Official Doctor Who Thread

Started by Samurai100181 pages

Favourite Doctor list

1.Paul Mcgann
2.David Tennant
3.Jon Pertwee
4.Peter Davison
5.Tom Baker
6.Silvester Mccoy
7.Patrick Troughton
8.William Hartnell
9.Christopher Ecclestone
10.Colin Baker
11.Matt Smith

New Series Companion list
1.Donna
2.Martha
3.Amy, Rose

Man, THinking that I am going to have to wait till Christmas for new Who is depressing.
I want some Torchwood or something else to tide me over.
I don't know about you but this season felt really short.

Next Who moment is a little closer than that, as The Doc is turning up in an episode of Sarah Jane Adventures, written by RTD (immediately breaking his promise that he'd never write for Matt Smith) and also featuring the return of former companion Jo Grant.

What with SJA already having had the Brigadier back, it looks like that is where they go crazy on the continuity.

Originally posted by The Nuul
Matt is the 2nd best to play the Doctor. I didnt like Christopher Eccleston at all.

To be honest, I adored Eccleston. Not only was he my first Doctor, but he had some fantastic moments and really made for an ideal character. He could be sweet and fun, but always had a sense of pain and anger.
It's sad that his career has died down so quickly.

David Tennant was obviously incredible, and is generally the only good part of the dreadful fourth season. His presence and sense of fun and wonder really pulled me in.

Matt Smith is extremely good in my opinion. Sure, there were some odd moments with him, but he's just started. In general, he was great as a light-hearted but semi-bipolar/egocentric hero that wants nothing but peace for the universe, despite being out of touch with his social abilities.

Originally posted by Koenig
Just seen the final two part story and it was not so much of a big bang more like a whimper, looks like the recession has hit the Dr Who budget.

Or was it a deliberate low key story? After all the big slam bang thank you mam stories of the past, any how it was alright.

I f'in LOVED the first part, but the second part felt extremely disappointing and anti-epic.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Next Who moment is a little closer than that, as The Doc is turning up in an episode of Sarah Jane Adventures, written by RTD (immediately breaking his promise that he'd never write for Matt Smith) and also featuring the return of former companion Jo Grant.

What with SJA already having had the Brigadier back, it looks like that is where they go crazy on the continuity.


I never really liked SJA enough to watch it with any sort of regularity.

Originally posted by Tptmanno1
I never really liked SJA enough to watch it with any sort of regularity.

Me neither, but it's a cool little program to watch once in a while. The villains aren't very threatening or dangerous, but I'd refer it to my little cousin.

I got a cool Dalek poster the other day.

Originally posted by Mr. Rhythmic
To be honest, I adored Eccleston. Not only was he my first Doctor, but he had some fantastic moments and really made for an ideal character. He could be sweet and fun, but always had a sense of pain and anger.
It's sad that his career has died down so quickly.

David Tennant was obviously incredible, and is generally the only good part of the dreadful fourth season. His presence and sense of fun and wonder really pulled me in.

Matt Smith is extremely good in my opinion. Sure, there were some odd moments with him, but he's just started. In general, he was great as a light-hearted but semi-bipolar/egocentric hero that wants nothing but peace for the universe, despite being out of touch with his social abilities.


Matt Smith for me acted alltogether too quirky and didnt really have enough depth

Originally posted by Samurai100
Matt Smith for me acted alltogether too quirky and didnt really have enough depth

I am starting to get at that also.

Tenants performance on the other hand actually showed him being believiablly sad

Yeah but Tennant was mediocre in the comedic moments and went too far over the top that it was cringeworthy.

Matt Smith got it just right for that.

As for SJA, fantastic programme for children especially. Need to do more childrens' programmes like this. Full of mostly rubbish the world of childrens television.

yeah just look at postman pat

Postman Pat use to be fantastic years and years ago, now it's changed and rubbish. 😛

Tennent sucked,and I hate what he and RTD did to my fave tv show.


blowup

What did you think of the Moffatt/Smith series?

Like it pretty much for the most part.

Especially the part that wiped the majority of Tennant/RTD more (Censored for content cause I aint sure of the flow of this place yet) GARBAGE from existence.

Hooray for the crack in time!

Don't like the new Daleks.

To rainbow-ee and chunky.

Originally posted by MildPossession
Postman Pat use to be fantastic years and years ago, now it's changed and rubbish. 😛

they just had to bring in that Stupid helicopter

The crack didn't wipe the majority of RTD's time. In fact, the only bit that it has even been speculated by the Doc as being erased was the Cyber King.