Originally posted by Bentley
The sad truth is that Smoker is outclassed by Luffy in this time and age, he is not even Magellan level, let alone trouble to the whole SH crew by himself.
Indeed. But then again, Magellan level is possibly still better than Luffy(Magellan all but one-shot the Blackbeard pirates when he caught them off guard, which is pretty awesome). But yeah, Smoker has fallen from whatever little grace he had before. He doesn't seem to have gotten better at all.
Originally posted by Q99
Yea. Smoker was a big threat in part 1 and seemed improvement-focused, but he and Taishigi upgraded, like, half as much as the Strawhats did.
Well he wasn't a huge threat in part 1...mostly because he was never used. Alabasta was the only time that Tashigi and Smoker really played a role in the story, aside from the occassional glimpse at what they're doing and the role they played at Marineford(very little). But certainly better than Luffy.
Now though yeah, he and Tashigi show little improvement compared to the Straw Hats(though admittedly Tashigi has come a LONG way from being as crappy as she was in part 1). It's a shame they were the Worfs for Law, who was a near unknown really and didn't really show off anything that I can't imagine him doing in part 1.
Question: Why didn't Law ask Luffy about forming an Alliance before?