Captain America vs. Wolverine

Originally posted by Daredevil1
Yes he has said its razor sharp. Actually people have picked it up and hurt themselves as well as seen in Fallen son.

They cut themselves? Well if he said that and people have cut themselves then thats it.

Originally posted by Daredevil1

Besides people pick up razor sharp knives without cutting themselves it just depends on how you grab.

Thats true but not if you don't expect it to be sharp.

Originally posted by Daredevil1

Well do you have quotes that say its blunt in the books? Because I can give you quotes that say quite the opposite.

Im assuming that they are blunt because its a shield. Shields by default tend not to have sharp edges. If Caps weapon was a sword or an axe I would have assumed that it would have been sharp.

Just because he can cut through tough substances don't neccesarily make it sharp either, its just that the weapon is indestructible and he is very skilled.

Bump

logan ftw for all the reasons already posted in the last 133 pages.

Wolverine wins:

- better stamina
- more deadly
- and insane hf

Cap's only advantage is that he is a better fighter, but he's only a little better. He can't really put down logan.

Wolverine 9/10. His damage soak is simply to much.

Originally posted by Starscream M

Cap's only advantage is that he is a better fighter, but he's only a little better. He can't really put down logan.

Thats your opinion.

I highly doubt capt is more skilled then Logan at all. There equals in skill, though I wager Logan knows a good deal more styles of combat.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Thats your opinion.

I highly doubt capt is more skilled then Logan at all. There equals in skill, though I wager Logan knows a good deal more styles of combat.

fine, they might technically be equally skilled...but Capt is more tactical and smarter fighter. but as i said, he can't beat logan.

Originally posted by Starscream M
fine, they might technically be equally skilled...but Capt is more tactical and smarter fighter. but as i said, he can't beat logan.

again your opinion. Logan has shown to be just as tactically sound in one on one combat and just as smart. In one on one h2h fights instincts is much more important which Logan has in spades.

yea the HF factor what wins it for him pretty much every dam time in this match up.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
again your opinion. Logan has shown to be just as tactically sound in one on one combat and just as smart. In one on one h2h fights instincts is much more important which Logan has in spades.

cap's average showing is more tactical than logan

but that's not much of an advantage in this fight

Originally posted by Starscream M
logan's instincts are no better than cap's...unless you can prove otherwise

cap's average showing is more tactical than logan

but that's not much of an advantage in this fight

never said they were. it also kinda of a ahrd thing to prove or disprove to be honest.

not in one on one fights. and Logan uses his instincts far more in there showings.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
and Logan uses his instincts far more in there showings.

Originally posted by Starscream M
what do you mean instincts? how do you know he uses instincts more than cap?

better word might have been relies for both tactics and instincts. capt main rely on tactics more often then wolverine and wolverine in turn might rely on instincts more often then capt.

if logan had cap's hf, who do you think wins?

but in the end of he day Wolverine HF wins it for him almost every time. It kind of a bad match up and kinda stupid that it so long lol.

Originally posted by Starscream M
if logan had cap's hf, who do you think wins?

Originally posted by Battlehammer
depends does Logan know he has capt healing factor? also does he have time to get uses to it? h2h? with weapons? if so what weapons ect.

logan gets his claws and cap gets his shield

Originally posted by Starscream M
yes, he knows and gets used to it

logan gets his claws and cap gets his shield

Originally posted by Starscream M
if logan had cap's hf, who do you think wins?

if logan was aware that he lacked his HF he would not allow himself to take as many hits.

he has gone up against both omega red and lady D without a HF and lived to tell the tail. logan is more then capable of relying just on his martial skills to compensate for his lack of HF, his martial skills have bn shown to exceed anything cap has demonstrated from one hit kill strikes to the ninja disappearing trick.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
well thats kind of unfair, you do relies Logan would be losing a lot of blood from the wounds the claws makes

that would make it unfair...which is not my intent