Master Chief vs Samus Aran

Started by General Kaliero144 pages

Sorry, dark, but the idea is the pit the two against each other as they are in thier games.

And Ryugen, great point, I'd not thought of that, but it's true.

Originally posted by dark1365
Read the damned Halo novels. He's human, alright. They only reason why they called him "cyborg" is that scientists grafted stuff in his body, like ceramic layering on his skeletal structure, and capilliary boost under his eyes.. Jeez, I'll send you a couple passages from The Fall of Reach if it takes that to convince you he's human.

Seriously....you're asking me to read a book about a video game. 🤨

Um, I'm still sticking with Master Cheif, as long as he's got a Fuel Rod Cannon, energy sword, and in a Ghost for the first half of the battle.

It really depends on the environment.But I still think Samus will.

If you're going to have Chief in a Ghost for half the battle, then Samus should have her ship for the same amount of time.

Originally posted by Linkalicious
Seriously....you're asking me to read a book about a video game. 🤨

That's right. And no, not all of them suck. Ask me more if you want to know which ones suck, which don't.
Actually, if you just want to me to type up a passage from the book, you won't have to read it.
I recommend Halo: First Strike. (Takes place after 1st game)

Originally posted by General Kaliero
Sorry, dark, but the idea is the pit the two against each other as they are in thier games.

That's half of it, very true... but the other half is pitting their own moral qualities, like discipline, training, reflexes, and stuff. Against each other.

And we haven't been doing that?

And I'd like to direct Master Chief supporters here

Originally posted by dark1365
Nope...put them both without armor, and with only a plasma pistol., nothin' else. Samus relies on technology so much, that she'll lose, easy.

i just wanna say before i post this that i dont really know that much about either character, i have not researched them or anything like that.

my opinions have been based upon what i have read in this thread, as its the place ive learent about both characters most, which leads me yp what you said dark. i have read a lot of people say that MC is a cyborg with a human brain, so when you say samus RELIES on technology, which is bad, doesnt this mean that masterchief IS technology? which would be worse, reliying(sp?) on technology or being technology?

i dont want this to be taken the wrong way like my last adding was 😮 and appologies if i got the wrong end of the stick!

Intresting point but I'm not sure. I'd like to say something in MC's favor because there is something he has that I'm fairly sure Samus doesn't...a sniper rifle. If MC could get into a good posistion he could just camp there and take out Samus with a high velocity bullet to the face. Close up and personal though I still say Samus'll come out on top.

Originally posted by ChickinMeat
i just wanna say before i post this that i dont really know that much about either character, i have not researched them or anything like that.

my opinions have been based upon what i have read in this thread, as its the place ive learent about both characters most, which leads me yp what you said dark. i have read a lot of people say that MC is a cyborg with a human brain, so when you say samus [b]RELIES on technology, which is bad, doesnt this mean that masterchief IS technology? which would be worse, reliying(sp?) on technology or being technology?

i dont want this to be taken the wrong way like my last adding was 😮 and appologies if i got the wrong end of the stick! [/B]


That's okay, Chikin. The reason I post that....MC isn't a cyborg witha human brain. He's a professionally-trained soldier-guy, with physical augmentations, and a high tech suit of armor. The bottom line is, he isn't technology, itself. Hell, don't you think that if Spartans WERE cyborgs and were manufactured, there would've been a helluva lot more Spartans to help out in the second Halo.

Well, Samus doesn't have a sniper rifle, but with lock-on Super Missiles, would she need one? And the far too overpowered Space Pirate cannon that you can use in one of the multiplayer maps is definitely fun and efficient (two blasts will kill anyone).

Originally posted by dark1365
Nope...put them both without armor, and with only a plasma pistol., nothin' else. Samus relies on technology so much, that she'll lose, easy.
.... both of them without armor? do you realise that armor is 50% of thier arsenal? in any case, if you've seen samus by using the justin bailey code for NES, you'd know she's just as agile w/o armor on.. I cant say the same for chief.... and why would samus want to use a plasma pistol of the halo world?.. her beam cannon would slaughter a silly halo weapon.

Not to mention a silly halo hero. 😗

Originally posted by SaTsuJiN
.... both of them without armor? do you realise that armor is 50% of thier arsenal? in any case, if you've seen samus by using the justin bailey code for NES, you'd know she's just as agile w/o armor on.. I cant say the same for chief.... and why would samus want to use a plasma pistol of the halo world?.. her beam cannon would slaughter a silly halo weapon.

So, look at the MC, who has to make do with normal guns, and the occasional plasma weapon. Samus has her own fancy schmancy armor, plus stupid auto-aim(yes it is, in fact, in Metroid Prime, i checked), PLUS all these suit types, plus all these beam types. She gets it real easy. Her powers seem cartoonish, even (yes i've said this before).
In all, I think that MC would still win, despite the fact that I've played three Metroids(Prime, Fusion, Zero Mission), and still like Samus.
'nuff said.

Prime is really not a good game to judge the Metroid series by. If you want a fair assestment of Metroid, try Super Metroid.

Again, auto-aim is irrelevant to this discussion.

And as far as how Samus has more than MC and that somehow makes it "easier" for her, so what? Look at it this way: If someone is coming at YOU with a 16th-century revolver, and you have to choose between a like revolver or a machine gun, which are you going to choose? If I were to apply your thinking to that situation, then you would be not as good because you had a better weapon.

Since when is using the best available to you a sign of weakness? Seems more like a sign of intelligence, to me.

I don't know about this one. Master Chief is definetly way cooler cause he's a badass, and I'm not saying Samus isn't, it's just that Master Chief is, well, cooler. dj

Samus, though, has all that high-tech weaponry.

But then again, Master Chief has some good weapons, too.

But then again, it depends on what's open to them.

But then again, it depends on where they're at.

But then again, I don't know why I keep saying but then again.

Overall, even though I think Master Chief is cooler and the Halo games are better, I'm going to have to vote for Samus on this one.

See, the problem I see here is that Chief supporters keep saying that Chief is "cooler," but I have yet to read any actual REASONS why they think so.

"Master Chief is cooler because... well, he just is."

I could easily say, "Master Chief is really C-3PO because... well, he just is."

Both assertions are equally illogical, because neither offers PROOF.

Some correct logical assertions:

Samus is cooler because she's infuzed with Chozo blood.

Samus is cooler because she's got ultra-high-tech advanced weaponry, all in a compact little arm cannon that reloads instantly, and usually doesn't need ammo.

Samus is cooler because she's a bounty hunter, and all bounty hunters are cool.

(Yes, this is a correct logical assertion. For the speaker, part B (about all bounty hunters being cool) is taken as fact, and the fact in B instantly proves part A to be fact as well.)

You see? If you want to say Chief is cooler, please give some ABSOLUTE reasons why. Otherwise, you just look like a fool.

masterchief is cool, because hes green

but then samus is orange, and thats pretty cool

😛

Hey! NOT very one is sexist ya know!

It's just that Halo 1 and 2 rules, Master Chief rules!

Also in Halo 2 there's Arbiter (The rejected Covnant dude).