I think it has.
In a Space Battle, Han. He's a better pilot.
Shoot-out, I'm not sure. Han is REALLY lucky, more so than Obi-wan. He's taken some tough cookies before. I think Han has this.
And Janus. I agree. I don't know why everyone hates him. He was annoying at first, but then I got to like him better further in.
Han is a better pilot? Where did you get that.
Carth Onasi is a decorated war hero, who saw more combat then anybody else in the Endar Spire. Which was a war ship, carrying Bastila. So it would have to have some pretty good soldiers on it. AFter all with Bastila her importance... It would be foolish not to have good soldiers there.
Carth would know damn well how to fly... I don't think Han stands a chance against him. No matter how good he is. At least not in space. On the ground I seriously doubt it because Carth probably just had better training. But this one is tough, seeing as all we know from Carth on the ground is that he couldn't hit Malak at point blank range, the rest is all gameplay experience.
Well, Carth was a professional soldier before he became a pilot and officer in the Mandalorian Wars. He was the ranking officer on the Endor Spire, and had balls to stick around until he had no other choice but to escape.
On a sidenote, how did Bandon escape the ship before it blew up I wonder...
Anyways, Han Solo was originally a thief and a very good pilot. He enrolled in the Imperial Naval academy but was drummed out for saving Chewbacca's life. He had a multitude of smuggling and battle experience beyond this point. I can't say he's fought a large scale war (The Battle of Nar Shadaa wasn't quite like the Mandalorian slaughterfest) but I wouldn't neccessarily say he's worse than Carth; he may even be better. Personally, I think Atton is a far better pilot than both, but he is also Force sensitive, and we know from Annie in TPM that Force Sensitivity can make a human an amazing pilot.
Ground battle? Carth. Carth is naturally ambidextrous and has an Arkanian heavy blaster modified with his own specs and even his family crest. Carth also wears a padded coat and suit which may be modified for light combat, but don't quote me on that one; it's just a possibility and really doesn't do much for this fight.
More or less it's a gut feeling. Neither of these guys is a lightweight, but on the ground Carth impresses me more. In space Carth has more war and tactical experience but Han has equal or perhaps even greater solo flying experience.
Sorry about diggin up an old thread, but I was reading a book that may actually make Han the better of the two. It seems Han actually has a form of precognition. This could be how he escaped so many bounty hunters over the years and was able to fly so well. This might just give him the edge over Carth IMO.