's not Jane Austen it's Marvel. If you really wanna pick holes you may aswell say "Nehhhh big green man."

"Just saying he “wasn’t furious enough” is a lame excuse."

Well....lame or not lame, if he wasn't furious enough, then he wasn't. It's quite telling about you finding Hulk's strength dubious. You just think that for someone to be able to say that and override someone elses whole debate is stupid. Well regardless, if Hulk walked into Abomination and Abomination smacked him around because he wasn't angry enough, then the reason for that would be because......he wasn't angry enough.

Lame or not lame, it's an excuse that is extremely valid.

-AC

If he didn’t have a limit, he could eventually be able to throw Jupiter (many times bigger and heavier than the Earth) to another galaxy with one hand. Now, do you really think he would be capable to do such a thing ?

The thing is, he wouldn't get THAT angry because he would have beat the crap out of his opponent already. Then he would be happy.

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
"I just want to stress the fact that nothing is limitless. Everything has a limit. So has Hulk."

Well Space is limitless. Infinity is limitless. If Hulk's strength is limitless then of course over many years time he could perform amazing feats. In an alternate timeline there's probably some 10x Maestro strolling around purely off the nature that infinity is limitless and possibilities are endless as a result.
-AC


Nobody can tell for sure if space is truly limitless. Einstein couldn't, Hubble couldn't and Hawking can't. And infinity is of course, in a way, limitless, but infinity is just an (empty) theoretical concept, nothing more. Hulks strength is not.

If his strength AND his anger are really limitless, he should be invincible. And he's not.

Okay?

Originally posted by who?-kid
Nobody can tell for sure if space is truly limitless. Einstein couldn't, Hubble couldn't and Hawking can't. And infinity is of course, in a way, limitless, but infinity is just an (empty) theoretical concept, nothing more. Hulks strength is not.

If his strength AND his anger are really limitless, he should be invincible. And he's not.

Not really, that presupposes that strength is the definitive factor in a victory.

Well, in most (granted, not all, but certainly most) of the Hulk fights, strength actually IS the deciding factor. What else would be the deciding factor ? His ability to prepare his fights, or his ability to "brain an opponent to death" ? Or maybe his magical skills ? Or his weapons ? Or his telepathic abilities ?

Lol 🙂

I take it the satisfied 'lol' is where you think you have deconstructed my argument.

You said that: If his strength AND his anger are really limitless, he should be invincible.

If this were true, then strength is not HULK's key factor, it's THE key factor overall.

That is clearly not true.

Lol.

I’m not 100 % sure if I follow you on this one, but I’ll give it a try.

I’ll quote myself for a change : “If his strength AND his anger are really limitless, he should be invincible.”

Naturally, I was talking about physical fights, fist fights, fighting with bare hands, mano a mano… that’s where the Hulk is good at. And most of times, strength is a deciding factor when fighting somebody in such a way, especially for the Hulk.

So, again “If his strength AND his anger are really limitless, he should be invincible” only applies for such physical fights, not of course other kind of battles. IF his strength really was limitless, he should not be able to lose such a fight. But he does from time to time.

But hey, maybe he wasn't angry enough 😉.

Well, it does make sense now you have phrased it correctly, because invincible doesn't only include fist fights.

Yes, you are correct now.

Although having limitless strength doesn't mean one canot be harmed, so maybe you aren't.

Who knows ? 😄

Is that a covert intertextual reference?

Because that would be sneaky indeed.

Again : who knows ? 😄

Just kidding...

I believe Superman can take Hulk, but would be the most demanding match for superman ever.(including darkseid) However, Thor,Hulk, and the thing, well it sounds to me that whoever made this thread doesnt like superman and is determined to see him fail miserably.

I would take Superman over the Hulk any day, but since Hulk has already beaten Superman (and we've all grown tired of the "flying into space" thing) Hulk can have this fight.