Perhaps Mags can choose to make his shield either airtight or not. This would explain how he is able to go into space and how on earth the air *might* get sucked out. It most likely was PIS but it may just be the type of field Mags uses.
A better fight would be Electric Superman vs Magneto, but superman is nigh invulnerable and it would take more firepower to kill Superman than Magneto has IMO. Superman takes a lot of damage and keeps going, I mean it would take sizable nukes to even being to hurt Superman. What is Magneto going to do?
Here is one way the fight can go. Supes can do this like I already posted.
http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c379/Doggydogg/Supermanvortexin.jpg
And this is what will happen except for Mags won't have the luxury of being able to hit Supes while he is vortexin'
Reversing the poles of the earth is a dubious feat. I mean what exactly about that act could be used in a fight? In fact the poles of the earth switch every couple of millions of years on their own and life on the earth doesn't end. I just have never seen a combat feat from Magneto that would put Superman down. Imagine Magneto trying to hold up his shield with superman flying around him at near light speed hitting the shield with at least thousands of mountain-shattering blows every second or just letting lose with his heat vision. IMO magneto would give out before Superman
Originally posted by jasofisc
yeah storm did it one time because of PIS, I say PIS because mags can with stand the vacum of space and haveing energy beams on all side but he can't stand a tornato, he would just need to completely close off his field.
Ok... let's give MAGS the benefit of the doubt that he can keep his air from getting sucked out of his field. Eventually (and quickly I might add) he will need a fresh supply of air. He'll give up before that happens.
Also, Supes can freeze him in a glazier that is miles long around him nearly instantly, and quickly toss him into the sun.
Magnetism also has a lot to do with positioning, Supes moves at very least 10,000 times than Mags can even think. There is no chance for Mags to do anything.
Supes can still cook Mags within his own forcefield. Mags can only keep it up for so long.
Originally posted by jasofisc
if he had enough power to reverse the poles isn't it consivable that he could throw the moon at him or an astorde. Now I know that Godsuperman could break it but normal would be hurt pretty bad.
Far out of Mags league, but lets suppose that Mags could... Supes has been in planetary explosions. All mags would end up doing is killing himself in the process.
supes surviving a plantary explostion is such crap. I know it's happened, but serously if he has that kind of power and doomsdays punches hurt him, then the impact of those punches should level a city. superman is one of the most inconsistant guys around. If he can lift billions of tons any punch he would give that was all out would kill every body with in the town or possibly state he's in. However I think your right about megneto not being able to do what I said I only remember him boasting about it. but a plantary explosion should kill him. It makes him a horrible character when he survives with out being hurt super novas it only shows that the writer has no idea how power full such things are. I think supes takes this 3 out of 10 times and possibley 5 out of 10.
Originally posted by jasofisc
supes surviving a plantary explostion is such crap. I know it's happened, but serously if he has that kind of power and doomsdays punches hurt him, then the impact of those punches should level a city. superman is one of the most inconsistant guys around. If he can lift billions of tons any punch he would give that was all out would kill every body with in the town or possibly state he's in. However I think your right about megneto not being able to do what I said I only remember him boasting about it. but a plantary explosion should kill him. It makes him a horrible character when he survives with out being hurt super novas it only shows that the writer has no idea how power full such things are. I think supes takes this 3 out of 10 times and possibley 5 out of 10.
😂 you like the Xmen 😉 thats cool - Supes moves faster than Magneto can even think. Speedblitz game over.
- end
Originally posted by jasofisc
I like supes also just not when he is shown to be more powerful then galactus. I think it makes him look stupid. As for the speed blitzing thing what about mags automatic sheild IF supes couldn't pentrate it he would get crused by his own momentum.
His speedblitz is faster than the auto shields I've seen Mags helmet removed so many times by people much slower than Supes. Supes has hit a number of things he could not break through, he is so hard he bounces, no crushed Supes yet. You are thinking of Apollo. 😉
I don't know who apollo is so probley not. I think if his auto shields are written right supes would have a hard time taging. But supes could do that I guess. If magneto was the agreesor then mags would be able to get his shield up. If not then I could see supes geting to mags even before he could get up a powerfull enough sheild.
Let's assume that Superman doesn't go for the speedblitz and lets Magneto get his sheild up. Then we would have Magneto on the defensive and Superman on a constant offensive. Even if Magneto's sheild could offer him protection from Superman's attack, given enough time Magneto should tire from the considerable strain of keeping up a strong enough sheild to stop Superman. Being essentially human, Magneto would tire before Superman and as soon as the sheild is down, the fight is over.
tsk tsk. I go away for awhile and suddenly people think Superman can beat Magneto? What's going on here?
Magneto has control over the fundamental elements that power Superman. He doesn't NEED to create enough physical power to KO Superman. He simply needs to put up his forcefield, which was powerful enough to hold back GALACTUS and PHOENIX and has never been broken, and drain away Superman's solar energy. When Superman is weak and vulnerable enough, like he was against an insane Dr. Polaris, THEN Magneto can KO Superman.
Magneto takes 7/10.
I think a lot of people are forgetting that we're using CURRENT Magneto. Old school Magneto has SMvsFL showings on par with Pre-Crisis sillyness (part of the problem of the Marvel Universe not having a "crisis"-type event to delinniate the difference between new and old tales is a lot of old and incredibly cheesy feats get thrown in for good measure) there is no modern writer who would put Magneto in the same class as Galactus on any scale (unless Galactus is jobbing).
Modern and CURRENT Magneto is completely incapable of flipping the magnetic poles without help from Kick, Cortez, or some similar power boost. Note that MOST of Magneto's recent power-feats have been executed under the influence of a power booster.
CURRENT Magneto is much weaker than his old-school demigod- pure-blooded evil-doer version... modern day Magneto has been depowered to be sympathetic sometimes/almost hero; much like Juggernaut.
Regardless, if we're talking about an all out bloodlusted battle, it's a simple Speed Blitz. If, for whatever reason, Magneto has his shield up, then it's a question of scope and endurance. Magneto's abilities, unenhanced, have a limited range much shorter than Superman's, leaving him to harass Magneto until he succumbs.
