Book Six : Harry Potter And The Half Blood Prince [merged]

Originally posted by Secosera_TD
JK already said in a FAQ that Mark has nothing to do with the HBP, and that over in England Evans is a common last name, so Mark Evans is out officially, leaving Tom or Hagrid, among a few others

I don't think it does. I just checked it.

*gives lianslo a cookie 🙂 *

i was just thinking, I know luna is a girl, but do we know if her mother was a witch?

^Yeah, it said that her mom liked to experiment spells on herself, and one time it went too far....

yes! i luv cookies! 🙂 *starts munching on the cookie*

in all honesty guys...i think we've gotta keep brainstorming...i don't know about the rest of you, but as much as i'd like to believe some of these theories, none of them quite seem to click...i thought Mark Evans was our closest bet, but evidentally that idea was shot down by JK herself...(if you don't know where it is on her site, you have to visit the FAQ poll section)

Originally posted by weegie
Is lupin a half blood? I really cant remember, how about lockheart?
I still think my theory about lockheart saying that he stopped a werewolf being a werewolf might be something about the small thing in book 2.

but what i remember is that lockheart is out of his mind and is a patient in a wizard's hospital.. if u have read OotP

And lockhart didnt really do all those things, he just modified memories of others who did and published it under his name

I think Scar has a point about the werewolf thing?

* Congrats to Scar!*

go scar

Lupin is supposed to have big role in book seven too!

😱 😱

yay LUpin rocks 🤘 🤘

So, do we have any new ideas about who the hbp is?

it should be voldomort....there is noone is who is half-blood...except for harry but then it wouldnt make sense...unless there is a new character added in the book.

don't keep mark evans out of the listing. JK isn't going to tell us EVERYTHING!

Especially if Mark Evans is the huge new character that will be introduced...she wouldn't just GIVE IT AWAY....I wouldn't. She wants to throw us all off track!

Originally posted by ladygrim
yay LUpin rocks 🤘 🤘

you wouldn't want 'to meet him in the moonlight' 🤘

JK has said that she wont lie to us on her website that everything on there is true and she said that MARK EVANS WAS NOBODY THEREFORE MARK EVANS IS NOBODY

yeah...as good as the mark evan idea sounds, i don't think JK would lie to us on her website...and does anybody know how much truth there is to the rumor of HBP being out in 4 or 5 months?

4 or 5 months? 😑
i think it will take almost a year...

If Mark Evans was to be significant, JKR simply wouldn't comment on the matter! We know what she is like! But she has therefore i honestly dont think we should be wasting our efforts on him xx

I just finished re-reading the CoS (I'm re-reading all the 5 books before HBP comes out), this time I paid more attention to who can possibly be the HBP so the only two that make any sense are Justin and Colin , both of them were petrified , and both of them had a small role, but still a role ?!\\

So we have a list now as follows:

Rubeus Hagrid
Mark Evans
Remus Lupin
Colin Creevey
Justin