Book Six : Harry Potter And The Half Blood Prince [merged]

Yea.. i do think that dumbledore will die coz he's close to harry an' an important character, n i do reckon dat petunia is hidin' summat.
I dont think that sirius will return as a dementor coz dat's just stupid.. dementors have now joined Voldemort, sirius died because he fought against the death eaters.. If he becomes evil, his death would be in vain. But he cant just disappear from the boks all togther coz he was 2 important, maybe he returns by sum other method??

Still for the dementors idea. It isn't really stupid. People, remember. He goes through, he has no choice to follow the other dementors and join Voldemort if he has to.

Maybe Fawkes heals Sirius back from the dead... who knows lol Personally, I think Sirius is a goner. He was a supporting character, not really a main character. He made two appearances - books three and five and brief appearances in book 4. He's really not that major I don't think!

He isn't coming back alive. I still see him coming back as a dementor because he isn't alive or dead then. Look at earlier pages to see supporting info.

theres always something happy that happens to harry in each book. so probably he will get to play again....Somehow

Originally posted by mentalbug
theres always something happy that happens to harry in each book. so probably he will get to play again....Somehow

Wha?

Originally posted by mentalbug
theres always something happy that happens to harry in each book. so probably he will get to play again....Somehow

play again? say what? 😕

I think sirius was just as important a character as hermione or ron, just coz he weren't in it a lot dont mean he aint important!!

Very true, Sarah.

he will be coming back JK has said this...in what shape or form we'll have to find out and see but he will return!! yay!

^^^ no she didnt... show me where... becuase she definatley did not say he was coming back... and him becoming a dementor? .... no.... thats stupid

Yeah I don't think sirius is going to be a dementor. However I am really curious about what that veil is all about, it's so mysterious and weird, it makes death seem a little ambiguious...

ok well iv shown it before so ill find it again.....

1) Q why did you kill Sirius? It made me very sad
A I'm really, really sorry. I didn't want to do it, but there was a reason. If you think you can forgive me, keep reading, you'll find out. [i feel really guilty now].

2) Q If we ever see Sirius again, what form will he be in?
A I couldn't possibly answer that for fear of incriminating myself.
Hope that kinda helps! although feel free to disagree...

and if you wish to check up on that you'll find it on the Leaky Cauldrons 'Everything There is to Know About Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (If You're Not J.K. Rowling)', i interpret this as him coming back so..make of it what you want

Well, maybe we wont see him at all. Who knows. How much longer till the book comes out?

34 days!! wahooo! 😱

Can't wait... most get......

Originally posted by air
1) Q why did you kill Sirius? It made me very sad
A I'm really, really sorry. I didn't want to do it, but there was a reason. If you think you can forgive me, keep reading, you'll find out. [i feel really guilty now].

2) Q If we ever see Sirius again, what form will he be in?
A I couldn't possibly answer that for fear of incriminating myself.
Hope that kinda helps! although feel free to disagree...

and if you wish to check up on that you'll find it on the Leaky Cauldrons 'Everything There is to Know About Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (If You're Not J.K. Rowling)', i interpret this as him coming back so..make of it what you want

the first question she said you would find the out the reason why he was killed

the second... she said nothing

perhaps, yet it still leavs it open to suggestion and in my personal opinion he will make a return, you of course can think what you wish...

cant wait for it tbh 🙂