Best fencer

who is the best with a lightsaber? I think Sidious. From what we've seen and heard he's ambidextrous and conserves movement well.

These are based on available info and my own observations (I do European fencing and Kenjitsu)

shit, let me repost this with a poll

that is wrong, so wrong.

We had a best fencer thread already, and I was under the impression that Dooku or Sidious took the W

mace he s saber iz amazing

hmmm, only form the movies or EU?

movies sidious(he is better then dooku i presume, cuz yoda was better then doku, and sidious defeated yoda

EU it would be Tulak Hord(best sith duelist ever)

Dooku probably has the cleanest, most precise form, though Sidious is amazingly Vaapad like in his movements. But for EU, I would have to vote Tulak Hord, with Exar Kun in second, perhaps.

Excellent choices my friend. I agree Dooku is the most refined fencer of the movies.

Well, Sidious I think is the best sword fighter but Dooku takes the fencing victory.

There needs to be more information on Jedi fighting techniques. I am not satisfied with a few movie battles. Who's with me on this one?

in the movies, yes.

We need to get a bunch of people together, and have them contact Lucas, the game creators, and the novelists and have them make a list of the best at what etc. etc.

It would be extremely hard to pull off but if we could, we'd finally know who is the best with what weapons, styles, powers etc.

That's a great idea.

notice that none of the Jedi actually fence, they use other sword fighting techniques. Dooku was supposed to fence in the movies but was unable to.

Fencing is a bit awkward to use as is any real swordfighting style. I mean, the whole blade, all sides, is potentially dangerous. If anything, it's a lot easier to use since you aren't concerned with one or two edges hitting the opponent.

Originally posted by Darth_Nefarus
We need to get a bunch of people together, and have them contact Lucas, the game creators, and the novelists and have them make a list of the best at what etc. etc.

It would be extremely hard to pull off but if we could, we'd finally know who is the best with what weapons, styles, powers etc.

That would be awesome

1 Yoda
2. Darth Tyranus
3. Mace Windu
4. Darth Sidious
5. Darth Maul

From waht we'v seen in the movies.

id say Luke skywaler and mace wundu

Luke and Mace from EU but w/ straight movies I'd have to go w/ my list.

Bane (potentially), Yoda, Kas'im or Luke.