No, he could still be created from her memory, he was still in there and so it used him
I was a little dissapointed with how weak they made that dalek seem
Spoiler:
River asking to say mercy really made me feel like the dalek was weak, Davros and the daleks have always seemed to be proud of having no emotions, no emotions means no fear and that dalek asking for mercy meant it felt fear
Originally posted by Samurai100
It was only awakened by him being there which he could not have been as he was never born
Except there were memories, because as was made clear there are still trace memories of the people erased. He did specify that.
And Amy being crack-girl seemed to be able to do that very well.
It's better in one thread. Frankly, having your own section actually kills a subject unless there is a phenomenal amount to talk about, which there is not. All the spam and ridiculous topics that come up eventually kill anyone's interest in talking about it all. I maintain this happened to Trek.
We're good with our popular thread here.