I know I said I'm out of this... and I am lol. Just have to draw attention to the relatively recent findings of a registered independent charitable organisation.
Royal Society for Prevention of Accidents, May 2005
Higher Speeds Cause More Serious InjuriesImpacts at higher speeds are more severe than at lower speeds, and so they lead to more serious injuries to those involved. At 35mph a driver is twice as likely to kill someone as they are at 30mph.
The probability of serious injury to a person wearing a seat belt in a front seat at an impact speed of 30mph is three times greater than at 20mph. At 40mph it is over five times greater.
In collisions involving pedestrians and cars or car-derived vans, 85% of fatalities occurred at impact speeds below 40mph, 45% occurred at less than 30mph and 5% at speeds below 20mph.
About 40% of pedestrians who are struck at speeds below 20 mph sustain non-minor injuries. At speeds up to 30 mph 90% of pedestrians suffer non-minor injuries. Pedestrians hit at speeds below 30 mph receive mainly survivable injuries, but this changes to mainly fatal injuries at speeds of between about 30 and 40mph.
Hit by a car at 40mph, 9 out of 10 pedestrians will be killed
Hit by a car at 30mph, about half of pedestrians will be killed
Hit by a car at 20mph, 9 out of 10 pedestrians will survive.
Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Now a car moving below 45 mph is it going to do more damage than the one batman inflicted? No and besides batman punches or anyone’s for that matter are directed to a specific location. Now if the car is clocked in above 45mph the car should do a lot of damage.
To answer your question. Yes.
Originally posted by lifeisaglich
The collision of the car with the human is going to have greater momentum because of the transfer of force to the stationary human.
This is a bit mixed up. The collision of the car with a human is going to produce greater force because of the transfer of momentum to the stationary human. The transfer in momentum is greater because the car produces more momentum than Batman can ever hope to achieve because it travels faster than Batman and it weighs much more than Batman, momentum is equal to the speed of an object multiplied by the mass of an object. Change in momentum, impulse, in this case increase in momentum of the stationary body is equal to the force applied multiplied by the time.
Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Physics is not my strong point either but what you explained seems to be on the money but people have been hit by vehicles moving at 65 miles per hour and survive, (but the car is still dealing more damage than a human). Maximum Exposure: saw a person being slammed by a rally car at incredible speed but said person still survive granted with some broken bones and some other stuff, I would not wish on even my greatest enemy, (ok maybe I would) but the cars is still dealing more damage than a human. This is reality now lets go into the comic world batman went through a 3 ft tree where as a car would rap it self around the tree. Obliviously the car has more force but batman did more damage…
The person you saw was very lucky. I would simply refer you to the aforementioned statistics. I don't intend to and probably wouldn't be able to go into the complex physics of crumple zones in car engineering. The tree is an often vaunted but but largely singular incident. If a comic shows him running down the street punching down trees with little effort then I'll accept that Batman is always that strong.
Originally posted by lifeisaglich
And would just like to add one thing spiderman stands more of chance of wining their initial encounters
So you agree that Spider-Man wins. 😛 The initial encounters are all he would need.
Ok... I'm out of this... for real this time 😏
Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Yes batman’s punches are going to produce more damage. Batman is said to be one of the greatest martial artist alive. And his punches are going to be stronger than the ones produced by martial artist in the real world. And by the way batman’s punches should be to do more damage. Here’s my reasoning lets say batman strongest punch is clocked at 45mph and produces so and so damage. Now a car moving below 45 mph is it going to do more damage than the one batman inflicted? No and besides batman punches or anyone’s for that matter are directed to a specific location. Now if the car is clocked in above 45mph the car should do a lot of damage.
full post
Originally posted by xmarksthespot
To answer your question. Yes.
Cutting out pieces of my post and answering what suits you and not the whole post does not really do wonders for your reply. You simply can't beat comic logic...😆
This is a bit mixed up. The collision of the car with a human is going to produce greater force because of the transfer of momentum to the stationary human. The transfer in momentum is greater because the car produces more momentum than Batman can ever hope to achieve because it travels faster than Batman and it weighs much more than Batman, momentum is equal to the speed of an object multiplied by the mass of an object. Change in momentum, impulse, in this case increase in momentum of the stationary body is equal to the force applied multiplied by the time.
My friend it would seem that you did not go through my post, for I said that the car produces more momentum thus giving more force.
The person you saw was very lucky. I would simply refer you to the aforementioned statistics. I don't intend to and probably wouldn't be able to go into the complex physics of crumple zones in car engineering. The tree is an often vaunted but but largely singular incident. If a comic shows him running down the street punching down trees with little effort then I'll accept that Batman is always that strong.
Of course the person I saw was lucky 🙂 well too bad for you batman has gone through a 3 ft tree. Just because batman does not go around kicking down every tree that he sees does not mean he can not..same as just because batman does not kill the people that he fights does no mean he cannot...
So you agree that Spider-Man wins.😛 The initial encounters are all he would need.Ok... I'm out of this... for real this time
What ever rocks your boat 😆 so 😛 right back at cha
Originally posted by long pigThanks. This is a no prep fight, so Spidey beats Batman into a coma.
As an impartial and all-knowing judge of yorn comic vs forum, I shall caste yon vote of who would win yin majority.Batman loses in a straight up fight, but he overwhelmingly wins in a prep fight.
Originally posted by Batman WinsSlade is Batman's superior. Deathstroke > Batman. That was pretty lame reasoning anyway.
Slade and Batman are equal so Bats take s this