Well if we want to talk about inconsistant writing than that peter parker comic is definitely a great example. Not only did spiderman win via sabretooth pulling the webbing of his face, and some of his face with it, but two months later, sabretooth not only had not recovered (still had stitches to boot), but then got his ass served to him by the black cat. WTF? I mean really, the guy layed out rogue in three blows, KOed her, and then in wolverine 126 his face healed in three panals after a similary devestating blow (as the spidey webs) from wolvies claws.
I don't think sabretooth is peak human, as it's been pointed out he's tossed cars into the air, he kicked rogues ass with physical force, he's uppercutted wolverine 3 stories into the air, and he's crumpled a curling bar into an iron shotput, and was killing killpower who's at herc level stength and has superhuman agility himself.
Now he's sporting adamantium.
He's definitely dangerous enough to put the hurt on spiderman in a bad way, he's blindingly fast (faster than wolverine, who's surprised spidey with his speed) and can take anything spiderman dishes out to him.
I cuncur, it all comes down to the webbing, sabretooth can shred it, pull it off, etc. but if he's bound in an uncomprimising position, it's all over. In a straight up brawl, I think, he's kicked spiderman's ass, but if spiderman has to resort to webbing him up completely, it's all over.
BTW.
in most of their showing's wolverine's been beaten by sabretooth, for a long long time (back in the day) sabretooth beat wolverine in every one of their encounters, Wolverine's gotten better since then and has been able to dice sabretooth up a few times since, but when it boils down to it, most of their encounters end up like it did in "the native" storyline with sabes standing victorious.
After making a fur coat out of the wendigo, I wouldn't be surprised to see sabretooth beating anyone below hulk-like levels anymore.