Are American troops undisciplined thugs dressed as soldiers?

Started by Linkalicious29 pages

Lil, you didn't make the comment I accused you of...

It was Mr. Zero who had made a comment that spoke for the American public...well more as it's point of view.

All you did was say that it was "the truth"

I'm out people. Arguing is starting my weekend out on the wrong foot. Have a good weekend everyone!

Originally posted by Linkalicious
Lil, you didn't make the comment I accused you of...
It was Mr. Zero who had made a comment that spoke for the American public...well more as it's point of view.
All you did was say that it was "the truth"

fully agreed. im sorry lil b.
i gaev zero plenty of opportunity to correct himself, and
take back his hateful words...and even went so far as to apologise
for my own words which were not prejudice or hateful, only overgeneralised,
partly as an example, and partly because i want people who oppose my view
to understand what i say, not feel belittled.

but he chose to spit insult after insult at me and you chose to cheer in support.
does that make me 'clueless'? why was i not clueless in other threads when we were in agreement.

if i make any false assumptions, please let me know.
but zero said america deserves another 9/11, and you called it "the truth".
i take that as a colossal insult.

you can help him disguise his own words if you will, but the truth is the truth.
i showed his quote to 8 other people at work and they all feel the same.

now i have to hear zero say "let it go", yet he gets to parade my words from page 1 around when i have already taken them back. this thread is ass backwards, and people need to have respect for others.

"but zero said america deserves another 9/11, and you called it "the truth".
i take that as a colossal insult."

Where did he say this? I really can't picture him saying that another 3000 innocent people deserve to die because of some wacko's illogical problems with the way we this country is run. If he did actually say this, then it was probably just for shock value seeing as it's blatantly wrong, simple as that.

Originally posted by Mr Zero
I am now SERIOUSLY out of this thread - my disgust has got the better of me. You chaps win. I give up.

American soldiers are the best in the world, anyone & everyone they kill is guilty, and god help you all for wondering why the East hates you enough to kill you in cold blood as you stare out your skyscraper windows.

Idiots.

here is his post in its entirety

I don't see where he said America deserves another 9/11? He just made a reference too it that was admittedly in bad taste.

I doubt it was his intent to insinuate that what happened on 9/11 was acceptable, let alone endorsed and should happen again. Probably just said for shock value and to offend people who would be offended by it.

Everyone with a brain knows that we don't deserve another 9/11, nor does any other country deserve an attack that consciously kills 3000 innocent people out of blind hatred and cold blood. Anyone who does actually think that we deserve another terrorist attack like what happened on 9/11 is simply stupid and not worth listening too.

and even tho VPL seems incapable of comprehending it: Here is the less easy-reader version of what i was trying to convey: posted pages and pages ago to try to comfort him

"All other political considerations aside, I don’t think that saying "the enemy does worse" is any kind of excuse for undisciplined behaviour, rules of engagement are clear - and any soldier that deviates from the orders they are given needs to be dealt with. Firstly because that’s how the army functions, but mostly because how the forces are perceived is what the entire nation is going to base it's opinion of americans on. You allow war crimes to go uninvestigated & unpunished you not only become the thing you fight - you give your enemy the ammunition to paint you as evil. You doom a new generation to grow up hating Americans. The exact thing that caused 9-11 in the first place, that’s my point: NEXT time (and its coming) you wont be able to say "why do they hate us so much?"

"American soldiers are the best in the world, anyone & everyone they kill is guilty"----sarcasm of coarse

"and god help you all for wondering why the East hates you enough to kill you in cold blood as you stare out your skyscraper windows."

GOD HELP YOU ALL

so, perhaps you're correct and he is just being a willing d!ck,
although he could have been more than a child and correct himself.

but then i read others say that he's 'right'? wtf?

Originally posted by Mr Zero
and even tho VPL seems incapable of comprehending it: Here is the less easy-reader version of what i was trying to convey: posted pages and pages ago to try to comfort him

"All other political considerations aside, I don’t think that saying "the enemy does worse" is any kind of excuse for undisciplined behaviour, rules of engagement are clear - and any soldier that deviates from the orders they are given needs to be dealt with. Firstly because that’s how the army functions, but mostly because how the forces are perceived is what the entire nation is going to base it's opinion of americans on. You allow war crimes to go uninvestigated & unpunished you not only become the thing you fight - you give your enemy the ammunition to paint you as evil. You doom a new generation to grow up hating Americans. The exact thing that caused 9-11 in the first place, that’s my point: NEXT time (and its coming) you wont be able to say "why do they hate us so much?"

who is YOU genius? ME?? I LET THIS SHIT HAPPEN?

and wahat of tony blair? so YOU let it all happen too, right?

or are you an exception?

Because it IS important to understand why these shit heads hate us so much, I think that's what people were agreeing with this. No one in their right mind would agree with something that condoned 3000 innocent people dying.

Once we understand why they hate us so much then maybe we can use that to figure out how to stop another terrorist attack that takes the lives of 3000 innocent people that had nothing to do with whatever problem these sacks of shit have with us.

The more Iraqis are aware of American soldiers being abusive and failing to follow their own laws, much less international laws, the less likely they are to help either the Americans or any government that America supports. Abusive American soldiers are, in the long run, a detriment to American political goals. Second, allowing even small acts of abuse to go unpunished has a negative impact on discipline overall. When people know that smaller rules can be broken at will, it's a lot easier to cross the line and break larger ones, especially in matters such as this. A lack of discipline will led to soldiers committing war crimes.

Originally posted by PVS
who is YOU genius? ME?? I LET THIS SHIT HAPPEN?

and wahat of tony blair? so YOU let it all happen too, right?

or are you an exception?

If you are going to insist on talking about this - try to use sentences and make some effort to be clear. I'm doing you a favour by indulging this insane rant of yours, could you at least do me the favour of trying to make sense.

Originally posted by Mr Zero
you give your enemy the ammunition to paint you as evil. You doom a new generation to grow up hating Americans. The exact thing that caused 9-11 in the first place, that’s my point: NEXT time (and its coming) you wont be able to say "why do they hate us so much?"

way to clarify your hate and ignorance.

i want everyone to read this and understand.
this is prejudice against ALL americans, as if every american
is responsible for the decisions of the government.

how can that not be translated as 'we deserve to die'

Originally posted by BackFire
Because it IS important to understand why these shit heads hate us so much, I think that's what people were agreeing with this. No one in their right mind would agree with something that condoned 3000 innocent people dying.

backfire, i understand what you say. but does zero?

i detect much anti american hating in his posts, and little rational

Originally posted by PVS
way to clarify your hate and ignorance.

i want everyone to read this and understand.
this is prejudice against ALL americans, as if every american
is responsible for the decisions of the government.

how can that not be translated as 'we deserve to die'

PVS, whats said in that paragraph is the truth. It is painfully true. Noone is saying ''you deserve to die'' what it is saying is that there are REASONS for the hate Middle East especially has for America. And until certain Americans released this - you're never gonna move away from where you are now.

Originally posted by Mr Zero
If you are going to insist on talking about this - try to use sentences and make some effort to be clear. I'm doing you a favour by indulging this insane rant of yours, could you at least do me the favour of trying to make sense.

what i meant was, who is the "YOU" that you refer to? as in "you let this happen" and "you let that happen"...seems to be that you are saying its ME,
and the guy sitting 1 desk over from me, and every other american...if i am mistaken, please correct me.

After 9-11 how anyone can blame our troops, Did the Iraqui people had any remorse about blowing the Twin Towers, No, Hijacking and killing all those people in those plane and now beheading hostages hiding what the americans did as an excuse, no, they have no remorse and im glad im not in that war because i probably wouldve been with the arrested americans since i would shoot anything that moves, Do you think if given the chance the wouldnt do another 9/11 on us?, frankly they are a threat that needs to be handle by any means necesarry

Originally posted by Darth Vicious
After 9-11 how anyone can blame our troops, Did the Iraqui people had any remorse about blowing the Twin Towers, No, Hijacking and killing all those people in those plane and now beheading hostages hiding what the americans did as an excuse, no, they have no remorse and im glad im not in that war because i probably wouldve been with the arrested americans since i would shoot anything that moves, Do you think if given the chance the wouldnt do another 9/11 on us?, frankly they are a threat that needs to be handle by any means necesarry

Dude, Iraq had NOTHING to do with 9/11, therefore your whole post is just....wrong.

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
PVS, whats said in that paragraph is the truth. It is painfully true. Noone is saying ''you deserve to die'' what it is saying is that there are REASONS for the hate Middle East especially has for America. And until certain Americans released this - you're never gonna move away from where you are now.

ok lil b. what about tony blair?
does that give me the right to insult and condiscend all
britains on the 'painful truth'?

how the hell did you two get on the other side of the fence?
check your drivers license, what country do you live in?
U.K.? guess you need to move away from where you are as well.

Originally posted by PVS
as if every american
is responsible for the decisions of the government.

Exactly my point. When you have an army (some of whom are) committing atrocities, and at home a majority of the press and populace that says "Hey dont bad-mouth the troops" and scorn is poured on anyone who raises any concerns about freedom of speech - the perception is going to be either that all, or the vast majority of americans feel that way. Hence they are all responsible, hence all guilty.

If you dont listen to dissent, you will never understand why America is perceived the way it is.

address my last post zero, for the fifth time